I am considering a Dorothy with treadle stand, because I can separate it into 2 tote-able parts, warped, and take it places. I wonder whether the treadles' harness cords slip off the handles they're attached to, and how easily it treadles.

Any feedback by weavers who have tried this combination would be very appreciated.

Thank you,

Dedee

 

Comments

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

I used to teach weaving at an art center with several Dorothy looms. They are durable and were not too expensive and easy to order, so they are often found in schools. I found them uncomfortable to use. The levers are off to the side and have to be pressed hard. Watch out for your hands when you release them!

I have been weaving since 1967 and have never seen a Dorothy loom with treadles. LeClerc makes a lot of different kinds of looms, many of which have treadles and work well with treadles. They make more portable looms (floor and table) than the Dorothy, which seemed to work all right for a 4-shaft beginning class; after 6 or 8 weeks, everybody was ready for a better loom. It seems quite likely that nobody has tried to build treadles for this model of loom, but maybe you will find somebody here.

Bonnie

Dedee

Thank you for your reply!

Camilla Valley Farms sells a Dorothy treadle stand. I much prefer foot power to pressing levers. If the treadle stand works well, I could dispense with the lever action problems. Or could I? The hard action might be present in the treadling, as well. 

The real question is whether I can find a foot powered loom lightweight enough for me to take to workshops. Neither the Wolf Pup LT or Harrisville 22/6 is light enough. In 2 parts, the Dorothy with treadle stand would be. I'm not familiar with another LeClerc floor loom that would be portable enough. The Saori W60 with 4'harness attachment would be, but it has 2 significant downsides: small clearance on the cloth roller, and much more expensive. A 3rd downside is that, when it is folded warped, the treadles push right into the warp. I think I could produce and attach a remedy for that, though.

Dedee

Weavingholiday

I have a Dorothy with a treadle stand that gives me the option of using the 6 treadles if I want.

I am very happy with this combination of loom and treadle stand. You can take just the loom or loom and stand if you want to travel.

I would say that the action using the treadles seems a bit softer than when using the levers, but it still does clunk a little when changing sheds. You can minimize this by holding the treadles you want down, but not going quite so far as to lock the levers into position if you want to (hope that makes sense?).

Anyway, this set up fits nicely into our smallish home, and allows me to take the loom with or without the stand much more easily than other looms. I have helped a friend move her loom and it had to be dissassembled and reassembled to be carried, and especially to fit into her van.

I have not woven on many different looms, and am quite new to loom weaving. My Dorothy and stand were not new to the person who sold them to me, so my set up may be a little different than what you would get buying new today. And I am not looking to do production work. So, given those paramters, think this can be a good set up.

Good luck with your quest!

Dedee

Weavingholiday, thank you for posting!

I understand that you are saying to create the shed but don't click the harnesses into place. I hadn't thought of that!

I was concerned  that the treadle cords would slip down on the levers, and maybe completely off. Has that been an issue for you? When you travel with the treadle stand, do you leave it fully assembled? I wonder whether it would fit in the back of my Jeep Liberty. How long does it take to assemble the loom and stand together?

One of the things I like best about the Dorothy is that it has plenty of clearance around the cloth beam. I'm still weaving with worsted weight yarns much of the time.

I'm very pleased to hear from someone who has experience with this combination!

Dedee

jj50 (not verified)

I have a 15 3/4" Dorothy that I use with a treadle stand. I got the stand used with a different model Leclerc  20", I think, table loom. I sold the loom and kept the stand for my little Dorothy. I loop texsolv cord around the levers and attach it to the lamms. To get a good shed, I tape the plastic lock back to prevent locking. It works well, except the stand I have is an old x-frame which isn't very roomy for your legs compared to the new style stand. I don't use it much, and have never traveled with it, but I like having it to use either as a table loom or with the treadles.

Dedee

Hi, jj50!

I'm glad to hear that the stand was able to accomodate your 15-3/4" Dorothy. I really like the idea of taping back the lock so the shafts don't click into place. Untaping for travel would come in handy, I suppose. Have you noticed how long it takes to assemble the loom to the treadle stand?

I notice that no one in this thread so far has reported any issues with the treadle action, or with the cords slipping off the levers. Is it only the colored lever tabs that hold the treadle cords in place, or is there a notch or crook in the metal bars, to prevent slippage?

All of this useful information is increasing my interest in this combination as a travel loom.

