So, I'm setting my Barbara IV up as counterbalance for the first time ever.   Up to now, I've always used it in jack loom mode.   And to be honest, I've never seen a counterbalance or countermarch except in pictures.   Several texts, etc., describe counterbalance as sinking shed, jack as raising shed, and countermarch as both raising and sinking.    But, the harnesses on my counterbalance both raise and fall when I push the treddle.   This makes sense because the pulleys give it a teeter totter action - one harness raises and the other falls.

The sheds I'm getting are HUGE, and in fact, they couldn't be any bigger because the warp threads are already very close to the heddle bars of the neighboring harness (10.5" heddles).  So, how is a countermarch different?  

 

Comments

WeaverDave (not verified)

With a rising shed Jack loom, at rest, the harnesses hold the warp threads about 1 inch below the level line between the front and rear beams.  When a harness is raised, it creates a shed about 3 1/2" to 4" high as it lifts the warp above the level line. 

A countermarch loom keeps the warp threads perfectly centered between the front and rear beams when the harnesses are at rest.  When you press a treadle, the warp is pried apart - one or more harnesses go up, and some go down.

A counterbalance loom moves the harness frames in the same way as a countermarch in that they pry the warp threads up and down away from the level line between the front and rear beams.  (Although, it accomplishes this in a much different way.)  I don't think there is such a thing as a "sinking shed" counterbalance loom.  Because of this, counterbalance and countermarch looms are able to maintain the high warp tension required for weaving rugs.  Jack looms can't create the correct tension. 

Most Jack looms are rising shed with the warp held 1 inch below the level line.  But some are sinking sheds where the warp threads are held about 1 inch above the level line.

Ellen (not verified)

I have not been close to counterbalance looms, but have worked with countermarche a lot. I think that when people call them "sinking shed" it is because when you do the tie-up on them, the marked, or black, squares in the draft are tied to the upper lamms and they will then pull the shafts down. All the others then go up on that treadle, as they are to be tied to the lower lamms. Hope this helps a little.

Dawn McCarthy

CB work in pairs one goes up, the opp goes down 

CM shafts move independently - whatever shafts are lifted - the remaining are lowered.  The CM uses two sets of lamms, one upper and one lower - this allows you to raise and lower shafts independently of one another.  The cm does not need a shuttle race as the lowered shafts create the floor of the shed and the tension on a cm aids in this.

for satin on a drawloom - for your satin pairs in your tie up - one shaft is lifted, another is lowered and the remaining stay stationary (these pairs may not be on opposites unless on 4, 6 or 8 shafts) If using four your ground is limited to a broken twill.

The CM is more flexible in the way shafts can be tied up, they are not restricted by pairings.  This is why they are generally preferred for drawlooms as 5 shaft satin is a very common ground weave for damask.  Your shed is reduced due to 2 sets of harnesses so a good shed to start with is important.  

If you can get the drall pulleys on your loom you can increase to 6 or 8 shafts - you will still need string long eye heddles and build a castle to support the back harness and be able to mount a draw frame on the front.

Hope this helps.

Dawn

 

SallyE (not verified)

Thank you all, this helps a lot.

How close together do you shafts have to be to use a drall pulley?  The Barbara has two sets of 8 shafts, but they are separated by a beam both below and above them.   Maybe I'd have to get two drall pulley's?  Also, if I'd need the elastics like Joanna said, I'm not sure how that would work.   My shafts are kind of "fat."

The Barbara has a big beam at the top that they call a hoist beam, and that would be a perfect place to mount the draw loom pulls, and the rest of the castle.

But all this would be a lot easier if I just had room for a CM.  (Or, could talk my husband into selling the baby grand piano that we never use!)

