I want to mention this here; I'm pasting a posting I just made to the Tapestry list and to WeaveTech list about this. I want to mention this in all of the online forums to which I contribute since I'm seriously considering cutting off my online presence because of my distress over this matter. Please give me your thoughts and ideas, if you have time. Here's what I said at both the Tapestry list and WeaveTech: I'm a bit miffed and more distressed. For some reason it occurred to me to look up my name on Pinterest (which I don't subscribe to, by the way). I was disturbed to find that many of my images are shown there, having been pinned by others on their boards, apparently. I haven't subscribed to Pinterest yet and don't want to so don't know if I can have my images removed from boards or not. And I don't know about the time it's going to take for me to go through whatever steps I need to to try to have them removed. Quickly looking at the help section at the Pinterest site it seems I can post this code at the top of a page where images of my work is posted... but what a pain in the you know where that's going to be for any and every time I make a post to my blog, for instance. I have been posting to Facebook but am very close to either closing my account at FB or severely limiting my use of it to communication with family. I wonder if any of you also have a problem with this--the fact that your images can be lifted and used without your knowledge? I guess if one posts anything at all online then it's a free-for-all unless one takes extra measures to make it harder to appropriate the images. Thoughts? Tommye Scanlin

Comments

ryashani (not verified)

I do believe you can request that the items be removed, if they originated from your own site.  If you click on them, you will see that they are actually linked, rather than just uploaded and reposted.  If they are posted on another site (such as in a gallery or magazine), I think that site would have to make the request to have them removed.

I was iffy about Pinterest at first, because of rights issues like these, but I have changed my position on that.  I think that alot of people click through the photos to the originating site to learn more (or find other, similar, images), so it can actually drive more traffic to your site.  It is not someone swiping your art, rather it is them wanting others to see it because they like it, admire it, want to make something similar...

Now, if someone actually took the image, uploaded it to their own computer, posted it on Pinterest and claimed it was their own work, that is an entirely different story.

tommye scanlin

While not new to the use of the web, I made a choice sometime back not to use Pinterest or Twitter. I'm now reconsidering my Facebook account and may decide it's not worth it. I would like to continue to share my work online, especially teaching thoughts through my blog posts--but want to be the one who controls where it's seen and how it's used. Tommye

Doanart

I totally know what you are going through. I was a painter, but I have had to shift my work to sculpture in the last year because too much of my time has been going to chasing after these rude or ignorant people who lifted my images of my paintings for photobucket, Pinterest, t-shirts, posters, etc. I have tried watermarks, but they crop them off! None of these were used without my permission. You can request to have the images removed, but it is a hassle and not always successful. Legal action is cost prohibitive. Since I moved to sculpture I have less image theft. Perhaps you can adjust the images you use so the are at a slight angle or with other objects so that it is less desirable for being lifted and used without your permission. This is one of the new problems emerging in this digital environment. There is a sense of entitlement that people have when they see something they like online, that they can just take what they see. This also corresponds with a lack of respect for artists and fine craftspeople and the long hard and expensive work they do. As artists and craftspeople we need to educate those around us. If you see images of others being used without credit, tell the person, inform the artist. At the very least, get them to list credit to the originator of the work! Too luck.

Doanart

I don't agree with ryashani. People post other people's work perhaps innocently, but fail to get permission or give credit. Then other people lift that image, and on and on. I know of artists who have seen their work being used for posters, greeting cards, banners for a conference, all without her permission and the images were traced to photobucket where someone had cropped her name off the image and posted it. Then people took that image and the snowball went on from there.

ryashani (not verified)

I think it is very different to swipe art and produce something like greeting cards than it is to post it on Pinterest (which links through to the source).  The first is a criminal act (and should be prosecuted), the second is, in my mind, honoring the artist (IF, and only if, that link really clicks through to the originial source).

