I am new to weaving.  I've been making scarf-like weavings with the intention of giving them as Christmas gifts -- but so far have only made one that had the touch and feel of something I would want around my neck.  What is the trick?  I'm using a 12-dent reed and have experimented with 6epi, 12 epi, and 18 epi.  By far, the softest piece was the 6epi using a fluffy, nubby (synthetic) weft. 

Last week, I bought all kinds of beautiful alpaca thinking that was going to do the trick.  Last night, I put on a warp using the alpaca @ 6epi (a little worried it wouldn't be suited to warping) and also used the alpaca for weft -- and was again disappointed with the "feel."  I've unwoven my weave of last night -- and am in pause mode.  THere must be something I'm not getting.  Someone somewhere said it softens when you wash it.  Hmmm . . .

On another matter, I was also attempting my first twill last night.  (Ambitious, eh?) A simple 4-thread bird's eye I got out of the Marguerite Davison book.  And aside from the above-mentioned disappointment (not soft enough), I had the added annoyance that the twill pattern simply didn't show.  And I'm guessing that twill only works with a weave denser than 6 epi. 

Any advice will be greatly appreciated.

 

Lisa

Comments

Alison (not verified)

Hi Lisa,

Things do soften up in finishing.  Could you post pictures here of your results?  It would help us to identify what you might be encountering.

Have you washed any of the scarves?  A good practice is to weave a sample, cut in half (don't forget to sew the edges) and wash one piece.  That will tell you if it has the drape and feel your aiming for.  When you're washing, think in terms of the final product - for example, do you want it fulled to any extent?  If so, how much?  You might also consider brushing the surface of the washed sample.  If the yarn is fuzzy, a brishing will bring that back up.

There are lots of finishing techniques.

One thing that I think I picked up in your post is that you may not have the sett close enough. The final fabric may not hold its structure if the sett is too open for the yarn.  The set won't affect the softness (unless it is so close that you could be weaving body armour) as much as the drape. 

There is a lot to consider and write here.  Rather than that, as it may not address what you're encountering, I encourage you to post some pictures and tell us more about your yarn.

Alison

laurafry

"Soft" comes from a variety of factors.  First is your fibre/yarn choice.  How does the yarn feel in the skein or on the cone?  If it is not 'soft' in that format, you will have to work harder to make a 'soft' textile.

So first step is in choosing an appropriate yarn.  It also has to be the right grist (thickness) - you cannot easily make a thin fabric from a fat yarn.  :}

Your set will determine how much drape your fabric will have.  The more dense the fabric, generally the less drape.  But then, of course, there is the weave structure.  Plain weave generally is stiffer than a twill. 

But the combination of set and weave structure can affect how the fabric drapes, too.

Since you have a rigid heddle loom, you need to choose yarn that is soft to the touch, and fairly limp so that when it is woven in plain weave it will feel soft and have drape.

Last, but not least, the wet finishing will bring the textile to it's final state. 

I am running a special on Magic in the Water; wet finishing handwovens where wet finishing is discussed.  It's a pricey book, but comes with 22 projects illustrated with before and after actual fabric samples.  Buy before Thanksgiving and get CD Weaver III along with the supplementary samples that go with the cd.  Perhaps your local guild would be interested in adding the book to their library.  :)

A new weaver can learn a lot about textile construction by studying fabric samples, especially where all the info has been given.  They can examine the results, see how they were achieved, then can make more informed choices about how to create their own textiles.

Cheers,

Laura

http://LauraFry.artfire.com

debmcclintock

 Welcome to the FSC, full size sample club.....membership to this club requires finishing a couple of projects before you grant the time dedicated to a couple of samples and taking notes might help the full size cloth coming off the loom!  ;)))))  Deb

Alison (not verified)

Laura's book is a great for any serious weaver.  I look at it fairly often.  If you can't afford it, there is a good chance that your local weaving guild owns a copy.  If they don't, they really should!

