Hello,

I'm a novice weaver and I'm contemplating making a tartan blanket. I'm looking at using Harrisville Highland yarn at 10 epi, and a tartan with a sett that would scale up to the large yarn size pretty well.

My question is about how feasible it is to try to do this. I've never intentionally fulled wool before, and I'm not sure if part of the design will be osbscured when I do so. Some of the elements will be only four threads wide. I don't expect crisp lines, but I also don't want to completely lose any detail. Is this likely to work out well, or would doubling the sett so that there is a minimum of eight threads of a color be a better idea? I'd prefer not to double it if possible.

I'll make a small sample first, but would like to get off on the right foot.

Thanks.

Comments

Sue in VT

I'm not sure, but I bet reed guy can answer this question, as he's worked with Harrisville and tartan plaids.  Good luck, sounds wonderful.  Blankets SEEM like big projects, but go amazingly fast once warped!

Sue in VT

I'm not sure, but I bet reed guy can answer this question, as he's worked with Harrisville and tartan plaids.  Good luck, sounds wonderful.  Blankets SEEM like big projects, but go amazingly fast once warped!

lisarothwell

Why did you choose Harrisville Highland vs Scotland yarn?  Also, are you looking at using it for warp or weft or both? I am making tartans with homespun but am considering using commercially spun yarn.  I have also heard mixed reviews of yarn being used for knitting is not suitable for weaving.  Is this a myth or fact?

thanks

roycroft

Hi, Lisa.

First, let me repeat that I'm a novice weaver - I have almost no practical weaving experience at all yet, but have done a lot of research, so please keep that in mind when you read what I have to say.

I've been interested in textiles all my life, but the push that got me to buy a loom and actually start weaving is that I've designed a tartan and want to weave a sample before registering it with the Scottish Register of Tartans, as once registered I can't change the sett. Now that I have a loom I plan on weaving enough fabric to make at least one kilt after I'm happy with the design. For that project I'll be using some 2/16 worsted wool yarn from Camilla Valley Farms, as that should give me the proper weight fabric for kiltmaking. I have some of that yarn and am dyeing small samples of it now to get the colors I want for my tartan design. It's going to take a while before I get the colors dialed in, so weaving the sample will not happen for a bit yet.

I decided to make a tartan blanket as a good weaving project in the meantime (nothing like a major challenge to really get one going). There are three criteria that led me to choosing Harrisville Highland. First, I wanted a woolen spun yarn, not worsted, so that I could get some nice fulling. Second, I want the blanket to be fairly heavy. Third, since the blanket will be large (queen size), I want the tartan design to be larger than it would be with kilt-weight fabric, as it might look kind of funny with a really small sett.

With the 2/16 yarn I'll be weaving at 40 epi, and with the Harrisville Highland I anticipate 10 epi, so the sett will be 4x larger than on heavy kilt fabric. I think that will look good on such a large piece. I'm going to do a mock full size printout and if it looks like the sett is way too big with that yarn I'll think about using their Shetland yarn instead at 20 epi, but I think that would make a lighter weight blanket than I want.

Finally, Harrisville yarns are available in colors that will work well for me without having to dye any for the project, which makes it an easy decision in that respect.

I'm still hoping for input from others who have done something similar before, and still have time before ordering yarn as I'm still in the planning stages, but I think I haven't made any horribly bad mistakes in my design process. All of this is still very new to me though.

I hope this helps.

sandra.eberhar…

Fulling your fabric shouldn't loose your pattern, it will still be visible.  Soft woolen spun yarn (like many knitting yarns) can by used for weft easily, but may not be abrasion resistan enough for warp.  It also may be too stretchy for warp.

sandra.eberhar…

What do you mean by Scotland yarns?  Camilla Valley used to carry a yarn imported from Scotland, I think it was about 2/20.  This would be much, much thinner that the Harrisville, and give a completely different fabric.  This is no longer availble in the US.

sandra.eberhar…

Roycroft, your plan sounds good to me. The hardest thing about a plaid is that the beat has to absolutely even and square.  Making a blanket first will give you good practice for that.  I would like to weave a tartan for my brother, and I'm kicking myself for not getting the Scottish kilt wool from Camilla Valley when they had it.  It was in the traditional colors of Scottish tartans.  I have not made tartans, but I have made very light, soft fabrics from soft woolen yarns set very  loosely and fulled for stability.  BTW, I think your use of sett to describe your pattern may be confusing; is usually applies to how close together your warps are (10 per inch, etc).  I think you mean the scale of the pattern.

sandra.eberhar…

The Tartan Registry calls what you are calling sett the threadcount.

roycroft

Hello,

Thanks for your feedback. I think you might have misread one of my posts, as I did not mention "Scotland yarns." The yarn I have for the kilt fabric is from Camilla Valley, and it is imported from Scotland - it's 2/16 worsted wool. I'm in the US and Camilla Valley is the only place on the continent I've found that weight yarn. I bought some tubes in white and am dyeing it.

