Hi all -

I have had some folks ask me to put together weaving kits, which seems like a fun project.  I figure I will measure off enough yarn plus a bit for them to do their warping and weaving ... and it would be easier for them to do that from cones instead of skeins.  Which means, I think, that I need a good cone winder.  Anyone have any recommendations?

Thanks!

heather

Comments

tien (not verified)

I bought a Silver Needles electric cone winder (which is the only electric one on the market) and quickly found that it wasn't nearly heavy-duty enough for the work I put it through.  These days I use an AVL double-ended bobbin winder with a wooden adapter that fits inside the cone.  It winds VERY quickly and is much less fussy than the Silver Needles electric cone winder.  The downside is that you do have to sit there with it as it winds, but I found that I had to babysit the Silver Needles conewinder as well because inevitably there would be some snag in the skein.

The only downside is that winding the cones does take some practice, and I had one cone's worth of yarn get tangled and come off the cone entirely.  But then, I've had that happen with commercial cones and with the electric cone winder as well.

I should say that I weave with fine threads (usually either 30/2 or 60/2 silk) so I put my cone winder through considerably more use than most people.  If you are weaving with thicker yarns, the Silver Needles electric cone winder might be OK, but I would advise investing in an electric double-ended bobbin winder - they're about the same price, and if you can get a woodturner to make you the adapter, the double ended bobbin winder will work just as well and is faster.  Plus, you can use it to wind bobbins!

I hope that was at least somewhat helpful...

Tien

Leslie M (not verified)

To wind cones I do the same as Tien except I use a styrofoam cone from my local florist.  It does wearout (the hole in the bottom keeps getting deeper), but it is inexpensive and easily available.  The other thing to watch is that the motor on your bobbin winder doesn't over heat.

cottageweaver (not verified)

Bob, Thanks for your efforts to solve the home cone winding dilemma. I'll look forward to learning more about your new product. I have a Silver Needles,and do use it successfully, but it can be a little quirky from time to time. I had trouble recently with winding, and will report that I did get excellent support when I called the company. The owner basically walked me through the adjustment on the phone - one of the metal guides had bent out of alignment. I also have a set of round wooden adaptors for my electric double-end winder that work fairly well. They hold the paper cone in place on the winder to allow horizontal winding of the cone. I have great hopes for Bob's solution, as I have a Nancy's Knit Knacks manual ball winder, and love it! I haven't motorized mine (yet). It's very well engineered and operates smoothly. I never have any problems with it, and I've wound lots of yarn with it. I use it as is for winding thin weaving wool into balls from Scandinavian skeins (Farogarn). Michael, your link was interesting, but there's no one at my house who could put that together!!

sarahnopp (not verified)

Wow Bob, nicely done! I love all the ideas and concerns you have worked through and resolved. I am passing on the link to your videa to a bunch of weaving guildies.

Sara von Tresckow

We needed as cone winder that would work for fine linen and wound up at McDermotts in Michigan. Chuck McDermott put us in contact with a firm in RI that remanufactures industrial cone winders - we took just a single head - and it was calibrated to the yarns we intend to use.

For finer yarns, especially linen, something like the ball winder approach in that video is not appropriate.jk After checking the pricing for the ball winder approach, the machine we purchased wasn't that much more and makes cones as professional as the ones from Habu.

Matt (not verified)

I also use my electric double-ended bobbin winder. I found a neat alternative to using a wooden adapter. I use one-hole rubber stoppers like these:

http://www.amazon.com/Rubber-Stopper-One-Hole-Individual/dp/B008BUQ00A

A google search will give you a zillion sources, and they are dirt cheap. The points of the bobbin winder fit into the holes in the stoppers. For a cone that comes to a point at the end, you only need a stopper that fits in the base. Get a second, smaller stopper if there's a hole at the narrow end of the cone as well. I just measured the cones that I have, and bought stoppers that would fit. 

The only disadvantage I found to using stoppers is that they are a tad "squishy", so the cone will wobble quite a bit as you wind unless you get the stopper(s) lined up evenly in the cone. 

