I've been weaving for upteen years and haven't been able to untangle weave structure from pattern.  I read Helene Bress's book, and she repeatedly mentioned weaving, say, overshot pattern with a twill structure.  I couldn't get my head around that.  What's a good resource to untangle myself?  I'm ready to try netword drafts and designing or modifying patterns, but I bet I need to get untangled first.  Madelyn can der Hoogt's Handwoven Fabric:  Structure and Pattern?  I don't know if watching it  on DVD would help or not.  Madelyn's Complete Book of Drafting?  Other suggestions? 

Comments

kfsuko (not verified)

make that "umpteen," I think

tien (not verified)

Bonnie Inouye's Exploring Multishaft Design (available from Bonnie at http://www.bonnieinouye.com ) is what I started with - it's an excellent book that walks you through exercises in designing your own drafts.  Don't be fooled by the fact that most of the drafts in the book are for 16 shafts - I worked through most of it the first time with an 8-shaft loom and found it extremely useful.  Bonnie also helped me with some tutoring - if you are confused you might ask her whether she is still doing tutoring.

For network drafting, Alice Schlein's book Network Drafting is the best book around.  It can work on 8 shafts but is better with more than 8, if you've got that many.  I think network drafting is really neat!

Madelyn van der Hoogt's book The Complete Book of Drafting for Handweavers is a good reference, but I don't think it's the best one for the novice drafter.  I found it very confusing until I had more experience under my belt.  A few years later I find it to be a wonderful reference, and have been avidly studying it the last few months.

Sharon Alderman's Mastering Weave Structures is great too, although it is more a reference on structures than an introduction to design.

I hope that helps!  Feel free to ask more questions about, well, anything.  :-)

Tien

Sara von Tresckow

Weaves are usually grouped into three categories - plain, twill and satin.

With few exceptions, drafts are derived from one of these. Overshot, for example develops a twill threading and treadling together with a supplementary weft for pattern to create the desired effect.

 

Rather than just going for books with completed drafts, try either Getzmann - Weave Drafting the Swedish Way or

wait for "Warp and Weft" from Marianne Eriksson coming in June

These books approach weave drafting and pattern development in a systematic way that will encourage you to develop your own drafts.

lkautio (not verified)

For teaching, I have found that Doramay Keasbey's two books: Designing with Blocks and Pattern Techniques for the Handweaver are really excellent.  Designing with Blocks is a little simpler and has been reissued recently, I believe (it was getting hard to come by).  It talks about design and structure (many structures) separately. 

Becoming familiar with profile drafts will allow you to separate the pattern idea from the structure (interlacement). In a nutshell, one can create pattern and background in many ways.  Often the background is the back face of the pattern, so it is as if you are switching back and forth between the front and back of the cloth, but side by side.  A more complex way to create pattern on background is through use of completely different interlacements (for example, twill and plain weave vs. warp and weft-faced twill).  It can get more complex still, with use of three or more different interlacements (for example, twill, huck lace, basketweave, and plain weave) to shade different areas of the pattern.

The structure guides the way the threads interlace (over one, under two vs. under one, over two) and the pattern guides how you place the interlacements (warp-faced goes here, weft-faced goes there).

Bress' book is great for learning unusual treadlings for common weaves.  One structure can be "woven as" another (that is, with the treadling from a different structure).  There are a lot of other treadling variations including honeycomb, on opposites, polychrome, etc. which were more common when most master weavers only used four shafts.  Many of these have been forgotten in the rush to more shafts because they use more treadles than are usually available.  If you understand how they work, you will learn a great deal about structure, whether you work on 4 shafts or 40.

Laurie Autio

kfsuko (not verified)

Such great information!  Thank you to each of you - Tien, Sara, and Laurie -

 

Kate

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

When you look at a piece of cloth (or a towel or runner or scarf) as a whole, not examining the details, the first thing you see is the design. That's where I start planning a piece. I think about design and scale. What kind of design do I want, and how large should it be?

Ideally, I can express any design I want in any weave structure and any fiber. In that case, I choose the weave structure (the interlacement of threads) so I get the most appropriate structure for the desired use. I consider many factors: durability, float length, texture, hand, drape, sheen, warmth, thickness, and maybe ease or speed of weaving.

The word, "pattern", can indicate a draft with instructions, like a knitting pattern but for weaving, or it can refer to the design, for example a pattern of checks or a pattern like small flowers, a small repeat pattern.

A full draft consists of the threading, tie-up, treadling, and resulting drawdown (or threading, liftplan and drawdown)- or draw up in some parts of the world. The design shows in the drawdown and I wish they included the drawdown in all of the drafts in Handwoven magazine.

Bonnie Inouye  (I do have some books still.)

lkautio (not verified)

Just to complicate things, another meaning of pattern is  how motifs are put together and repeated - where the symmetry operations (rotation, repetition, mirroring, gliding) are the language of pattern.

