I am struggling with a question I have about men's scarves.  Should they have fringe or not?   I shure would like some opinions about the matter. Am planning on making them about 7" x 90".  Does that size sound right?    Thanks everyone and happy thanksgiving! 

Comments

endorph

them both with and without fringe. When I have done fringe on a man's scarf I have not twisted it. I think it really depends on the man -

ilovefiber

Thanks Endorph.  They may go on the rigid heddle loom and fringe would be so much easier. I was planning on just tying a knot for the fringe.  How does the size sound? 

laurafry

It depends on the man - some like fringe, some don't.  Generally I find tha men tend to like my scarves with twisted fringes....

cheers,

Laura

endorph

would be good for tall folks - I tend to go arounf 70 inches or so for length so weave about 72 inches on the loom plus 5 - 7 inches of fringe on both ends. Just make sure that f you are using wool not to agitate the fringe in the wet finish or you can end up with fulled clumps! Ask me how I know that! 

Artistry

I hemstitch the ends for a dressier look and then cut a shorter fringe, a couple of inches. That way they can go casual or dress up.

endorph

comment above - won't let me edit my post - if you are twisting or braiding the fringe they can be agitated in the wet finish - my caution applied when you are knotting and just leaving the fringe handing straight! Wet yes - agitate no - unless you are using a wool that doesn't full - in that case - never mind. . . .  :)

Artistry

But i use fine yarns, if you're using heavy yarns a longer fringe would probably look better, like Endorph suggests and I also like twisted fringes too:)

ilovefiber

Wow, thanks everyone for your input!  Will have to give this some more thought.  Have the weft figured out.  Just not sure about the warp yet.  Was told to make this an "easy care" garment so am sticking to wool/nylon mix.  Hopefully will have a chance to visit a yarn store this weekend although the thought of going shopping this weekend scares me!   Thanks again.  M

r1mein54 (not verified)

I think a scarf should be "sized" to the one that will wear it - if possible.  Something too small looks out of place on a larger person.  Seven inch wide may be good for a male child or young teen, for an adult I would go more with 8 or even 9 inches wide. 90 inches ( 8ft.6 in.) is plenty long for a tall person but if the guy in 5ft.5 it may hang below his knees. Again, it goes to personal preference. I don`t think a straight male will like wearing a scarf with a frilly looking fringe. Two or three strand twist will do or lock stitch the ends and just trim them both to less than 3 inches.

ReedGuy

I prefer twisted and around 2 inches. There ya have it. :)

I had a tartan scarf given to me from Scotland and I didn't know anything much about the care of it. So, the short story is, it is now a piece of felt. :/

No worries, I have all the yarn for a bunch more just sitting in waiting. :)

I have to read up on the twist method. :)

I don't like real long scarves, mine get stuffed inside my coat, and up around my neck. Not dangling over my shoulders and on the outside.

 

ilovefiber

Thank you gentlemen for your input.  Very valuable!  I guess I will go with a little shorter and wider scarf. Will post pictures when I have them done. Happy thanksgiving!  M

prairiegirl (not verified)

I had texted the guy friend I just made a scarf for to ask about fringe, and he said it was girly.  However, when I showed him the finished product with the fringe, he decided that it was perfectly fine with the fringe. I think it's a personal preference.  The dimensions were about 8x77 inches. 

sally orgren

I usually do a very short fringe for a guy's scarf, and I always ply my fringes so they last a long time. Unplied fringe can get messy, matted, and raggedy looking after a while on a well-loved and worn scarf.

Go to a men's store and look at commercial offerings for overall width, length, and fringe length & finish.

A younger guy might be more willing to wear longer (and perhaps "girly" looking) fringe than an older guy. So I think you have to take age into account too. I'd be curious if scarves from Hollister/Abercrombie differ or are the same dimensions as those offered at Men's Warehouse?

Maybe we should do a little sidebar research as part of our Christmas shopping this year. (Don't forget to bring the tape measure and report back !!! ;-)

amycarter

Everybody has their own prescription about it But, I personally think that fringes on the scarves is a girly thing. usually fringes are made for the womens scarves.

sequel (not verified)

Mens' wool scarves generally have short, untwisted fringe and are woven with a fine, smooth yarn.  Either hemstitch in small/tiny groups or sew carefully along the first and last 2 picks.  My favorite yarn is Jaggerspun 2/24 lambswool, scarf not to exceed 9 to 10" in width. 

If your guy is uber-trendy, the scarves at Nordstroms are wide, more like ladies stoles, but still made with fine yarns to improve drape and avoid bulk.  The wider the scarf/stole, the longer the fringe, but not to exceed 3" for men.

Artistry

I'm back again:) I really like Sally's advice of looking at men's scarves online AND of course with everyone else's advice, taking into account the wonderful gentlemen of Weavolution who have responded!

i have made scarves out of painted warps, subdued and fancy Twills, very fine, short , short  fringe! and as sequel says with tiny hemStitching! Again silk 20/2 or finer, in Browns and tans , highly small patterned , short, short fringe. If these are dry leaned or hand washed, the fringe is just fine.also Jaggerspun zephyr in Twills, plaids, great colors, to be drycleaned or hand washed, do a color fastness test first, with a hem Or fringe.

i personally don't care for Tencel, but lots of people do. If you want that kind of shiney look without the cost of silk, many people go that way.

than the personality of the man! My brother a retired lawyer, and drummer in several bands, loves purple, the brighter the better, and pattern! He also likes to wear his scarves halved, with the ends of the scarf looped though! My father, conservative, likes wool, tartan, or twill , scarf worn, crisis crossed over his chest . My husband just wears a scarf, doesn't matter what it is, I made it:)

ok , I'll be quiet now:) have fun!

Cathie

 

Submitted by ilovefiber on