As mentioned above, winding a good cone on a bobbin winder (that won't fall apart) takes some skill. I'm not quite there yet, but I've found that winding tightly makes a big difference. Also I've learned to be very careful not to wind much yarn near the tip of the cone. The thread can dig in and push the layers underneath towards the tip so that things loosen up, making it very likely that the whole thing will fall apart when you're winding your warp (ask me how I know!). 

Does anyone have advice for winding cones this way? I wind back and forth in small sections as if it were a pirn. I'm wondering if it might be better to go all the way across with each pass (like a bobbin), but move my hand quickly so that the windings are at an angle like a professionally wound cone. I may just have to get some cheap mill-ends and practice some more!

Matt in Boulder

ReedGuy

What are you winding cones for is my question? A manufacturer wound cone will fit onto a dowel and all you need do is fit an adapter down over the dowel first like a sleeve and never have to remove it , secure it permanent if you want, and the tube won't flop around if the sleeve is made wide enough that the cone will fit with friction over it. You could make it on a wood lathe and if the schools didn't remove shop class from the classroom, your son, daughter or nephew can make one for next to nothing. A tube/spool will still slide down the dowel and now rest on the wooden adapter if your not using a cone next time. Why as a home weaver, bother to make cone windings? You don't have to mimic every process to get a warp on the loom. ;)

I guess I'm in the dark, because your talking about needing cones, but I am not seeing why. I'm missing the grand picture. ;)

The original poster was talking about going from skeins to cones. I guess it depends on how you warp and how fine the threads are as to the need of using cones or spools. If I'm warping wool, singles (1/16" thick) and thicker, and I usually warp in 4's, all I do is set the skeins as they are onto a swift and a reel, 2 each, and warp away. I understand I am in a unique position to be able to make tools, but why wind cones? Where are you going with them and how are they used? Much easier to wind a spool if your going to wind anything for a rack. They could be closed or open ended.

Matt (not verified)

In my case, I wind my warp from two cones at a time. I do shorter warps, so I usually buy one cone at a time of a given color. It takes at most 5-10 minutes for me to make a cone, but winding with two ends at once cuts the time at the warping board/mill in half. I've played around with sectional warping spools etc. but cones are the only thing (that I can make) that unwind with zero drag. I've found that if there is any drag on the warp yarn from e.g. a spinning spool, winding the warp takes a lot more effort. Plus the warp ends become unnecessarily tight around my warping mill. It works well for me, now that I'm getting better at making cones :-)

ReedGuy

Use spools or wind spools and take 4 threads at once and do it in 1/4 the time. Too much fuss with cones, not worth it. ;) You've got something set up wrong if a couple of spools has that much drag. I've got a small rack I use with a mill and have turned closed end spools on there and nothing could be any easier. ;)

I also have a 144 spool rack and a tension box for the sectional, again nothing to it. Not trying to run you down, I'm just puzzled. I'd would have to see what's causing you frustration.

Sara von Tresckow

Like Matt, I warp with two coned threads for many reasons and find that cones are the best way to go, especially when plain beam warping with a mill. This applies for long or short warps.

Sectional warping has its place, but for many projects, it is a hassle. Sectional was developed for rag rug weavers and 12 epi - not linen at 40-60 epi.

For home use, the manual or makeshift winders mentioned here will work. We repackage linen yarn from large cones and need the certainty of an industrial winder so that the yarn doesn't slip or tangle. The cones we wind and sell are as professional as any from the yarn companies out there.

I once worked with winding spools and believe me, there are issues - alone the time needed to do the winding is worth considering. To wind with 4 threads, you need 4 cones or the tension will be odd. 

The original poster here wanted to sell kits with small cones as packaging - spools would not be appropriate because it would not be known how the weaver intendced to warp the loom.

ReedGuy

I have not been weaving very long as you know Sara. But I have not had issues with winding spools that would make it a frustrating process. To wind a cone at home, that would be a frustration because of the shape and slippage and so on. If one wants cones, use professional wound ones. Four cones, or four spools makes no difference to me when warping a mill. For me a cone is a hassle actually. But this seems like one of those arguements that no one wins I guess. A small project is really not that long to warp on a sectional. It depends on the method. I do not use sectional tie-on strings. However, I would not want to warp fine threads of several yards without a sectional. I would have a tangled mess in a heap. And yes I've used ties and chained warp in 10/2 cotton. No more of that, thank you. :)

Sara von Tresckow

Just FYI - 10/2 cotton is MEDIUM weight yarn, not at all fine - and believe me, with experience, plain beaming with a 2-thread cross is the most efficient and easiest method out there. Purchasing 2 cones of warp material is usually not too expensive or awkward.