I love looking at samples in general, they really are educational.

Michael White

lisa, all the advise above is very good, but I will add the following. To keep your scarf soft you have to have a very soft beat. If you beat too hard you will pack the yarn and get a stiff scarf no matter how you wash it. A fancy twill and a woolly yarn are not a good marriage. The design in the twill will get covered up. You can see some very soft scarves below at "new to knitting yarn' or at www.handweaver.us The scarves where woven at 6 epi, 48 ends in plain weave.

Michael

lisamarty (not verified)

Thanks for all the great comments and advice.

I did wash the first scarf.  But the sett was so close and my beat so hard that I happened on a recipe for "woolen steel."  Not to replicate.

Since then, using various low-grist (skinny) warps together with soft synthetic weft, I produced a couple of acceptable scarves which I didn't wash.

The yarn I'm now using is baby alpaca -- very soft.

Not sure whether I should increase my sett from 6epi to 10 or 12.  I had thought that a less dense weave was the path to "soft." But Alison brings up the matter of "structural integrity."  I'll  try softening my beat (even more!), and wash and brush and see what happens.  Will post results with photo.

Laura, not sure how you supposed "rigid heddle."  I'm working on a 1938 Bernat jack-style floor loom (4-shaft, 6 peddles).

So, Michael, you're saying I can't twill with alpaca or other fuzzy yarn?  What do you recommend?

 

Lisa

 

claudia (not verified)

Hi Lisa,

You've received a lot of good advice already. I will only add my welcome to the FSC, full size sample club.  After 4 or 5 colorful examples of steel wool in twill and plain weave, I started weaving samples.  I sampled almost every combination of warp and weft on 4 different looms (I have friends who share looms). I learned a lot about yarn, beat, my beat and what works for me.

Finishing is key as is good fiber. Sounds like you are on the right path. I encourage you to put on a short warp or add an extra 24" to the warp you are planning and sample, take notes about beat, size on loom, etc. Cut off the sample, I use Peggy Osterkamp's 2-stick heading when I cut off the sample, and then measure, wet finish, dry, measure and evaluate. I write everything down on my original weaving calculations sheet. I love the weaving calculator in our Resources section, it has a place to add extra length to your warp for sampling.

Just my 2cents

Claudia

Joanne Hall

Hi Lisa,

When you start weaving, only weave one inch and then take a tape measure to count the number of wefts you have woven in that inch.  It should be about the same as your sett in the reed.  So, if you have a 10 dent reed and 10 warps per inch, you would aim for 10 wefts per inch.  6 would be very hard to weave.  You would need to set the yarn in with no beating at all.  If you have beaten too hard, you may not be able to see the wefts enough to count them. 

Try again with any yarn that you have and see if this makes a difference.

Joanne

Michael White

Lisa, you can do twill, what I am saying is you will lose the effect of a "fancy twill" by having the wooly yarn cover up the design. What I would do is go and get some cheap knitting yarn to play with. make a short  scarf yarp set at 6epi, 48 ends. This will give you 8" before wet finishing. Use the same yarn as weft. You can tie up as plain weave or a simple twill. In time you will be able to pickup a yarn and say I can use this for........ I would save my costly mohair untill you get the feel for the yarn you are using. Have fun an remember  practice, practice. By the way when you wash a delicate, soft scarf you want to lay it in a tub of warm water with mild soap and push down on the piece, DO NOT RUB OR TWIST THE PIECE. Rinse in warm water, again just pushing down on the piece, rinse again and this time add just a teaspoon of fabric softner, remove and push out the excess water, do not twist. You can roll it up in a dry towel and push out the excess water, then hang to dry. I hope I did not get to basic on you.

Michael  

lisamarty (not verified)

Thanks to all for these additional very useful comments.

Glad to know, Claudia, I'm not the only one with a penchant for "steel wool."  I've been using Deborah Chandler's book LEARNING TO WEAVE  and she also recommends focusing on samples for a long time before launching into real projects. I was so excited to be finally getting the hang of warping and threading that I thought I was ready for a scarf.  Turns out there's SO MUCH to weaving. 

