Hi all,

I'm curious if anyone has not used sticks, kraft paper, shelf lining, wallpaper, etc. when winding on the warp beam. I've been weaving for years now and have always used something back there. But I'd be interested to know just how bad things could get if just once I didn't pack the warp. Seriously, how bad could it get? I imagine a lot would depend on the yarn and the pattern. For simplicity sake, let's just say a straight twill using non-fluffy yarn. Right now I have 12 yards of Tencel needing to be beamed. It's cheap enough that if I tried not using packing material that I wouldn't really care if the warp got wonky. But I have a suspicion that it probably wouldn't matter. 

Now I know some of you will be aghast at this suggestion. But this particular project is only five inches wide. What do you think will happen? (Other than the weaving police giving me a citation.)

Comments

laurafry

On very short warps it's not an issue. OR, if you use warp flanges.  OR if you have a sectional beam where the dividers act as warp flanges.  But a 12 yard long warp?  With Tencel, which has little to zero elasticity?  The upper layers will likely cut down through into the lower layers causing tension problems.  But I've never actually tried it with Tencel on such a narrow warp, so.....might be worth an experiment?  Do let us know how it turns out if you do try.

cheers,

Laura

sally orgren

1) Beaming smoothly under consistently high tension might work. (Weighted at the front the whole time.) I would not suspect a successful result from a weaver who employs the "jerk the bouts and beam a few rotations" method.

2) A bigger beam in back (vs a smaller circumference beam) would improve your odds of less problems. The warp isn't covering itself as much, so less of a chance to bite down irregularly into previous layers if they were not beamed as consistently.

3) Also, I imagine it depends on your loom type and how you attach your warp at the back—do you need to cover lumpy bundles, cords, or knots, or do you just slide the warp loops onto a rod?

If your warps are typically rock hard, using paper or not, you might be a good candidate to give this a try. A mushy warper, well...

When you visit commercial looms, they don't use packing paper. So yes, it IS possible.

(So who ARE these weaving police and what does a citation look like?)

Sara von Tresckow

The industrial warping machines have all manner of built in checks to assure that the warp winds on without issues.

The use of flanges also contains, if I am not wrong, a slight right/left back and forth while winding on so that the bed forms a mini x-spooling to assist in not cutting through.

For most home looms, there is no easy substitute for packing material.

Del (not verified)

I remember reading, yrs. ago, that Scandanavians often beamed fine linen without packing. I've never been brave enough to try.

Sara von Tresckow

Perhaps without packing, but certainly not without flanges.

kerstinfroberg

Because of where my beam cords are placed,  I often do the first turns without packing for narrow warps. I would not try to beam more than, say, 3-5 metres, though - but that can be because I'm not adventurous (sp?) enough...

The reason for my practice is described on my blog, here. (What I don't write in that post is that, for some reason, I don't have problems with wider warps)

Weavin Steven

Based on the comments, no one has really tried beaming with no packing, at least on semi-longish warps! So I may boldly go where no one has gone before. I was all set to try it on this current 12-yard warp. Then I realized that this warp is actually tied onto an existing warp and not directly onto the warp beam. Thus I have knots which will certainly mess things up without packing. The grand experiment will have to wait a bit. But I'll post a follow-up once I do try it.

Regarding flanges, I walked around my local hardware store to see what would work. L-brackets seem good but I couldn't find any that didn't have a tiny gap where the two pieces of perpendicular pieces of metal come together. That's because the brackets I saw were not exactly formed at a perfect 90-degree angle at the "L." Rather they were bent and not soldered/welded. 

laurafry

The reason I haven't gone without packing on longer warps is because when I did go ahead and not use any, I wasn't terribly happy with my results.  The same with beaming without tension.  The one time I used the 'jerk' method of applying tension to a 15 yard long cotton warp it was a disaster.

I usually put at least 10 yards or more on the loom so it's just easier to be consistent about my methodology.  I now use a warping valet and have found that my warps are usually nice and firm with few tension issues.  And using one has really knocked a lot of prep time off - why spend hours beaming a warp when it can take minutes.  :^)

Ultimately if someone is happy with their results they don't have to change a thing.  It's when they are *not* happy that they should know another process.  The more tools we have in our toolboxes, the better able we will be to get the results we want.

cheers,

Laura

ps - what I use for warp packing?  Bamboo blinds with the hardware removed....

mneligh

On a conventional beam I have had issues using only paper as packing.  On a long warp, if the layers can slip off the edges, they might, and the paper is not strong enough to hold them away from the next layer.  The problem manifested itself not at beaming with too tight edges, but while weaving with the edges becoming too loose. (The warp sat for a little while with no tension, maybe got jiggled, and then retensioned.)  Fortunately I was able to insert wedges under the loose threads at the back to retension it, but it was a major hassle. Never again . . . I use lathing as well as paper now.  I'm looking for some wide blinds to take apart . . .

Submitted by Weavin Steven on