I am a fairly new weaver.  I've woven on a RH loom but just got my first multishaft loom, an 8 harness Louet Jane, a few days ago.  I attended a weaving camp a few weeks ago where I was taught back to front warping and in fact my loom comes with back to front directions.  But recently I bought Madelyn van der Hoogt's warping video and she seems to prefer front to back.  From what I have heard and read, more people seem to prefer back to front, but watching Madelyn's video, front to back sure looks easier and quicker.  I've been thinking though, since more people seem to prefer back to front, even though it seems harder to me, there must be something about it that makes it better (at least in the eyes of the people who do it that way).  So I decided to try front to back on my new loom and even though it seemed easier than the way I was taught.  I wasn't very impressed by the results and it just doesn't look like a good warp to me, but then what do I know.   I'm just wondering, for those of you who prefer one method over the other, what about it makes you prefer it over the other?  I'd appreciate the input of anyone who wants to give it but let's not start a war as I know this is a touchy subject.

Comments

Joanne Hall

No need to start a war.  Learn both methods.  But for fine threads or fragile threads or warps longer than 6 yards, back to front will beam on faster with fewer tangles.

Joanne

sally orgren

and I am glad you are brave enough to post the question!

B2F seems to work best for most situations I face, and especially when I am helping beginners. There are some tricks with F2B that new weavers sometimes miss, resulting in a warp that becomes a "hot mess" fast. (And yes, I actually used F2B to solve a hot mess I created for myself last summer, so knowing both can save your bacon in unexpected ways ;-)

IMHO, when the warp is one thread per dent, it doesn't matter as much. When the warp is all one color, it also doesn't matter as much. Keep in mind, either warping method looks fantastic when demonstrated by someone who has been doing it for more than 10 years!

When you are thinking to wind a warp of many frequent color changes, it might seem easier and faster to wind each color of warp as separate bouts (for example 50 blues, 50 yellows, 100 whites.) With F2B, the next step is to distribute the colors in the reed. The tricky part is then figuring out which colored thread to select when threading the heddles AND reversing the pattern, since you are now sitting at the back of the loom to thread. If the color order is regular (blue, yellow, white, repeat) that is easy to track, but if it is irregular, it can get confusing fast. 

Also, if the sley order is irregular, say 2,2,3, a new weaver is more likely to get these threads crossed between the reed and the heddles.

Many folks forget to take strings and place them across the reed to create different "levels" of warps to assist in more complicated threading when doing F2B.

The best warping habit is to wind shorter warps frequently so you build your skills in the method you choose, and keep consistent weight on your warp when beaming. You will migrate to the method that works fastest and most accurately for you over time.

P.S. At Convergence 2010 Long Beach, they had a public contest between Madelyn (F2B) and Suzie Liles (B2F). Suzie won by a good 10 minutes. 

theresasc

regardless of which method you use.  My friend and I each put the same warp on two of the same looms, she warped f2b, I warped b2f - we finished within minutes of each other.  

laurafry

What they said. If you are happy with your results you don't need to change anything. If you aren't it is a good thing to know more than one way to do the task at hand. Cheers Laura

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

A lot of weaving questions are answered with "it depends" because weaving is such a big field.

Sometimes it is much easier to make the space to stand in front of the loom, sometimes in back. With a table loom, you can easily move the loom! Some looms make it easy to reach the heddles from the front (removing parts first) and some are comfy sitting behind the heddles. A short warp, less than 5 yards or meters, is likely to go onto the beam reasonably easily with either method. It can be easier to place colors, particularly threads from a painted or dyed chain, at the reed. It is generally easier to thread the heddles after the warp is on the beam when using energized yarn (two strands start to twist together if you let them hang from the cones) or very fine yarn, especially if you want more than 2 warp ends per dent in the reed.

Bonnie Inouye

NancyHassel

I warp sectionally, usually with an AVL warping wheel with crossmaker.  Sectional warping could be considered a type of back-to-front technique.  One time I really wanted to warp front to back (complicated wide painted warp).  I threaded the reed and mounted it.  Then I got a stool and tried to position myself between the warp beam and the harnesses so I could thread the heddles.  There was no room (AVL Folding Dobby) - it would have been necessary to take off both warp beams.  So I warped back-to-front that day.  Now I have a second loom (AVL full-frame Production Dobby) and there is plent of room for a stool between the warp beam and the harnesses and there will likely be a day when I warp that loom front to back.  Most of the time my needs are best served warping sectionally.

Nancy

kerstinfroberg

Being from Sweden, I had never even heard of F2B before the internet...