Sectional beaming of large warps results in too much yarn waste - that is why so many weavers now use the AVL warping wheel that essentially makes one or two inch chains to go into a section. Also, for striped or mixed warps that are not repeating in every section, sectional warping is truly a hassle.

Until one gains skill and experience, beginner mistakes should really not be blamed on the method - until you've done that method a few times for practice.

Yarn sold on cones is the most practical packaging - it unwinds without difficulty and is easy to pack and ship. For anyone reselling yarn and repackaging it, cones are the way to go. Habu yarns in NYC depends almost completely on their coning equipment to deliver the exquisite little amounts of their specialty yarns.

ReedGuy

Sara, I understand where your coming from. You've been doing this for years. But you have to realize people get comfortable with their methods just as your are confident in yours. :)

However, I don't see how weaving up to the heddles, when traditioanally warped or using a sectional is any difference in waste. You cannot weave from the reed through the heddles. I could see there being waste if one does not weave up to the heddles. However, not every sectional setup wastes yardage like that. As far as striping, with planning ahead I see no hassle. For instance, if I want a set of 24 epi and I want to have a color change or stripe of blue then white alternating in the piece every 12 ends, 12 ends (spools) feed the white 12 spools feed  the blue and go through the thread box just as easy as all one color. I don't see the hassle. Even if I want just 6 threads of blue at wider spacing between wider bands of white all I have to do is interchange 6 threads which takes no more than 60 seconds. You'll do something similar on an AVL. I might go for instance, 6 - 1" sections before I want another narrow strip of blue. There really is no strong case against it.

And do not assume that I warp only by sectional, just because I have sectionals on my loom right now doesn't mean every other warp method has been tossed out the window. ;) When I do heavy wool blankets, I will be doing it the conventional method. I do only two blankets at a time, doublewoven and the wool is very easy to warp with traditional methods. :)

But, for me I like the sectionals for long warps that are using fine threads. 10/2 cotton is fine enough to me and 80 epi polyster is even finer. No way am I trying to warp that without a sectional. ;)

Believe me, I do not waste anything that is not necessary. :)

Sara von Tresckow

Sir,until you get some more experience, it is painful to have someone posting half truths on a public forum where there are others trying to learn to weave.

The waste in sectional warping comes from the inexact amount of thread on the individual spools - not loom waste - loom waste is the same regardless of method.

No matter how accurate your counter, you fill those 144 spools and have a few yards left on each when finished. If using inexpensive thread, it doesn't matter that much, but think linen or silk and you have a major cost factor. The time it takes to fill all those spools is also taken from somewhere and most people's time has a value.

Matt is entirely correct about the tug from spools when using a mill - the chain binds itself too tightly around the mill when using spools rather than cones.

You obviously have never designed warps that do not have a regular repeat that meshes with your section boundaries or you would know how difficult it is to use a sectional method or many spools and plain beaming - for eclectic fiber mixes or color changes, breaking and tying is  the most economical way in terms of time and money. Alone the time it takes to figure out how many spools with how many yards for an irregular stripe makes it too expensive for sectional warping.

Fine threads, properly prepared, beam on by any method - the secret if learning to handle the threads.

 

ReedGuy

Of course there is time to wind spools, that is only stating the obvious. Winding cones at home isn't free time either, 15-20 minutes per cone seems like a little time to me.  I use a counter to wind the spools with the proper yardage, which cuts on waste. My latest project using over 4000 yards and I have less than 10 yards of waste left behind on the spools (combined). That could even be less, because I always drew just a little longer off the spools when measuring. They were not conventional weaving spools from the factory. There are also various ways to figure the wastage, as in how long of a tail do you leave on your ends when tying on. Did you leave too much? Now figure that waste on 2000 ends. Say 2" extra was left on those tails on 2000 ends is over 100 yards of waste.