I used to feel differently about Pinterest (much the way you many of you seem to feel now), but I have changed my stance on it over the last year and actually think it is an interesting resource and not a bad way for people to discover some of the lesser known artists out there.  (Of course, others are entitled to a very different opinion.) 

tommye scanlin

I am not opposed to others having my image at their blog or possibly another site like Pinterest IF THEY ASK for my permission! I have been asked before and, so far, have always said yes. Likewise, I have posted the work of others at my blog and have used others' work in teaching--but I ask for permission and given credit when I've posted/used. That's my primary objection here, that I didn't know my images were out there without my knowledge of where they're appearing. If they link to my original source at my blog or even here at my projects page at Weovolution, well and good. However, they were used without my permission to do the linking. That's what I'm objecting to and trying to find a solution for--other than removing all of my images, as much as I can, from the web. Thanks again for your thoughts. Tommye

ReedGuy

You can use Google Images to see who is lifting your images to.

Sara von Tresckow

From the start of my web presence over 10 years ago I realized that if I was really protective of an image, draft or idea, it wasn't a good idea to post it.

We have had a busiess idea on our site also manufactured by the same maker using one of our poor quality web photos. The item in question is neither patented nore copyrighted, so we just live with it.

Life is too short to chase every link that I didn't give permission for.

It astounds me how many images show up when I search my name - most of them in appropriate places to make some nice advertising for my work and business - even just showing work at a guild show exposes it to copying of some sort. If you take your work in public, it runs the risk of being used again by someone. The fashion industry actually thrives on it because the affordable clothing makers doing knockoffs keep ordinary folks well dressed.

Artistry

Tommye, you got my interest up so I went to Pinterest and there's a Tapestry Diary of mine with no credit to me what so ever. if there's a piece of mine , there's probably quite a few people from weavolution "pinned". I exhibit some of my work and want the credit for it. Yeah, I'm irked! I've had this happen to me before on Facebook , that time the person gave me credit but did not ask permission. I would not have given permission since it was going into an upcoming exhibit, I wanted people to experience the piece in person. After the opening if they had asked, I would have said fine. It seems like it should be clear cut but apparently isn't. I would just miss so much if artists like you decide unsubscribe.

Artistry

Pinterest does give me credit, I'm still irked though.

ReedGuy

When I post stuff of my own to the web, I don't care who uses it or it wouldn't be posted. I've not seen anything where I didn't post it and I've been around the web for a long time. :)

As the experts say constantly, don't post what you don't want the world to get a hold of and use. ;)

Cheryl'B

take a look at the very top of the page (without being logged in).  There is a link from your blog to share (see pic below, red arrow points to share area).  I am sure at one of these share sites you can pin it to pintrest.  It is all the rage now.  And yes, while things are pinned without any thought and I am sure innocently, I truly believe it is still wrong.  So in reality, it could have started from your own blog.  You may want to check your blog settings (I don't blog) to see if you can stop the sharing ability.  Sorry I can't offer a solution.

Doanart

I hate it when people give permission to the unscrupulous people to use images found online without permission when they say things like," if you don't want it used don't post it." Some of us are artists who make a living from our work. The Internet is a tool for making it possible to survive as an artist. The solution is not as simple as just don't post images. This kind of answer is insensitive and ignores the real issue: that we shouldn't be allowing this kind off behavior on the Internet.

Sara von Tresckow

There are ways of formatting images sent to web sites  - collages, combined images, low resolution, etc. that allow professional artists to portray their style without going into minute detail - coupled with an inquiry form or similar for interested potential customers. I have a friend with a weaving studio - high end weft faced rugs - the web site is fairly sparse but gives a good impression of style and quality - ane then invites the viewer to make contact through the inquiry or a visit to the studio.

Honestly, I've been running a web site now for 12 years, we get around 100 distinct visitors daily, and checking pinterest and goodle images, there isn't anything major our there that compromises any of my work.

Even displaying one's work in a studio or gallery opens it up to others analyzing form and technique for possible "copying". There is also the possibility that others photograph your work as it hangs and pass those photos along - I did find something like that on flickr - know who did the photo and where it was taken - find it a nice compliment.

Note, I do not "blog" but have a secure hosted web site and the email addresses are all contained in that domain - no freebies like gmail or hotmail. This gives me a sliver of privacy. 