Being chicken, I have never dared try it. How do you make the knots at the back apron rod, without disturbing the warp (length)? Is there a trick to make sure the knots take up the same length? As I understand it, the back knots have to be done without tension on the warp - doesn't that make it all the more difficult?

 

Erica J

Thank you for prompting this wonderful discussion!

My experience weaving was I learned F2B and hated it initially! This was probably due to the fact that I learned when I was 8 and didn't warp on my own regularly until I was in my 20's. :) When I became frustated with F2B, I learned B2F from Peggy Oesterkamp's books. It is still my preferred method, but I have learned from both Madelyn's video and Daryl Lancaster's Cyber Fiber class. I am now competent with both methods, though I still defer to B2F. As previously stated, there is a time and place for both method, but for straight foward warps it really does come down to personal preference.

As you progress as a weaver and start teaching other people it is good to know boht methods as well, as different people obviously gravitate to one method or the other.

Cheers,

Erica

pammersw

I've heard that F2B is used a lot in the US and Canada,  and is almost unheard of in the rest of the world, where they nearly all use B2F. I learned B2F so that's what makes the most sense to me.

EvaHall

Like Kerstin I learned about F2B from the internet. In fact it was Weavolution that brought this method to my attention. I could ask the same question as Kerstin. How do you make sure the ends are of equal length? That is a big mystery to me. Once I tied a new warp to the leftovers of the old one, it was a rather short one, just to make use of some leftover yarn. If the warp had been any longer than the about 2 meters, I think I would have been in big trouble. I cannot imagine doping F2B with 20 meters of warp.

jlread (not verified)

What works best for you is the way to go...why get all tangled in the clutter of which way is best...there is none...your way is the right way!

mneligh

I use B2F for my B type Macomber, and F2B for my Baby Wolf.  In other words, I try to figue out which method was intended when the loom was designed, and use that.  Usually, there are clues in the design.  On the BW the back beam comes off to give access to the heddles.  On the Macomber, the front beam folds down and the beater  comes off to provide that access.

I'm much faster at warping the Macomber than the Baby Wolf, even at warps twice the width.  Not only have I had the loom at least 30 years longer, but I also use it more.  I use the Baby Wolf mostly for demos and sheep-to-shawls, although I have done some nice things on it.  The Macomber is almost constantly in use these days.

With the Macomber, the ergonomics are right for me for warping.  I can thread or sley for hours.  With the BW, I have to keep it folded up and sit on a 6" stool when threading.  Watching Madelyn, I've learned to remove and sley the reed outside of the loom at a comfortable height, but the rest makes me achy.  Besides removing the back beam, this is another reason for using F2B on that loom.

Dena (not verified)

To get the threads the same length in the back when warping front to back, I tie a really tight choke tie approximately a yard/meter from the start of your warp.  When I am threading the heddles, I give a gentle tug to each thread and they naturally all stop in the same place.  I make sure they are all in line and the same length (a very quick process) and then make an overhand knot in each group of about 1.5".  There are two possible methods that I use to then tie the overhand knot to the back of the loom.  I prefer to lash on, but my students seem more comfortable with tying it directly.

Front to back has worked well for everything I have done over the past twenty seven years.  I don't generally work with linen or homespun.

Many weavers say that back to front is better because you are only going through the heddles once.  My theory is that heddles have changed quite a bit and they aren't anywhere near as abrasive as they used to be so this is rarely a problem.  I am guessing that your problems with front to back warping had more to do with your inexperience and less to do with the method.  Any warping method should be tried 3-5 times before making a decision.

pammersw

To each his own LOL! I warp the rented baby wolf b2f, without taking anythingoff, with it unfolded and ready to use! It really is an individual thing.

jander14indoor (not verified)

I've only warped my  Baby Wolf a couple of times, did it B2F as that's how I started.  Before I experiment with other methods I want to get that right first.

Funny thing is, I just took off the front beam when I was threading.  Comes off of mine about as easily as the back.

Jeff Anderson

catherine8

Sally, I love that you said "wind shorter warps frequently so you build your skills in the method you choose".  I am a relatively new weaver and am doing a series of different projects but feeling a bit guilty that I am not putting on 9 yard warps and weaving a lot all at once.  But today, putting on (yet another) 3 yard warp I felt more confident and things are going along well, better than usual.  Your comment suggests that I am on the right track after all!  Thanks.

sally orgren

Besides improving your warping skills, the more you weave helps you define what you like to weave. So you'll know when you want to put a longer warp on and enjoy weaving it off. I have seen too many guildmates start with a very long, all white warp, and then get bored/burned out before they ever finish. Have fun!

Submitted by Raine59 on