When winding by hand from 4 spools onto a mill, you need some tension anyway. With 4 spools it's not much. You can not mill a loose warp on a vertical mill, it needs "some" tension. And tension off 4 spools, which is typical of how I warp a mill, does not make a huge tension.

If your going to tell a story, tell the whole thing. ;)

Sara von Tresckow

Sir,

any tension put on threads when warping with a mill comes from your hands, not the yarn packages. If you are depending on the drag from spools, good luck - because the drag changes as the spools empty.

I recently had to wind a linen warp using those Swedish spools on a cardboard tube believe me it was MUCH more difficult than whern winding from cones or cheeses.

Nobody is talking about winding many cones at home - at best one or two to split a large cheese - get back with your stats when you've finished a warp using more than 50 spools and let us know your results, including waste. The yardage counters  have a margin of error, and in sectional beaming, it is usual to see that each spool has that margin of error included. Not to mention, that turning that beam with buildup, while workable, is inexact and some sections may have a little more or less than others, affecting the total needed on each spool. Bottom line is, with sectional warping from spools, you can eaily have up to 10 yards leftover - or worse, run out close to the end so that that spool has excess drag. And for ease of use, you need to put warp for many threads on each spool - do 1000 threads with 25 per inch, you need 50 spools times 20 threads times the length of warp. Yarn is elastic - you tell me how you plan to wind those spools so accurately that you have no waste.

The discussion about winding the occasional cone is so that the weaver has two to warp from - as stated earlier, for those not in industrial settings, warping with TWO threads and the finger held between is the most foolproof method - the two thread cross glides, needs no little handshake at the pegs, allows for postioning of stripes and materials, AND means that the weaver needs only TWO packages of yarn to complete the project.

The time spent winding a second cone from the first would be well spent - and if the weaver is not reselling those cones, some of the methods outlined here would be just fine. Matt's idea had considerable promise.

ReedGuy

No, not depending on drag or tension of the spools to warp on a mill. Just saying that tension is needed. And warping in 4's is just as common as 2's. When I turn my beam I also use my meter, because I go from section to section with the same spools (depends on the yards). I do not rely on the fact that one revolution of my beam is a yard. As you say, it is building up all the time with a growing circumference. I don't know why you compare two cones to several spools, why not compare 2 cones to 4 spools, since we are both talking about measuring on a mill. Matt is not on a  sectional. I only brought it up because I happen to use one, but I also use a mill. So far in this journey I have not had the troubles you keeping implying. You are really too presumptuous. Why not just ask for clarification about something your discussing instead of running off on a rant about something I have not even undertaken.

You have to realize that this is not your classroom. It is a forum to share information. The fact that some may find some morsals as questionable can never be avoided. If you want to control that, you need your own forum where you moderate the questions and answers. And twisting the meaning of someone's responses is not neccessary. Realize that there are many ways to do things. As I have said in an earlier post in this thread I may warp with more than one method I do not toss others aside. If I wish from time to time, as many do, to share my methods and ponder others' I should not be met with a prepondorant attitude that there is no other way but one.

Now with that being said, I still have a long journey to go to ever become a master of this art. If ever. In fact, I don't know if I want to. My main passion is to work with wood. I'm in the shop right now building a new project. Anyways, you will keep the interest of folks in the audience much longer when you realize being helpful is far better than dictitorial and pompous and come to the realization that there are many methods to arrive at the same goal. Please realize the teacher does not have all the answers.

Have a good day, and thank you for your help and maybe some understanding. :)

I have nothing further to add to this thread.

shroyer

Michael, we bought one of these expensive black cylinders from Russia. It is a component from an industrial winder. They must be stripping these from old machines or getting spare parts or something. The whole situation is very strange.

The cylinder alone weighs almost 3 Lbs. We tried to emulate the pattern that this cylinder uses and it would have cost quite a bit to engineer and to make the mold necessary to make a less expensive and lighter piece of plastic. The Russian part is actually machined in a hard rubberized/plastic material (it is not molded). It is a very expensive part and I predict we will never see it in a consumer or even commercial winder. Lastly, it needs a tremendous amount of pressure to force it against the cone to make it wind properly. You will notice in the Russion video that the operator has to use both gravity and a heavy weight to make it work. When it is mounted in an industrial machine, the big automated machine handles this task.