Thank you for sharing your experience, 

Dedee

Weavingholiday

Have never had any trouble with slipping, and this loom has been around the block a few times. On mine, the cords hook into a hole on the lever beside the little coloured plastic ends. It would take quite a bit to loosen them in normal operation. We have a Ford Focus, so I have never tried putting the stand in assembled. I think you might have a good chance of getting the stand in whole in your Jeep, but since I have never tried, that is just a guess. You might, at worst, take the stand partly apart, but it is not huge. One thing I would do if carting the stand whole is to figure out a way to keep the treadles together, maybe a little stick across them or some such? Setting up the loom on the assembled stand is really quick, but I have always had someone to help hold things in place while attaching. You could probably jigger up some sort of support if needs be, but with a helper, it is just a couple of bolts and reattaching the cords. I have never really timed the assembling, but don't find it honorous. Pulling the lock out of the way is genius! Have to try that, although just not really trumping the treadles does prevent the locking and unlocking "kathwump." The stand I have will let you set the loom at a few different heights, and I have not minded the clearance, but that is so much a personal thing it is hard to know how another person will find the feel. Hope this helps a bit, and you end up with just the right loom!

Dedee

Hi, Weavingholiday,

Oh, so that's how it goes! Holes in the levers. I've looked at the Dorothy and treadle stand ad photos several times, but there isn't enough detail. I'll keep in mind that a gizmo to keep the treadles together will help. Do the lamms stay in place when the loom is off the stand?

The LeClerc stand marketed by them and Camilla Valley Farm has height adjustments; 3, I think.

Your describing the cable attachment to the levers is a key piece in helping me decide about this combination. Reading that the treadle action isn't unusually heavy also is helpful. Besides useful content, your post was fun to read.

Thank you much!

Dedee

Weavingholiday

I think if taking the stand all in one piece you probably could find or make a sort of seat belt to keep them stable, but don't think you would have too much trouble just for getting everything in and out of your vehicle. Taking the lamms on and off is not too hard once the loom is off the stand, too. If you could see everything set up in person, I know it would be easier; pictures and descriptions can be a bit "flat." I would probably make a nice little kit, maybe a little box, to keep the bits and pieces you remove when taking things apart, and maybe add a wrench or two, and one of those nice little wing nut wrenches if you are going for speed and comfort. And maybe a few extra nuts and such (being the sort of person who sometimes has them roll away never to be seen again....) But have to say, the first time I assembled everything I was surprised how straightforward it all turned out to be. Standard disclaimer: this is how things are on my venerable loom, there is the chance things have been changed a bit on newer models in ways that are not obvious to me when I look at the schematics. And at this point things are held together with a marvellous assortment of different nuts on my beastie, but I think originally there were a lot more wing nuts involved, which would make assembly and disassembly even quicker.

jj50 (not verified)

I keep my little Dorothy with stand in the basement so what takes the longest is carrying it upstairs. I need to make 2 trips, one for Dorothy & one for the stand. The stand is an x-frame that folds making it easier to carry around. I have it tied for straight twill, so setting it up takes about 5 minutes, a little longer if I change the tie-up. I don't screw Dorothy onto the stand, the frame doesn't allow for this. It sits on top of the frame where it rests on it's side beams instead of the legs, and I just need to loop the cords from the lamms around the levers to get it ready. I don't have holes drilled in the levers. The colorful plastic tips keep the cords on the levers.

I looked at Leclerc webstie for a drawing of the x-frame but can't find it on their list of schematics. Here is a link to the current 24" Dorothy stand in PDF so you can enlarge it for a better view of the set up.

http://www.leclerclooms.com/draw_inst/dorst4.pdf

Weavingholiday

The stand I have looks much like the one on the LeClerc website these days. A couple (4?) of wingnuts to hold the loom on the stand, but very quickly removed and put back.

That x-frame sounds really cool!

jj50 (not verified)

The x-frame really isn't very cool, for me anyway. It has a brace across the front & back that the loom sits on. The front brace makes it cramped for leg space when treadling. Still, it's faster than using the hand levers!

Weavingholiday

Guess there is always a compromise. The frame I have has more adjustable leg room, but then you have to undo the wing nuts to remove the loom. But one way or another, the treadles definitely make changing sheds much easier.

After you mentioned preventing the sheds from actually locking I went back and re-read the LeClerc material more closely, and they suggest how to do that with the Dorothy I have. I totally missed that up to now. Thanks for that great tip! Now I can treadle with abandon! :)

Dedee

Lammas (llamas) are scary; lamms (lambs) are much nicer :-)

Dedee

Wow, so you have an X-frame with treadles! I don't see that on the LeClerc website anymore. The folding down would be a convenience in small spaces. Does it fold up side to side, or front to back?

Thank you,

Dedee

Dedee

It's nice to hear that LeClerc has a method for stopping the latch. I really want this combination with treadle stand, now that I've learned so much from all of you. I'm reassured that LeClerc will give helpful instructions for this process. I, too, want to set up a Dorothy with treadles and "treadle with abandon!"

