I'm looking for help to combine a waffle weave on 4 harnesses with double weave on the edges - so I have a two layer ruffle on the edges. I want to use the waffle weave in the center for the added draw-in to give the edges a ruffly shape. I have 8 harnesses - so I figured I could do it - but I've been stumped trying to figure the tie-up and treadling.Any advice? Many thanks in advance!

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

When mixing structures, you usually dedicate a set of shafts to each structure so the tieups can remain independent.

That means 4 of your shafts will be used to thread and treadle the waffle weave sections and 4 shafts will be used for the double weave edges - with 4 treadles used for this set. You cannot have an 8-shaft double weave here, you'd need 12 shafts for that.

The simplest example of this is when you mix plain weave and twill - you need a minimum of 6 shafts/6treadles. 4 for the twill and the other 2 for the plain weave.

sally orgren

Dedicate 4 shafts for the waffle weave in the center. Then allocate 4 shafts for the double weave edges. Say shaft 1+3 weaves the top layer, and 2+4 weaves the bottom layer of the doubleweave. The thing is, wouldn't this require more than one shuttle? With doubleweave, don't forget to consider the shuttle path.

ReedGuy

I missed the mark, or else the orginal post to this thread was edited. I was sure I read 8 shaft waffle at some point.

Sara von Tresckow

Waffle weave can be done on 4 shafts, as can double weave. The 4 shaft waffle does need 5 treadles.

You can also thread sections of a warp such that some have a single layer, sett being what one needs for a single layer of whatever is being used. Then others could have 2 layers and the appropriate sett.

Each treadle would be tied to both structures, and when the shuttle goes all the way across, the weft would mesh with the center structure, and again with the 2-layer piece on the other side. It might be necessary to shuttle a few rows through only the double layer on each side, but that would be quite possible and not all that difficult to do.

The most valuable lesson the Arn-Grischott doubleweave book (out of print and rare) was how to design each layer or portion of the fabric and then combine the threading, tieup and treadling. Approached with system and care, this might be possible - though the waffle might need some other structure with shrinkage to be substituted.

ReedGuy

Interesting and complicated. :)

I can't see how you can make two hinges in from the selvege. I know the sett would need doubling, but how do you make the dive at the fold to return when your into the warp, say 3 inch from the edge?

Sarah, I think in your last sentence, 3rd paragraph, that's what I was thinking could be done. Otherwise I would see the centre area getting behind one pick or two every time a complete round is made across the full width.

I do know you'd need the 5 treadles or you wouldn't get enough contour/relief to the waffle.

 

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

Is your 8-shaft loom a table loom or a floor loom? If the latter, how many treadles do you have?

kerstinfroberg

ReedGuy, it is "just" a question of threading and tie-up... :-)

I once wove a scarf with "fins" - the principle sketch:

To work out the shuttle-passes, I made another diagram:

The rest of the story is described on my blog, here. - this particular construction took 16 shafts, just because I wanted to be able to take the shuttle out and in at the right places. Making the shuttle-path diagram was the easiset way (that I can think of) to decide what/how I wanted it to work.

Looking at the second diagram, I think it can be used for the original question - only the right side "fin" should go towards the (right) selvage.

 

ReedGuy

Kerstin thanks,

That is exactly like one of my hand sketches when I was scratching my head last night. ;)

But I was thinking another method. Double the set at the outter edges. Tie up so the outter edges are double weave. On the right hand side the fold is on the left, and over on the left side of the fabric the fold is on the right. You would want to make sure that the fold catches more than one thread, maybe floats 3 or 4 threads at the middle point of a waffle or something for strength. Here is a sketch, with the edges separated for simplicity. The middle does not get double woven. On the return path you lower the upper fringe warp ends and bring the lower ones to the top to be woven.