 

rstovin

Just wanted to add my two cents - I agree with ryashani and Sara on this issue.  I find Pinterest a useful network to get ideas and inspiration.  Personally, I enjoy showing off my work and hoping it might inspire others to become artisans in their own right.  I am flattered when I see that someone has pinned an image of my work to the site.  I'm not trying to make a living at it, however, and I certainly wouldn't like the idea of having my original projects promoted as someone else's work.

tommye scanlin

I appreciate the thoughts about my concerns with Pinterest.  I will deal with this issue now in whatever way I can manage.  My blog, through blogger (a Google product) is set to allow viewing but I can't change the share items that Cheryl'B pointed out.  I do want to share about my work, that's why I've blogged for a number of years.  However, I would like to know when others are sharing it on their own pages or at Pinterest.  For now, I'll see how it goes.

It's always something, isn't it?  Think Gilda Radner said that.

Happy weaving to all,

Tommye

Michael White

Tommye and everyone else.

When you sign up for facebook you give them permission to use anything you post anyway they like. Your pictures your email files becomes their property.

 

Michael

Quoted from Facebook’s legal terms:

“For content that is covered by intellectual property rights, like photos and videos (IP content), you specifically give us the following permission, subject to your privacy and application settings: you grant us a non-exclusive, transferable, sub-licensable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use any IP content that you post on or in connection with Facebook (IP License). This IP License ends when you delete your IP content or your account unless your content has been shared with others, and they have not deleted it.”

 

loomyladi (not verified)

This is an ongoing issue and will continue to be an issue in the modern world. There are college courses taught specifically on copyright issues for images (I'm taking one in the spring). It is, in part, an educational issue. The public (users) need to be educated on the dos and don't, but you will always have those that don't play by the rules, even if they know them. I think there is good information in this thread and excellent communication. I appreciate the views and opinions of all on this topic. I may actually use the concept of the thread and the relevant discussions as part of my final project for a Technology in Education Course, where we've been discussing the use of social media. Yes, I'll contact you before I "quote" you.

ReedGuy

It's up to individuals to use discression when they expose their work to the world. You simply have to make the right choices your comfortable with. Most people do not read the agreements and so forth of a website or online service they are using. Most often just click agree and move on, then later discover "what is this?". And chances are you will be on your own to fight for and defend what is yours. If there is something you want to protect and hold sacred, be smart and keep it that way.

Badfaerie (not verified)

I'm confused as to what the upset is about.

I fully agree that you should have control over your work and intellectual property. So, don't think I'm one of those free grabber types. But I don't see how pinterest in any way even crosses a gray area when used according to the site's terms and conditions.

Let's look at an "old tech" example. You have your work published in a magazine, or a brochure for a gallery exhibit, or even your own brochure for your work. I take the images from those sources, and maybe the articles, cut them out and pin them to a cork board I keep in my studio and use for things that inspire me. When someone comes to my studio, I tell them about my inspiration board and let them look at the snippets and pictures. Heck I may even have photos of your work that I took myself at a public display that you don't even know about!

This is not a case that most people would have a problem with. If you find out that your images are on my inspiration board you aren't going to ask me to remove them, and if you do, the courts aren't going to back you and force me to remove them (under the circumstances I'm positing here). All of this falls pretty firmly under fair use and all of that.

This is really what Pinterest is, a virtual cork board for things on the web that interest and inspire you. As such, it is more free advertising than infringement for artists. If the items on Pinterest (and any other website, service, and/or social network) are falsely used or attributed, then that is a separate matter.

Getting upset because your work appears on a Pinterest board without your permission can, and probably will, generate some ill will amongst the people that are likely current or future customers. If someone "pins" an item they plan to buy for their room redecoration project, and you find out and send a stern cease and desist, they are not very likely to make that purchase.

I caution all of us to be very careful how protectionist we get with these things. Just because we have a right to do something doesn't mean it's a good idea.

tommye scanlin

... just a quick reply to your thoughts here, Badfaerie. I appreciate hearing what you've got to say about it. However, there is at least one image that doesn't link back to my site from which the image came. Also, I am not putting my images up in a sales site. So your comment about " ... generate some ill will amongst the people that are likely current or future customers." doesn't apply in my case to my images of my tapestries. I have posted about my work at my blog and I use it to share what I'm working on as well as other assorted things about the making of tapestry that I think others might find helpful. My works are also shown at the sites of a few non-profit arts/crafts organizations, as well as here at Weavolution. Since most of my career was spent in the academic world where giving credit to sources used was essential when making presentations of any kind, I am adapting slowly to this medium of free-for-all that web interaction seems to be. I do appreciate any and all of the feedback from those of you who are using Pinterest for your own purposes. I'm learning quite a bit more about how control of my images might take place and I'll make future decisions about what I'm sharing based on some of this conversation. Tommye

ryashani (not verified)