After playing with this approach for quite some time, we finally abandoned it. Instead, we decided to take the best of what we already have, a system that is field tested and peforming winding fucntions every day all over the planet. I also concluded that the only people that really need to wind cones in a traditional cone shape are the large mills, and the mills have the large industrial machines to do that. I believe that most ordinary users simply need a quality machine that will reliably wind yarn on a cone or tube. That is what our cone winder adapter will do. It is a hybrid ball winder that winds cones both manually and motorized. We also have electronic metering systems that will work with it.  

I expect shipments of our cone winder adapter to start near the end of March. We will also make available 7" paper cones (cone model #557 with a 1" opening at the top). Our system will also work with cone model #351 with a 1-3/16" opening as well as the cylindrical cones which have a 2" opening. The only cone we cannot use on the winder is the very pointy cone that has a 3/16" opening.

I will be making a 2nd video in the next few days that will demonstrate how the winder will not have any yarn getting tangled under the ball on the cone during winding as some observers of my initial video thought might occur. The video will also dispel the belief that pulling yarn horzontally from a cone requires a lot of effort. Our new method for mounting cones on our line of yarn holders is like magic. The yarn comes off of the cone so easily and I will demonstrate that in my upcoming video. 

Often times a picture is worth a thousand words, but a video is worth a million.

Thanks,

Bob Shroyer

Nancy's Knit Knacks

 

 

SallyE (not verified)

I'm thinking that those cylinders could be made fairly easily out of hard plastic with a 3-D printer.   Not that I have one, but I'm in the process of talking my husband into making one for me since he is retiring soon!

 

shroyer

Youtube link is:  http://youtu.be/HAHk1RjzYFc

The cone being demonstrated is a cone that I wound on our Cone Winder. Personally, I think cones would with our winder system are smoother than those wound at the mill in terms of getting the yarn off the cone but mill wound cones will also work like this. We have single, double and triple Yarn Pets in both 8.25" and 11.25" rod lengths. In addition to serving the yarn to the device being used, they prevent the cone from falling over. As you can see they also have a built-in tensioining system. When is the last time anyone has seen a built-in, adjustable tensioner on a cone stand?

Anyway, take a look at the video. I will have more updates in the near future as we begin to roll these systems out with the necessary cone adapter/attachments.

Thanks

Bob Shroyer

Nancy's Knit Knacks LLC

 

 

shroyer

You are correct, SallyE. A 3D printer could make that cylinder but the programming of the pattern would take some extensive effort. The unit cost would be very high also and definitely not be for production purposes (3 D printers are only good for prototypes and small volume manufacturing).

When we approached tool experts and engineers on how such a part could be made they had a solution often times but it was expensive. It turns out there are "landing and take-off zones" in the groove on either side of the groove so that when the yarn follows the groove going up the cylinder it has to "fly" over the groove going down and the widths and depths of these grooves changes.

But this project would make a great hobby for your husband when he retires, however!

shroyer

I have another solution which some weavers have mentioned is all that is required. It consists of rigid paper tubes (we have our own line of paper tubes which we call Yarn Ball Cores™ which are made from acid free paper). These tubes measure 5" long by 1.15" outside diameter. The user can wind a ball on a ball winder and then press this core against the top of the spindle and pull the ball onto the core (tube). They then have a ball on a tube.

But with the introduction of our Yarn Pet™ and our cone winder adapter, we can now take that tube/core and place it on our Yarn Pet's rod and feed yarn from this to another device. We have inserts that keep the tube smoothly rotating on the rod as well as o-rings that keep the ball on the tube in case it is not snug. The spindle that winds the yarn is only slightly larger than the core so the yarn passes easily from the spindle to the core and yet it is snug on the core.

Why is this interesting? Because a user of the ball/cone winder can now wind: balls, cones, and cores/tubes on the same machine. When these cones, balls, or cores are then mounted on our Yarn Pet™ series of yarn holders, the user can direct the yarn whereever they want to (loom, knitting machine, to an individual knitter, etc.). The Pets do this without adding any twist to the yarn.