 

Dawn McCarthy

the mount pole for the cb or drall would have to sit above and middle to all the shafts you plan to use (say 8)

above is a pic of my loom elastics at farthest end of shafts hanging from cb pole, then a pair of drall pulleys for 6 shafts (these are the front ground shafts) In the back are the pattern shafts - these need to be located a certain distance away from the ground shafts to allow movement of the threads, these shafts are supported by a separate shaft hanger.  The pulley board uses a comber board (center) to create a path for the cords from pattern shaft to the front pulleys, these shafts are operated independently from the ground.  Why not wait for your class and decide then if drawloom weaving is for you? At that point you can make a decision to keep or sell your loom or get a countermarch (this loom then can be used for almost any weaving).  Also consider the weight and tension generated by the two sets of shafts, the loom needs to have a good square frame - especially for the castle as the pattern shafts and comber board are mounted from this - also the loom will need to have the back beam extended (the loom needs to be a lot deeper -generally at least a foot or two.  You are looking a major modifications to a loom which at best may only give you fair results for damask weaving.  You really should look at the Damask and Opphamta book as this will give you insight to the scale of modifications needed.  If drawloom weaving was easily done on anything else other than a swedish style cb or cm loom, most loom manufacturers would probably offer it a supplementry equipment.

 

Dawn

 

Sara von Tresckow

When doing drawloom work, usually 8 shafts are quite sufficient for the ground weave. Pattern is achieved with the single unit harness or the pattern shaft harness - and that is an independent harness with a full set of heddles separated by at least a footof space behind the ground harness.

That would mean that you'd only use 8 of your Barbara shafts on the drall pulley.

The counterbalance is sometimes referred to as sinking because the motion that creates the shed pulls certain shafts down, raising the other shaft on the pulley like a seesaw - as opposed to the independent action of the countermarche shafts.

Do not make the common mistake of thinking that because a loom has more than 8 shafts on the ground harness that these "extra" shafts then become the pattern harness. On a double harness loom every thread passes through TWO heddles so that every thread can alternate between being part of the ground or part of the pattern.

Here is where the distinction between shaft and harness becomes quite important.

Joanne Hall

Last winter I visited a weaving studio which had received a Barbara loom as a donation.  It was wider than yours, but it looked about the same.  One of the things I noticed is what you describe, that the shafts are very thick and they are separated.  This is very typical of the 70s when most weaving was done on two or four shafts and weavers were just starting to consider weaving on more shafts.  And there were many loom makers around.  When weaving on only four shafts, it is not so important to have them close together.  But if you look at a loom that has 16 shafts, you will find that the shafts are thinner and closer together.  The reason for this is that you can get much better sheds while still keeping a tight tension on the warp.  Both are very important for drawloom weaving, where the shed is 2 inches less than what is capable when you are not using long eyed heddles. I don't know if you can make your shafts closer together, but it would help.

If you continue with your project I would restrict your tie-up of the ground shafts to four shafts.

Joanne

SallyE (not verified)

How do the elastics work?   They are all bunched together to a single point at the top - it seems to me that means you could only lower the individual shafts and not raise them.

I'm sorry, I seem to be fixated on this right now.  I should wait for my spring class - that seems so far away!

 

Joanne Hall

The tie up for the drawloom is different than tying up for a normal counterbalance or cm tie-up.  When you get the DVD, you will see this.  When tying up a four shaft ground weave for a twill damask, one shaft goes up and one goes down.  So, two shafts are not moved by the treadle.  Something has to hold them, so the elastics do that.  Primarily, they keep those untied shafts from falling.

Joanne

Sara von Tresckow

For anyone interested in drawloom weaving - there is an important concept that needs to be understood.

Some shafts remain in NEUTRAL when the shed is formed. The Weavepoint Complex Drafting software even has a little icon for designating those shafts that neither rise nor sink on a treadle. This set of neutral shafts is what makes the jack loom nearly impossible to convert as some shafts really do need to sink below the web.

The topic is rather complex and if considering purchasing a draw unit or making one, you also need to know how the cloth is made and the pattern formed, as well as how pattern is designed before just sawing boards to try to put together the hardware needed.

I've been weaving along time and had read many books, but needed to travel for some instruction - AND a look at how a correctly functioning drawloom worked.

SallyE (not verified)

My great thank to all of you for answering my questions!  Now what I'm reading is making more sense too.  I find that a lot of writers will say what works or how to do something without saying why, and I really need the why to understand.

I'm still going to set up my loom for counterbalance (missing some cables I need to make) and will try some counterbalance weaving.   That should keep me busy for while anyway!

Again, thank you all for sharing your knowledge.

Dawn McCarthy

Sally, texsolv is a good investment for replacement cables!  Strong and easily adjusted.

Dawn

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on