Badfaerie just stated the reasons why my thinking changed about Pinterest.  Like some here, I first saw it as "swiping" images, but realized (when I saw that the items actually do click through to the original sites) later that it is just a new way of sharing things.  I hate to say this, but this type of social sharing is really here to stay and I think artists, especially, should make the best - and the most - of it.


Again, I make no excuses for those who remove the images from the source, and re-name them, or who post another's work as their own and worst of all, those who swipe images and use them for their own profit.  This last group should indeed recieve a legal cease and desist should be prosecuted.

Slipstream (not verified)

VARA (Visual Artists Rights Act) the copyright act as synchronized with the World Trade Organization standards gives one rights beyond thos we are accustomed to. One of the more interesting rights is the way the end user uses your material.  Material is now assumed to be copyrighted automatically and carries certain rights even as to display.  Even if the material has become the property of another entity can not be used in a manner that the artists deems inappropriate.  This is a body of law that is still evolving through court cases but it has been held that displaying and even disposing of the item must be done in a manner that does not impugn the work of the artists. Recently a beach city here in California (City of Carlsbad if my memory is good) commissioned an art work and after it had been installed on a bluff overlooking the ocean became controlversial.  The City decided to remmove it and had to comission the artist to do the actual removal so as not to violate VARA.  I use watermarks and a digital signature within the code generating the picture to maintain identification of the origins of the art.   Unfortunately there are capture programs that grab the image off the screen (I know, I use one myself for research) so if I really want to keep something private I keep it off the Internet. Good luck, it is a battle better avoided than fought. I understand your pain!

I am not licensed to practice law and this is my own personal interpretation used only for discussion and entertainment.  A licensed attorney in your State is the appropriate person to seek advice from regarding interpretation of the law.

 

ReedGuy

That's California. And sounds a little over the top. I doubt it would fly here in court. WTO hasn't the teeth they think they have. It never worked with the softwood lumber when they ruled in Canada's favour. It was completely ignored. Any ruling they make is none binding.

sally orgren

It may be "fair game" as long as you are willing to accept the consequences, and I think we are still figuring this out. Real examples:

1) An organization in Colorado lifted an image from the Internet (from a photo site like flickr, etc.) of a couple in New Jersey and used it in their political advertising this fall. Because the couple had no idea their image was being used, let alone never granted permission for use, that organization is now being sued.

2) One of my clients used an agency for their billboard campaign. The agency used images of individuals from one of the websites that offers cheap, copyright free images. One of the models featured in the campaign saw the billboards and sued the college because when they were photographed, they did not grant permission for their image to be used by the institution. The school lost. (Not sure what penalty the agency had to pay or which web site was involved, but it resulted in our gaining a new client.) 

3) I saw a beautiful medium-sized tapestry someone wove and excitedly posted to one of our weaving forums a few years ago. (It was not Weavolution). I am sure the weaver was flattered when they were asked if their project could appear in one of our textile publications. However, the actual image appeared postage-stamp sized with a short blurb on the letters to the editor page. Although it might have been an honor for that initial recognition, I am not sure if the weaver understood s/he may never enter that piece in a juried weaving competition in the future because it had now appeared in print.

4) A related story. One of my weaving buddies blogs, and she had a project that caught the eye of another print publication, outside the weaving community. Because that publication featured her project in an article about popular blogs, she had to make the hard decision to abandon any hopes of entering that project in future juried weaving shows (her intention when making the item), and accept the recognition for possibly a wider audience of non-weavers.

Tommye, I think this discussion has been helpful so we can all figure out where our comfort level is within this medium, what is ethical (or not), and look at possible unintended consequences of our online activities. Thanks for asking the question! 