Dedee

Thanks, jj50, for the web link. It clarifies things a lot. Funny I didn't see it when I was on the LeClerc site. :-)

jj50 (not verified)

Glad to help with the unlocking the levers tip Weavingholiday! I hadn't read anything about an official way to keep the lock in the unlock position. When I use mine as a table loom, I flip the plastic piece back to release the shed, lower the levers, then press the levers for a new shed to avoid having the shafts come banging down. This probably takes a lot more time than the way most people use a Dorothy. I knew all about unlocking the levers.  Maybe because my process is a bit slower, I was more motivated than most to find a work around that the x-frame stand addressed beautifully. 

 

The x-frame is a compromise compared to the other type of stand.  DeDee, it folds back to front. Maybe it wasn't one of LeClercs better ideas so they don't include it on their list. ;-)

 

I'm seriously thinking about making a new stand that looks like the current stand, reusing the lamms & treadles that are on the x-frame. Lack of tools and woodworking skill are my biggest obstacles right now.

Jan

 

Weavingholiday

If you can re-use the lamms and treadles, the rest of the stand is pretty straight forward. Because the design depends on the width of the loom fitting the upright "legs" of the stand, think you would probably have to make the stand to fit your Dorothy, the only ones I have seen for sale are for the wider loom? Wonder if a local high school woodworking class or similar might be willing to take making one on as a project?

Best ishes to both of you, having my Dorothy with treadles tucked into a corner in the dining room is a real joy :)

SAORI Peachtree City

Ok, so obviously from my username, I have a bias.  But let's set aside my bias....... there.  it is over in the corner.

Dedee, Have you made a decision?  I do not dictate the price of SAORI looms, so I cannot help there, BUT I can possibly help with other questions.... like the treadles hitting the warp threads..... the weight, etc.  If there are questions you would like answered by someone who uses the looms.  Yes, I sell them, but you probably already have a dealer in mind (since you know the price range) and my point would be to help inform, not to sell. 

Denise

Dedee

Hi, Denise. Thank you for offering information on the Saori W60. I still haven't made a decision.

I said before, "The Saori W60 with 4 harness attachment would be (light enough for me to take to workshops), but it has 2 significant downsides: small clearance on the cloth roller, and much more expensive. A 3rd downside is that, when it is folded warped, the treadles push right into the warp. I think I could produce and attach a remedy for that, though."

I like many things about the W60 with 4 harnesses, and have had a chance to help assemble one, but I have the few issues above. I especially find the clearance around the warp beam very small, since I still often weave with worsted-weight yarns. Mihoko at Saori Worcester here in Massachusetts had one of her students show me how they unwrap the cloth from the cloth beam and wind a section of cloth nearer the fell around the roller with wood clamp - I forget what it's called, then attach it to the cloth beam with the attached cord-and-plastic clips. That works well only if the cloth width is significantly narrower than the maximum weaving width. I have attached shoelaces and a metal rod to my Piccolo's cloth beam, and warp "on a shoestring." That improves the clearance around the cloth beam, but it is still limited. I like to warp a pair of worsted weight scarves and weave them both before detaching from the loom. This, as well as warping "on a shoestring," saves warp. I know I could detach the first scarf and tie on the 2nd, but I have a preference for using material efficiently. I don't skimp on scarf length itself :-)

I realize that I haven't asked any questions; I have only made observations. I find the 4 harness mechanism on the Saori looms elegant and lightweight, and the pedals surprisingly roomy for such a light loom. 

I think I could figure out how to attach something to keep the pedals from pushing into the warp when I fold it. It comes down to the lack of clearance around the cloth beam, and I don't see any additional remedies for that, besides the one I have used on my Piccolo. Also, I will need to save for it for a while. 

I am interested in any suggestions you may have for maximizing the cloth beam capacity of the WX60.

Thank you,

Dedee


SAORI Peachtree City

DeeDee.  I sometimes forget to check here.  

I am not sure how Mihoko does that with a wood clamp.  I do it with the tie rod.  It can be trickier full width, but still could be done.

I just put together a wx60 4h this weekend.  The weaver is a bit taller than me, so we put the 2 in height extenders on it (btw SAORI also now makes a 4inch extender for the wx!).  The treadles to hit the backbeam.  Here is what I do:  I take a length of cord behind the tie up and pull the treadles forward.  and fold.  once it is folded the tension is off the warp, so I have never had a problem occur from the treadles hitting the warp at that point.  Takes a second to check the treadles and pull the tie cords out before unfolding.  I have been weaving on the SX60h 4h for 4 years.  never a problem.

 

feel free to email me with specific questions.  I am on this forum so seldom.    [email protected]  I am happy to answer questions.  Not trying to sell! Just trying to help get good information out in the public.

Submitted by Dedee on