I will read your blog link Kerstin. ;)

 

laurafry

The biggest challenge to doing this sort of combination will be getting the threads and epi correct for each section.  I'd use something half as thick for the waffle area because each pick is going to weave one pick of the waffle but only half of the threads for the double weave edges....Sampling will definitely be required for this methinks....  :)

Just out of curiousity, is there a reason you want to do this?  Remember that the waffle is going to take up a lot more than the edges and the tube areas will likely become quite um, ruffly?  Only weaving and wet finishing will give you all of the information you need before committing to a large project....

cheers,

Laura

ReedGuy

I was also thinking if done 'just right', it could leave the edge crimply and not just plain/flat. If it were me, I would not do waffle on the edges, but incorporate a point twill that will leave the warp undulating evenly on the far edge. It's just an idea. I intend to persue this further as an experiment, but at a later date. My loom is full of warp right now, and I do not make work out of weaving. It's just something to break up the days of winter. There is lots to learn about weaving. ;)

amyspins

Thanks All - a few reasons I want to do this. I am trying to combine two challenges - a crayon challenge (pull 4 random crayons out of a bag and combine them in a project) AND a waffle weave study. I didn't love the four colors I got together - so I wanted to do a "reversable" scarf - with the doubleweave ruffly edges (as seen in handwoven Sept/Oct 2010 Four Seasons double weave scarf) I wanted the waffle weave in the middle for that added draw in- in the pattern she used tencel on the edges and wool (camel) in the center - then wet finished it to get the wool to draw in - the tencel did not and voila - lovey ruffles on the edges. the double weave just on the edges is a nice touch. I've been sampling and sampling- off couse I'm usining two shuttles - one color way for the top layer and another for the under layer. But I can't get the treadling right. I have 10 treadles - 8 harnesses. If I thread for a waffle in the middle and doubleweave plain weave edges - and then I tie the 7 harnness to my first treadle- then treadle for my p.w. - I can get a "twillish" pattern in the center and get my double layered edges - but not a real waffle- I called the people at fiberworks (Bob I think) and asked him if his software could help me figure the problem out but he didnt seem to think I could get those two structures to work together.I might have to admit defeat!

amyspins

Thanks All - a few reasons I want to do this. I am trying to combine two challenges - a crayon challenge (pull 4 random crayons out of a bag and combine them in a project) AND a waffle weave study. I didn't love the four colors I got together - so I wanted to do a "reversable" scarf - with the doubleweave ruffly edges (as seen in handwoven Sept/Oct 2010 Four Seasons double weave scarf) I wanted the waffle weave in the middle for that added draw in- in the pattern she used tencel on the edges and wool (camel) in the center - then wet finished it to get the wool to draw in - the tencel did not and voila - lovey ruffles on the edges. the double weave just on the edges is a nice touch. I've been sampling and sampling- of course I'm using two shuttles - one color way for the top layer and another for the under layer. But I can't get the treadling right. I have 10 treadles - 8 harnesses. If I thread for a waffle in the middle and doubleweave plain weave edges - and then I tie the 7 harnness to my first treadle- then treadle for my p.w. - I can get a "twillish" pattern in the center and get my double layered edges - but not a real waffle- I called the people at fiberworks (Bob I think) and asked him if his software could help me figure the problem out but he didnt seem to think I could get those two structures to work together.I might have to admit defeat!

ReedGuy

A point twill would work with a waffle because the threading and treadling can be the same, but the tie up for the two weaves can be different. With this you have to look at your tie-up as if it's in 4 quarters. The opposite corners for waffle the other opposites for the other structure. Waffle would be good for the middle because the warp floats of the waffle will allow the hinge to be across 3 or 4 ends to strengthen the hinge. You would not want the hinge laced on one warp thread.

kerstinfroberg

I found this idea interesting, and wanted to see what I could make of it. Started with working out a possible shuttle path:

In this case, I started with the right plain weave edge, bottom layer, starting the shuttle from left to right (inserting the shuttle from "inside" the warp). The next pass would go from selvage to selvage (right to left), making the second plain weave pick in the bottom layer, the first pick in the waffle area and the first plain weave pick in the bottom left layer. Shuttle pass no 3 would make the second tabby pick in the bottom left layer (only that, exiting over the warp). Pass 4 will make the first pick in the upper tabby layer on the left. Pass 5 will go from selvage to selvage (leeft to right), making the second pick in the left tabby edge, the second pick in the waffle area and the first pick in the upper layer right tabby edge. Only one shuttle needed (in this case: for it to work, only one shuttle *possible*)

(This will make your waffle area very open - but as you stated you wanted the edges to ruffle... hopefully this open weave will shrink even more.)