Forgot to mention that I know a number of people who have learned a great deal by working their way through Bonnie's book page by page.  Most were using more than 8 shafts, but there is no reason you couldn't work your way through it with fewer.

Laurie Autio

sally orgren

Laurie, I liked how clearly you described this! And I appreciated everyone's input. Because there is no formal weaving course we all follow step-by-step, what we learn is sort of hit-or-miss depending on what we are exposed to or seek out. How long one has been weaving really doesn't count in this equation.

I find it helpful to spend a fair amount of time sampling on table looms to see the direct result of treadling options, because I might not have enough peddles on a floor loom to explore all the possibilities. (I also get myself into trouble by falling in love with something that requires gymnastics to weave on the floor loom ... then I visit Tim's Treadle reducer ;-)

Yes, I start on the computer, but sometimes computer software just doesn't give me the whole story, like when weaving an original Bedford Cord design. Many times how I treadle and then tie-up is influenced by what I figure out with my "direct" tie-up experiments. (Often, Tim's formula needs some tweaking for real-world implementation.)

Robyn Spady presented a workshop to our guild several years ago where we all threaded our looms the same way (but not straight draw) and then we were given directions to treadle in "rose fashion", "on opposites", "summer & winter", etc. My first thought was how can you do that? —the loom wasn't threaded for "summer and winter"! But the diversity of the patterns that appeared on that warp was astounding. Perhaps taking a workshop like that would help you learn more about the possibilities.

Bonnie's workshop was also a fascinating one for our guild. The group was hesitant at first, because only one member had a 24-shaft AVL at home, and she certainly wasn't going to lug it to the workshop! A few members had 10-12 shaft floor looms at home. The majority of the group wasn't sure what they would get from the experience if they only had 8 shafts. But who knew you could get so many different beautiful fabrics out of ONE threading? The experience certainly made them think differently about the relationship between threading, tie-up, and treadling. Each person stayed on their own warp (and each warp was different), but the general concepts played out for everyone to see.

Laurie, I am also hearing glowing reports from Mary Underwood about your class up in MA, but unsure about the details.

I also wondered if pursuing the COE would put things into an orderly context for you?

(Could this topic be a Cyber Fiber offering?)

This sounds like a *very* fun and interesting pursuit to me. You have to let us know what you are going to do next!

Cally (not verified)

If you are able to get hold of a copy at a reasonable price, or from a friendly guild library, then I highly recommend Ann Sutton's book "The Structure of Weaving". It is a brilliant guide to the creative things you can do with basic weave structures such as plain weave, twill and satin. In fact a huge amount of the book is devoted to plain weave alone! I was lucky enough to be given a secondhand copy when I was new to weaving and I go back to it again and again (quite often just to drool over the pictures).

Cally

kfsuko (not verified)

Those workshops sound just like what would clarify things for me!  Thanks, Sally and Laurie.  So far, I've just gotten as far as ordering Bonnie's book (thanks, Tien).  Through all your postings, I realized that I had a better handle on the distinctions than I thought. 

What part does tie-up play in one warp treadled rose fashion or summer-and-winter? 

kfsuko (not verified)

Think I've taken it out of my local public library.  I'll get it again to explore structure and pattern  -  thanks, Cally -

Sara von Tresckow

I do offer two classes on weave drafting -

Beginning drafting for beginning to intermediate weavers - on how to develop one's own creative weaving plans.

The more advanced class is systematic drafting (Bindungslehre) of basic weaves and their derivations.

Both can be offered at the shop or at any guild or conference.

lkautio (not verified)

Sally, the class Mary Underwood is taking with me meets in person once a month for lecture and sharing in MA for six hours, 10 times per year, for four years.  It is for intermediate to advanced weavers (better for early advanced and higher).  Some people are doing the class after finishing a master rating, some while working on ratings, and others just for the heck of it. It covers in a somewhat quirky fashion structure, design, drafting, and complexity in as many forms as I can think of.  By meeting regularly with the same group we can build on a shared base of knowledge and get a lot further with each topic than any single topic guild or conference class. If there is enough interest I will be starting a new section in September, 2013. 

Here on Weavolution, Judie Eatough is offering some classes on structures and computer drafting which might be of interest to some in this discussion. 

Working through the COE or guild ratings is a great way to increase your structure and design understanding if you work well on your own with minimal outside input.  What you get out of it will depend a lot on what you bring in and what you put into it.  I did the master program at Hill Institute in MA, which met in person for four years, then had two years of independent work - a combination of methods that worked well for me. 

If you aren't already a member, join Complex Weavers if this thread interests you in any way.  It has the only meaty publication for handweavers at the moment, a journal which comes out three times a year, plus many study groups at various levels, and a conference.

Happy learning,
Laurie Autio

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on