Also, this solution is different because the ball/cone winder is commercial grade. It is not a plastic tool and it is serviced by an American company 7 days per week. The same machine can be motorized or used manually (the only one in the World that can do this). It can be easily meterized as well. The only thing it does not do is wind a traditional cone shape on a paper cone. It winds a ball on a cone instead.

I will have a video soon of these cores in action.

Sorry for being so wordy, but I wanted to make sure I gave you all of the facts about this new solution and why it is a good thing for weavers and other cone/tube users alike.

Thanks for listening!

Bob

Nancy's Knit Knacks   

shroyer

Matt - you mentioned that the stoppers you were using were squishy. We are using solid EPDM rubber stoppers and they are anything but squishy. We use them to center the cones on our various cone holders. They work great. In fact, they actually help the process in certain cases where we have the rubber surface against wood. The rubber ensures proper traction on the wood. We use the rubber stoppers in a wide variety of sizes to fit every type of cone or tube available.

What kind of squishy stoppers were you using?

Bob

shroyer

Here is a video that shows how our system secures 3 different sizes of cones. This is certainly a "first" for anything less than a full fledged industrial cone winder.

We embarked on making a cone winder that was heavy duty, motorized, and meterized. We have done that and except for those who plan to sell coned yarn and need a traditional looking cone style for resale purposes, the rest of you could benefit immediately from our system. Especially when you consider that we have eliminated the problem of retwisting/untwisting the yarn caused by removing yarn vertically from a cone.

To the very best of my knowledge, you will not find another commercial grade product that is motorized (and I mean under full machine control, not feeding the yarn by hand as Matt is doing) and which can be controlled by an electronic yarn meter. Even the industrial units that someone mentioned are more than likely not meterized, but if they are they are not electronically meterized which is far superior to mechancial metering systems (and a lot quieter).

We have addressed virtually all of the issues that we were faced with in the development of a cone winder and the only thing we failed at was winding the cone in the traditional manner.

But I gotta tell you, that the tests that I have run on traditonally wound cones is that they have "catch" points which results in changes in yarn tension as it is being removed from the cone. I have seen it time and time again. This problem does not exist on a ball wound onto our cones using our system. I believe that the ball winding process is a much smoother process than the cone winding process and the yarn is under less tension and stress, and as a result, performs better during removal when it is removed horizontally.

If the high price of these systems is what is troubling many of you, well, then I understand. It does, indeed, cost money to make good equipment. Just look at how much you probably had to spend on your looms. Unfortunately, the cheap stuff either doesn't work very well or for very long.

I plan to run tests performed by weavers and this should provide independent data to either confirm or disprove what I am saying. I will let you know how these tests do in a few months.

In the meantime, keep an open mind because there are not very many other companies doing what we are trying to do. We are trying to help all fiber artists solve a variety of fiber related problems that we can impact, including the weavers, by providing high quality, commercial grade, high performance systems.

Thanks

Bob Shroyer

Nancy's Knit Knacks

 

 

 

 

shroyer

I promised I would have a video demonstrating the problem of yarn being twisted as it comes off of a cone. We have completely solved that problem with our line of horizontal yarn holders - called Yarn Pets™ (and Yarn Pet Duos and Yarn Pet Trios).

These work by mounting the cone on a small wooden platform that slides up inside of the cone until it meets the interior walls of the cone. We then lock it in place with collars. The wooden disc is designed to rotate freely around the rod that it is mounted on with very low friction. We then mount a rubber stopper in the top of the cone. This stopper fits the rod perfectly. Then when we pull the yarn off HORIZONTALLY and run it through our adjustable tensioning guide, we can direct the yarn in any direction with super low drag and no twisting at all. Watch this video to see how I demonstrate how normally removed yarn flails all over the place when removed vertically as compared to my system which is under control and does not add twist.  

The nice additional feature of this system is that you can apply variable tension to the yarn while it is on its way to your other device. Variable tension adjustment, no twisting of the yarn, will not tip over, what else can you possibly need for a cone holder to do for you?

Please check out this video, the second half shows the demo. Be sure to see the toilet paper example near the end. It is most educational!

youtube Video

Thanks

Bob Shroyer

Nancy's Knit Knacks

 

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on