---

Full disclosure — I don't make my living at weaving. At most, I aspire to enter a juried weaving show from time to time, if I have a project I think is worthy. I DO enjoy sharing and viewing everyone's photos on these forums as a learning process, and I appreciate the spirit of sharing for which Pinterest was created, although I do not participate myself in that venue as yet.

Sara von Tresckow

"In print" disqualilfying a piece from juried exhibits is a bit of a stretch. There are guidelines as to the nature and scope of the publication. I chose not to enter a garment in the fashion show for Long Beach, but was assured by HGA that the garment being in CW Journal did not count as being in a widely circulated publication - since it was for members only and not for sale at newsstands. Likewise for posting on a personal web site or blog.

The artist needs to check with the specific shows for their guidelines. I seriously doubt that a thumbnail in a byline counts as "publication" - the featured item might disqualify it.

SallyE (not verified)

I find this discussion interesting.   When it came up, I started doing some research into it, reading articles, etc. 

For what it's worth, my take is that Pinterest pretty much admits that it's a copyright violation to pin copyrighted material at their site.  They were forced to come up with the below policy that lets copyright owners ask that their images to be removed.   If it weren't a violation, they wouldn't need this policy:

http://pinterest.com/about/copyright/

It's interesting to note that this policy helps protect them legally from these violations, and so puts all of the risk onto the user who pins the material.

But what a pain in the backside to have to do this for each image that you have copyrighted!

 

 

Badfaerie (not verified)

I still caution everyone here to avoid false equivelancies. Posting something on Pinterest is not like taking an image and using it in a print publication, your own blog, or other social media website. I strongly recommend that you learn and understand the site and how it works before you get upset about content appearing there. Pinterest is much like the old webrings and drives traffic to the "pinned" artist. This is usually considered a good thing in the web world.

Now, of course you do have the right to insist that nothing you own the rights too gets pinned on the site. This takes a lot of policing on your part, generates ill will with potential visitors/customers/students and isolates you and your work from a source of exposure.

And in reality that is what it all comes back too. We put our work on the web for other people to see.

There's an emerging new set of rules for how to best control your content on the web. Most of them are evolving social convention and actual law is lagging behind. It is completely true that anything you put on the web can be taken and used in a manner that you do not approve of. Further more, it is time consuming and costly to exercise you rights and remedies. It is not right, but it is how it is.

I ask, is this a new thing or is it just that you are able to more easily find the violations? Before Google, it was much less likely that someone far away would ever get caught in these types of nefarious deeds.

I take the approach of picking my battles.

And for disclosure, I am a web application developer in my day job. I do everyday deal with the issue of theft of intellectual property by competitors and have to judge the costs and rewards of pursuing actions against the thieves.

Kelly Range

Thsi is all well and good (or bad) but it is nnot about weaving.

Peace 

sally orgren

Posting an image of your project on forums, blogs, or online in general is typically not a problem for the handweaving community—say you want to enter something in Convergence, or other similar venues. It seems it is when your project appears in print that the conflict arises for the jurors. 

Sara, interesting point about profit vs not-for-profit.

Cheryl'B

this thread and find all the views, opinions, and information very interesting. Shows the diversity in the community.

SallyE (not verified)

Badfaerie, you wrote "Pinterest is much like the old webrings and drives traffic to the "pinned" artist. This is usually considered a good thing in the web world."

Since you are a web developer, I'd expect you to feel that way.  What I think you are missing is that ARTISTS don't feel that way, and it's their images that are being violated.  Not everything that is considered "good" in the web world, actually is good just because the "web world" feels it is. 

 

Badfaerie (not verified)

Tell me how the artist is being violated? Yes, I am a web professional, but I'm also a fiber artist and fiber art teacher as well. I do have a dog in this fight on both sides.

There are multiple issues being discussed here and they are not all equal. There are the web behaviors that are positive which promote the content we make available on the web, behaviors that are negative which take our content and attribute it to someone else, and many degrees in between.I use the word behaviors because it best describes the actions of viewers and consumers of our content. These behaviors may be assisted and encouraged by services, such as Pinterest, Twitter, Ravelry, Weavolution and so forth.

