I was wondering, what would count as an original design? For instance, I'm starting a project where I'm using the threading from Davidson's book (Scheelein's 123), but I'm not doing it as over-shot, I'm doing it as shadow weave. I didn't like how the treadling she showed looked as shadow weave, so I came up with my own. I was telling a friend of mine about it, and she commented about it being an original design, but is it really? Just wondering what you all thought here. :) Thanks! Lisa Ann

Comments

laurafry

There are only so many threading drafts that will produce functional cloth.  Using a published threading draft but interpreting it in your own way - changing the tie up, the treadling etc., using your own yarn and colour choices - that all makes it sufficiently 'original' in my mind.  

What *isn't* 'original' is taking a project from a publication and using precisely the same yarns, colours, threading, tie up and treadling.  

Cheers,

Laura

 

tien (not verified)

I wrote a post about this on my book blog a few weeks back. (I'm blogging a book about creating original craft designs.) You can read the full post at http://www.creatingcraft.com/originality-copyright-and-credit/ , but the excerpt I was thinking of is this:

In my opinion, the question “Is this 100% original to me?” is not especially useful.  Originality is not a yes/no question; instead, it’s a continuum, and most work falls into the gray zone.  If you take an existing piece and change the color scheme, is it original?  The answer is both yes and no.  If you totally change the appearance, but the underlying structure is the same, is it original?  Again, yes and no – perhaps a little more yes than no, but still in the gray zone.

I think it’s equally important to ask yourself why you are asking the question.  Is it pride, wanting to know that you created an “original” piece?  This may be a relevant question early on, when you are just getting started in design, but once you get some experience under  your belt, you’ll likely realize that most work does not start from scratch, but is firmly grounded in existing techniques, design concepts, and bits and pieces of existing work.  The job of the creator/designer is not generally to create something wholly new under the sun, but to combine what exists already into something that is different from what came before.

...If your piece is substantively derivative of someone else’s work, you owe it to them to mention that in the description of the piece, whether on a hang tag or in the description for a show or exhibit.  If it bears a close resemblance, get the original maker’s permission before exhibiting it in a public arena, and state clearly that it is a variation on the original author’s work.

My "take" on it is basically that the more derivative your work is, the more you should cite your inspiration. But things are rarely 100% original.

But I like Laura's answer, too. :-)

Sara von Tresckow

To answer the original question, yes, the design is your own.

"Original" implies totally one of a kind, perhaps "Designed by xxx" would be the more appropriate wording of any hang tags or exhibit labeling.

One cannot get a copyright for common knowledge - many weaving structures and patterns ARE common knowledge. There is an entire set of ISO weaves, with designation numbers - and by changing the numbers, you can derive a multitude of additional structures. Anything derived in this manner becomes "your own" in the final design implementation. 

lisaann1961 (not verified)

As I said in the original post, my friend commented on it being an "original design", and I didn't think it was, because the threading wasn't original. I didn't think it "counted" that I'd also changed the tie-up, the treadling, the yarns and the colors. :)

Then again, I cook the same way. Someone will give me a recipe, and all I'll say, "Oh, I made your recipe! But I used X instead of Y, and I changed the seasonings, and I didn't use the pasta I changed it to rice." When all is said in done, the only thing both dishes had in common was "bake at 350 deg for 45 minutes."

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

Say a draft has been published in a book or a magazine or in the handout pages from a workshop. If I see something and I know it was woven with that draft, then I want to see a line about the source of the design. If it came from a book but you got it without buying the book, saying that the draft "came from a website" is not the same as saying it came from a book by this author.

You started with a threading from M. Davison. Did she used it as drawn in? If you took one of her overshot threadings and interpreted it as shadow weave or as double weave or as turned taquete, also woven as drawn in, then you are using the same design in another way. It's like using a profile draft from a source and weaving it in a different structure. The design came from the source but you are not copying the finished product. You could say "inspired by" in this case. If you have a different design in the treadling, not shown in the Davison book, you can say it is your design. Next step is designing your own threadings- it is fun, and then you don't have to wonder about this.

Sara von Tresckow

Seriously, if someone has authored a work about a technique that they have derived that is stylistically new territory, I can see giving credit for drafts.

The Davison and many other books are mere collections of patterns from other weaving books - many from other countries and long out of print - that reiterate in slight variations, basic weave structures - threadings, treadlings and tieups that can then be recombined in thousands of new ways. I've been collecting books for so long now, that I recognize many drafts as appearing in books from many areas and periods - these are mathematical representations of threads that do repeat themselves, sometimes spontaneously, and it is entirely possible to create a draft that you later find in a book.

There really is no requirement that using portions of common knowledge need be credited to one particular source.

lisaann1961 (not verified)

I can honestly answer the question by stating, "Oh, I copied the threading sequence from the Davidson book, it's Scheelein's 123.  I just wanted to see what else I could make it do."  Okay, that makes me feel better.  

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

I like your answer. I was thinking about what would be appropriate for posting on Weavolution or another online group as a project or for sharing with your guild. When the audience includes other weavers, it can be helpful for them to know that you use a particular book and the way you have used it. Less experienced weavers might own Davison (no second "d") but had not considered using the given threadings in the way that you have. If you had started with a threading from Davison and worked through a series of methods in Helene Bress's weaving book, others might appreciate this kind of information.This is also a reason for including the name of the book author when you find a draft you like on handweaving.net because others might want to search under that book online or order a CD of the book or download it.

lisaann1961 (not verified)

I was more concerned about taking credit where credit wasn't due, and hadn't thought about other weavers looking at my draft and thinking, "Hmm...so that's Scheelein's 123 from Davison and Lisa made it look like that?  I wonder what I could do with it if I tinkered!"  

I get picky about things like that because my Mom is a gourd artist, and she's had occasions where someone has (in our opinion) duplicated one of her designs, and claimed it was original because the creation had green eyes instead of blue, or some other minor difference.  I'd rather say, "Oh, I copied that from this resource and just made a few minor tweaks" than to let someone assume I'd created everything about it.   I know that at some point, I'll make enough changes that it will be 95% mine and 5% someone elses...but it's good to know that stating "I used this threading from XYZ book, changed the yarn, changed the tie-up, changed the treadling and somehow got here" isn't being dishonest.

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on