To make the construction, I started with the waffle bit, reserving the back shafts for the plain weave edges:

I colour-coded the plain weave warps: turquoise for the bottom layer, purple for the top.

As the treadling for the waffle area repeats on 8 picks, I would need 4 of the shuttle-passes above (which each consists of 6 "ins and outs"). Next step was to go to liftplan mode in my software (which is PCW, by the way), and insert all 4 x 6 = 24 tabby picks on the edges. I let the selvage-to-selvage picks show on top of the warp.

After that, I inserted the waffle (as above) over the middle part. (Essentially it was done, then - but to make it more "readable" when describing the weaving procedure, I chose the gridded drawdown and exported it to Paint.) After some fiddling in Paint, it looked like this, the arrows indicating the path of the shuttle: (edit: I just saw that the waffle "model" at the top has one more plain weave pick than it should - I did use the above waffle for the construction. Too much work to edit the picture...)

This is 2 repeats, as I wanted to be sure I had the repeat correct.

However, this is not the best way to actually weave it. It would be so much easier to have all the "short" passes exit on top of the waffles. This makes the drawdown a lot more difficult to "read" (for me, anyway :-) - but here it is. It only takes 7 treadles.

Now - whether this will work as you want it to, I have no idea! The waffle area will be quite open, weft-wise, so I guess the sett would have to be adjusted to be more open -  and if the waffle's shrinkage will get the edges to ruffle "enough" will only be determined by sampling.

*If* you decide to try it, can we please know if it worked?

amyspins

Wow - this is so cool!

I wish I had some time to figure these programs out- what software are you using?Ok - I'm going to try this this afternoon- I have to take my 5 year old to the Aquarium today (as promised) then I'll turn into very bad mommy mode and let her play on the computer or watch Mulan for two hours while I rethread the loom to try this out.

I'm a little confused about the shuttle paths - but I'm a hands on learner so I think once I have the shuttle in hand, I'll be able to figure it out. In the bottom picture, are those really long floats in the weft? One of my sampling efforts produced those type of floats and that would not work at all for my scarf. And thanks so much for putting your experience to work for me! I'll post later and let you know how it worked!

Amy

kerstinfroberg

No - if you use the shuttle-path I used, all of the floats (and half of the picks in the edges) will be eliminated. Enter your shuttle from the left into the shed in the right-hand edge (both edge sections will give a shed - to eliminte that you will need another 4 shafts, but if the waffle section is wide enough, I think it will be easy to enter, or take out, the shuttle).

So: first pick in right-hand edge. Now your shuttle is on the right-hand side. Next pick should give a shed over the whole width - shuttle goes all the way to the other side. With your shuttle at the left-hand edge, use the left shed - take out shuttle over the waffle part. Next shed is again in the egde - shuttle in left edge from right to left (and the float will disappear, as the yarn is woven only in the edge section.) Fifth pick - you will get a shed over the whole width - use that, and get the shuttle to the right-hand side. Sixth pick, shuttle only in the right edge. You will have the shuttle on top of the waffle portion. You have now completed 2 tabby picks in all four tabby portions, and two picks in the waffle section.