Let's not forget, the only reason to put anything on the internet anywhere is for people to see it. If we put it on a blog or any other unsecured and minimally restricted venue, we make it accessible to people we may not know/meet/have any other contact or relationship with. This is a choice we make. If no one sees our content, it is a waste of time, bandwidth and storage space to put it out there.

So, it IS a good in the internet at large, and fiber artist bloggers included, to have services that drive traffic to our content. Services that drive targeted traffic of of viewers that are most likely to consume our product (the content) are highly prized and well paid. Billions of dollars are spent to get specific people to sites and any grassroots service and/or behaviors that generate this type of traffic without financial outlay is very sought out.

Now, once the people have visited the site, they have the choice to perform certain behaviors with the content they find. If they like what they see, they may do good things like write a post on their own blog with a rave review and link back to your site, post a link on Facebook, twitter, pinterest ect, recommending you to their online associates. Email a link to friends. All of these are things that an artist/content creator wants to encourage as much as possible.

By taking a wholesale approach of "If I see this anywhere else I'm going to issue a take down", you are discouraging this grassroots, word of mouth advertisement for the content you create, and by extension your product, whether that be your services as a teacher, your items for sale, the books you write and the like. At the same time, you discourage others from consuming the content you create and supporting your product, you generate ill will.

I am in no way excusing illegal activity, plagiarism and other truly harmful to the artist behaviors. Those should be handled aggressively without mercy.

What I do strongly suggest is that you really look at each case of suspected intellectual property theft and as a few questions before you decide what action to take:

Is this being falsely represented?
Is this benefiting the person who posted/pinned/linked my content more than it is me?
What are my real losses from this behavior and what are my gains?Can I use this to promote and generate good will to my brand?

The people and companies that do the best job of utilizing the internet to promote and protect their brands see Pinterest, FB, Twitter (Ravelry, Weavo, ect and so forth) as opportunities not liabilities.

That being said, you, me, all of us who create web content and therefore hold property rights on that are fully within our rights to aggressively seek to protect that content in any way we feel is necessary. If you feel that is the best way to protect your brand, please do so. You would find it much less headache to just not put the content on the web in the first place. 

Sara von Tresckow

Regarding fiber arts, weavers and dyers have been secretive about their work and processes for absolutely ages.

The origin of the countermarche loom is essentially unknown. Discussed this once with Peter Collingwood. We have plenty of illustrations from the 12th century forward of horizontal counterbalanced looms - some with many shafts, some with two weavers, but no illustrations of countermarche looms until the French technical encyclopedias of the first half of the 18th century. These illustrations are of technically sophisticated, well ripened CM looms - obviously they are nothing new. Why don't we have any earlier pictures? Same reason as all these copyright discussions - the weavers didn't want the competition to profit from their loom design and production methods.

Dyeing recipes are much the same - there are lovely examples of fabrics dyed with vegetal materials with no good way for us to find out the recipe as the dyer took it to the grave with him rather than let the competition know his secret.

It is for each of us to decide how open we choose to be with publishing of any kind, including the web. Most of the legal cases that I hear of are rather odd - with the person making the damage claim often being incapable of earning that kind of money with the original photo or product. If you are aware of the consequenses of posting your information publicly in a forum such as the Internet, it is unseemly then to play the "victim" of improper use of said information. If it is that valuable, just keep it to yourself.

There was a recent op-ed in the NYT titled "Thank you for not sharing" about the shallowness of the "shared information" running out there.

tommye scanlin

... lots of food for thought. I do appreciate every comment made about the issue I raised about Pinterest. I'll be doing further thinking about this to guide my posting of images of my work on the web. Like someone mentioned earlier, what's this have to do with weaving? Not much about the creation of fabrics but quite a lot about the way we share with others. I've certainly learned a bit over the past couple of days of comments here and on other forums. Now, I'm ready to go back to reading about the weavings you're all doing. In that spirit--and in the spirit of sharing about my weaving I've posted a just completed project in my projects. I wish everyone of you happy and productive weaving days. Tommye

ReedGuy

I've been putting a warp on all day here. Got it  all tied up and ready to weave tommorrow.