Based on Joanne's suggestion, my warp/weft ratio is off:  6 warps/10 wefts per inch.  Hope to balance that in my next "sample" and see if it helps with the "softness" quotient.

Thanks for the tips on washing, Michael.  Hard to get too basic with me at this point. 

Sorry to bother the group with such elementals, but I greatly appreciate the feedback.

 

Lisa

 

claudia (not verified)

Hey, no apologies Lisa. No one complained and I see lots of people wanting to help you out. We all started where you are now and it feels good to offer our experiences (not that I put myself in the same class as Alison, Deb, Laura, Michael and Joanne) to help you out.

This is one of the reasons we started Weavolution. For experienced weavers, it's a place to discuss complex weave structures or problems with their AVL warping wheel. For those starting out, it's a place to find support and advice. That advice can come from anyone wanting to answer.

So, you are welcome (I'll be presumptuous enough to speak for everyone who responded) and please don't apologize. There is something to be learned by everyone if they choose.

Claudia, Weavolution co-founder

Michael White

Lisa, my better half says if you hold your scarf up to the light you should see holes in it. The yarn is not beaten it is just pushed into place Also if you are washing mohair you can use "hair" conditioner in the final rinse water..

Michael

BonnieI (not verified)

Lisa, each of us has a different scarf in mind when we think about our ideal soft scarf.  If you can, visit a weaving guild sale or a craft fair with weavers or a fine craft gallery or quality store with scarves. Look at all the scarves to learn as much as possible from woven examples.  Soft might mean fluffy, in which case you can lightly brush the scarf after washing it. Soft might include flexible, probably indicating a finer yarn. Soft with lovely drape often means more warps per inch than wefts and a twill structure.

If you like twills, including fancy twills, they can look great with wool. The design will show nicely if you have contrast in value between the warp and the weft. If your warp is dark, then use a light weft.  I avoid holes in my scarves because they could catch on buttons or earrings and I want my work to be durable.   Some of the fancy twills are not hard to treadle.

Look at other people's scarves and think about the things that most appeal to you, and also notice the things that you would not want in your work.  Hope this helps!  Bonnie Inouye

Michael White

Hi Bonnie, are you back on the East coast? When I said holes I did not means that large that a botton would go through. What I ment was like airy, since Lisa was beating too hard. y'all have a great Thanksgiving!

Michael

lisamarty (not verified)

Thanks again to everyone for all the encouragement and advice.  Trying to incorporate everything everyone has said, and my current "scarf" seems better -- not something to gird a bridge with.  :)  I'll see what happens after I give it a bath.

 

Happy Thanksgiving!

 

Lisa

 

BonnieI (not verified)

I hope you all had great food today. Yes, I am in Maryland now and we shared our Thanksgiving meal with a grad student from Indonesia. He taught me their word for "weaving" but I need to write it down to remember it.  He was not expecting to meet a weaver with a loom in the USA.

Lisa, improvement is always good, and washing your scarf will let the yarns relax.  I finish the ends before washing, usually with a twisted fringe.

With a new warp yarn, it can be very helpful to sample. Weave maybe 3-4 inches one way and then try something different: change how you beat or use different weft yarn or different treadling or different color. Change one thing at a time so you can learn more by comparing two samples. Even very experienced weavers need to sample sometimes!

Bonnie Inouye

laurafry

Sampling?  Not just sometimes - all the time it seems.  Every time I get a new yarn, I need to sample it.  :D

Cheers,

Laura

Chiquita345

Lisa,

Do you happen to have any info on your loom?  Like a manual or anything instructional?  If not, could you possibly send me some pictures of the cords tying the harnesses to the jacks?  I need to spruce mine up but I'm new to this and don't know how it's supposed to be.

Thanks!

Lindsey

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on