The Harrisville yarns are named "Highland" and "Shetland." As far as I know they are made with domestic wool, and I know they are spun here - not imported. The Highland is 450 yards/lb, and they recommend weaving at 8-10 epi. Since I'll be weaving  2/2 twill , I figure 10 epi will be the number to go with. Shetland is 900 yards/lb and recommended 18-20 epi. Interestingly, they list both of these yarns on their website as both knitting and weaving yarns, but with different packaging for the knitting vs. weaving yarn. I'm looking for a warm, fuzzy, heavy wool blanket so I need something a lot heavier than the 2/16 worsted wool for the blanket project.

Again, with no real world experience with this, is using their yarn for warp likely to be a big problem? For a tartan design I need a balanced weave, and using a different warp yarn than weft yarn might make that difficult.

Thanks.

roycroft

Hi, again.

I should probably have discussed this earlier, as I was anticipating some confusion, perhaps mostly on my end. The "tartan community" seem to like to discuss the overall pattern of a tartan design as the sett, and the detailed color sequence as the thread count. This seems to be another of those terms that's used differently in different communities, just as "worsted" means one thing to knitters and another thing to weavers. I'm pretty clear what the tartan (kilt) folks mean when they say "sett" and I know that is different from what weavers mean. A kiltmaker thinks of a 6" sett or 8" sett, and uses that to determine how many pleats to build into a kilt and what size the pleats should be.

I know that's different from the weaver's meaning of sett, but it's hard for me to try to translate terms from one context to the other. The tartan crowd may have it wrong, but that's what they do. I don't mean to confuse.

lisarothwell

This is great info.. need to start a weavers glossary to clarify and standardize our discussion.. Also, Has any one started a cross reference of the books available?  for level of experience, focus of information, product, loom, dyeing, gardening, sheep/ fiber, etc. would be of great appreciation instead of an insurmountal task. By making information easy to access, more will be interested and create a following.  Also, encouragement of middle and high school woodworking shops to educate future woodworker for all things textile. With interest in getting back to basics, now is the time..  Don't forget that propogation of a low maintenance dyers and organic food landscaping is coming to fruition as well.

G/B

sandra.eberhar…

I have woven very light and warm blankets using yarn very similar to Harrisville using it for warp and weft with no problems.  Another poster mentioned "Scotland Yarn" and I was hoping for reply from them.  The packaging for weaving yarn is coned and may still contain spinning oils, this oil would make it easier to work with as warp and weft, but would give the yarn a hard hand that will wash out.

Artistry

Roycroft,

If you care to, you can type tartan into the search engine and the discussions re: tartans will pop up. Lots of good info in there. There is a fellow, I think it's r1mein54, who has woven kilts. You might go look at his project page. I know there have been several on Weavolution who have woven and sewn their own ! 

Good luck,

from a Scot,( of heritage) Cathie

 

ReedGuy

Your Shetland weight is off somewhat and your sett too high. What CVF sells is 1800 yards/lb on cones. With a sett of 10-15 recommended. Your confusing yards/cone (package) with yards/lb (weight). They are packaged on 1/2 lb cones. I have used a sett of 12 per layer in a doubleweave, so sleyed at 24 epi in the reed. It makes a soft desireable blanket when fulled that isn't too heavy. I have made some blankets from 870 yard/lb wool and they are on the heavy side and a sett of  8 epi per layer (sleighed at 16). My mother likes this weight in a throw I made from Briggs and Little wool. The Shetland doesn't have a high twist, so isn't as elastic as the B&L.  Shetland is  "Sport" weight and 2-ply, B&L only has single ply in "Sport" weight.

I have a project page here to look at where I wove the Canadian Centenial tartan with 2/2 "Batavia" twill. Good on both sides.

http://weavolution.com/project/reedguy/doubleweave-width-batavia-twill-…

Ask away if you have any further questions.

Another Canuck of Scottish heritage. :)

Submitted by roycroft on