That's the spirit. :)

Badfaerie (not verified)

I took 18 towels off the loom last night and got them serged. Finishing them tonight and Christmas is done early!

endorph

my comment above disappeared so I will try again - I have been following this thread with interest. As a librarian / archivist in a museum setting I deal with copyright and use isses almost daily. Both in having our images being used as well as us using other peoples images. I have found that there is not a black and white answer for any of this - and the US and International copyright lawas are not much hel either unless you are a copyright attorney. This is not a new issue - I was dealing with artist rights and fair use back in the days when slide shows were the going thing - I find images from and of the museum and our exhibits plastered all over the Internet - most used appropriately with propoer credit being given, but other not so much. We have to decide which battles are worth the time and money to fight and which we just have to live with. Unfortunately as technologies change the issues of copyrights, artist rights and fair use will remain the same. It is throught converstaions like this one that we help to keep awarenee of the issues alive.

Artistry

Thank you Endorph! " it is through conversations like this one that we Help to keep awareness of the issues alive". I have found this discussion such an eye opener. But most of all I no longer have this knee jerk reaction of being wronged. I am processing. All I know for sure that as a artist is I want to make art and I want to reach people to show it too. I am working on another Tapestry Diary , one large Tapestry. And Tea Towels which I plan to post on Weavolution:) don't hold your breath for the large tapestry though!

Artistry

And what I mean about the large tapestry is that it will take a long time to make!

Slipstream (not verified)

I don't often post on here. Unfortunately there is a lot of misinformation that gets related.  If you take some time and actually read my post on the Visual Artists Rights Act, right there in the title is a clue that it is not a "California thing" since I quoted 17 USC section 106A. USC stands for United States Code.  The word "Act" in the simple title would indicate it to have been a law passed by the Congress of the United States of America and signed into Law by the President.  No where did I suggest that anyone outside the US follow this law.  Now, I understand that someone outside the US might not understand that this was law but to call it a "California thing" is just plain inaccurate. Dismissing something you don't understand as trivial and useless does nothing to further the understanding of one's rights under the laws of the United State of America and I believe that the original poster is located in the US so my response is be applicable.

Badfaerie (not verified)

Actually, VARA would not apply in this instance. There are 2 main things that are necessary.

First, the photo's themselves do not meet the standards of protected works

VARA provides its protection only to paintings, drawings, prints, sculptures, still photographic images produced for exhibition only, and existing in single copies or in limited editions of 200 or fewer copies, signed and numbered by the artist. The requirements for protection do not implicate aesthetic taste or value.

Images posted on the internet are not produced for exhibit only and internet images are not eligable to be a single copy or signed limited edition.

Also, the act protects moral right of artists against specific acts,

 

VARA exclusively grants authors of works that fall under the protection of the Act the following rights

right to claim authorship

right to prevent the use of one's name on any work the author did not create

right to prevent use of one's name on any work that has been distorted, mutilated, or modified in a way that would be prejudicial to the author's honor or reputation

right to prevent distortion, mutilation, or modification that would prejudice the author's honor or reputation

 

The only condition that might apply would be the last 2, if the images were deemed to qualify for protection. If the image was distorted, mutilated or modified and the artists reputation or honor was harmed by it, they could seek to prevent the alteration or have their name removed from the work.

 

ReedGuy

Slipstream don't forget that the internet is global. It's not so cut and dry as someone from the US having their images used by someone in Denmark for instance. This for example would have to look at treaties and agreements between countries. That being said, Canada and the US being neighbors pretty much follow the same laws by treaty. If someone in Canada is hacking someones site in the US then there is consequences for instance. This example has happened more than once in the last decade. But maybe this is not so cut and dry with other nations with people from there doing the web hosting and the heisting. My point is that the WTO is at best a mediator that makes non binding decisions. And as to the comment about being a California thing, it's related to your example which seems so idiotic about taking down an art exhibit and if I recall you said it happened in California.

Erica

Those who are interested in blocking pinning of images on their website, please note you should be able to put the code <meta name="pinterest" content="nopin" /> before the final hearder tag in your template this will add this code to every page on your site, so you will not have to add this to every page. If you only want selected pages to be blocked from pinning you will have to either do a custom template that is only applied to those pages, or you will have to do it on a page by page basis.

I hope some people find this helpful.

Cheers,

Erica

Submitted by tommye scanlin on