This may not be the best treadling order. Try "shaft shuffler" and see if you can get it easier to memorize. (I think the shaft shuffler exists in all verasions of Fiberworks, but I may be wrong) It could also be that, using more treadles (duplicating some at strategic places) can give an easier treadling order.

amyspins

Kerstin -You are a genius - almost! It works - the waffle is perfect - draw in is great. The only problem is that the pw #6 treadling(actually that would be your #3 treadle - I had already threaded my loom with the waffle in the front and the p.w. in the back so I just reversed the tie-up and threading you gave me) puts the weft in the same shed - on each edge. I could weave it by snicking up an extra thread just to anchor the weft thread in the shed - but then I'll have a doubled thread every so often in the edges - only happens in the top layer. Not sure if this would bother me. I'm going to puzzle on this for a while - for now I'll just weave a bit before I cut it off and wet finish it and see how much wave I get - I'm so excited that I might actually get this to work. I will surely give you the credit at show and tell!

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

I am impressed, Kerstin. And I am curious, Amy, about the end result. I have a draft that makes a single ruffle down each side and has a type of double weave (on a tied threading) in the body of the scarf, wool and cotton in the double weave for differential shrinkage. This one is easy with 8 shafts and 10 treadles and it works. I had not tried with waffle weave, which I do not associate with scarves but the 4-shaft version does not have such long floats.

ReedGuy

I was thinking you were after a V edge not interwoven layers. :)

Kerstin, your a master of fibre arts. ;)

kerstinfroberg

Looking at just the plain weave portion, upper right-hand corner:

The two tie-ups for the upper plain weave layer are marked with the light blue - should give the  two opposite sheds, I think? (or I am misunderstanding you) In the upper right-hand corner, *if* treadling from top to bottom, fourth pick should not be woven on this side. It should stay at the left-hand edge. Picks 5 and 6 are opposites, I think.

I am probably misunderstanding something: why do you say that you reversed the tie-up and threading, if you already had the pw on the back shafts? If you mean you threaded (what I see as) "backwards", it would only give you "my" bottom layer on top -

(which means the colour-coding gets wrong, but you are using just one colour anyway, so...)

(The reason I see this threading as "backwards" is that I am right-handed  - when threading from right to left it is so much easier to go from the back shaft towards the front shaft, if at all possible. Laura recently blogged about this, here - and I am totally with her :-D

kerstinfroberg

what do you mean by "interwoven layers"? There are two separate layers on the edges, and one layer in the middle, which is what (I think) Amy wanted.

ReedGuy

Kerstin, it looked like a interwoven doubleweave. I guess I was mistaken. ;) I guess I can't see what separates one layer from another, except almost in the lower left quarter, but one shaft is pulled done there along with 3 in the upper left.

amyspins

Reed guy- there is a "V" on each edge of the scarf - that part is working perfectly.

THe four thread waffle is nice in the middle (Bonnie, it was a challenge - that's why I wanted to do it - no big floats with the 4-shaft waffle- I have alpaca/ silk superwash yarn and I needed to use all the same yarn so I couldn't use the wool to draw in in the middle (I would have in the end if I couldn't get this to work) so I wanted to use the waffle in the middle to give me draw in-

Kerstin, you're not the first to suggest I do things a** backwards! SMILE

I'm going to take all the sample stuff off- and dress the loom with my project yarn following the pattern you posted Kerstin and I'm sure it will all work out right. It's actually really fun to weave - though it'll be a bit time intensive. I have to go back to work tomorrow (I did not grade all of the 100 short stories I should have this weekend!) so now I'll be working evenings only on this - I'll update with photos as soon as I get it going.

I'm actually using four colors - two on the top layer and two on the bottom- so winding the warp is taking a little longer than usual. 24 epi. (48 for the double weave parts).

Thanks again Kerstin for sticking with me on this! Photos soon!

amy

ReedGuy

I'm glad it's all working out Amy, you have a good teacher (Kerstin). :)

amyspins

Bonnie, Check out Handwoven Sept. Oct. 2010 for the "Four Seasons Doubleweave scarf" it uses wool in the center and tencel on the edges to get the draw in- and the two layers - with the bottom peeking out a bit from the top is really nice, I thought. The Tencel stands up nicely for a collar effect.

Submitted by amyspins on