I'll start by admitting that I'm feeling a little dopey on this.  I think I might be making this too hard (one of my common problems.) :-(

I know it's totally possible to weave twills without using a floating selvedge.  The trick is to figure out which pick and which side to start on.  I have Fiberworks, which I use regularly in my designing, and feel like I should be able to look at it and know the answer, but I'll be darned if I can figure it out.

Is this a matter of a combination of sampling & experience?  

If sampling, my concern is that if I don't put a floating selvedge in when I beam the warp, determining only after sampling that I need them, then I have to add & hang weights.  If I do put the selvedge in, then it's hard to sample without catching it, which defeats the purpose.

Thanks for your helpful insights!

Comments

naturalfibres (not verified)

I thread my loom from right to left, with number one shaft being the closest to me, then when I start to weave I treadle shafts 1 & 2, and my weft goes from left to right, then I don't miss the side threads.

I've never used a floating selvedge.

Lauries (not verified)

I have also find it I start my weft on the left I don't need a floating selvedge.

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

This discussion is about 4-shaft twills and 3-shaft twills. Peg did not say anything about her loom but it sounds like a 4-shaft loom. Right?

 

peg.cherre (not verified)

I LOVE my 4-harness counterbalance, and do my of my weaving on it.  If it's as simple as Naturalfibres and Lauries say, I'll feel pretty dumb for using a floating selvedge for years, but really appreciate your insight.

I do also have an 8H Macomber that I use.  Are the 'rules' the same?

cubbysmaid (not verified)

Please can anyone advise me? I have the above loom. Shafts 1 and 3 aren't too bad, but 2 and 4 are a nightmare, especially shaft 4.

It doesn't want to stay in the guides.

Sharon

Claudia Segal (not verified)

Hi Sharon,

This is a good question and I encourage you to move it to it's own post in the Weaving forum where we are now.  

I have a Glimakra CB/CM and also had difficulty getting clean sheds with the counterbalance but I don't understand what you mean about "staying in the guides".  I know there are others on Weavo who own this loom and if you go to the main page of thsi forum by clicking on Weaving in the breadcrumbs on the top left side of the page, just above the ad, it will take you to the main landing page for the Forum.   Once there, click on "Post a new post" on the right side and put this note up.  i'm sure you'll have lots of response.  

Claudia

peg.cherre (not verified)

It appears that the simple response - just start on the left side - is perhaps only workable in a straight draw twill.  It certainly wasn't the case in the M & W pattern I just did.

So I revert to a modification of my original question - what should I be looking at in the draft in my weaving software to know if I need a floating selvedge?

kerstinfroberg

Make a draw-down (the outer 4-6 ends is enough).

If the weft comes out OVER the first end, it should (ideally) go in UNDER the same end in next pick - and so on.

If it looks like it will not work, try the other way: if it comes out UNDER etc., etc.

Perhaps it can be remedied by a basketweave slevage? Laura has posted one here.

OTOH - it will never work perfectly if the twill changes direction all the time. But perhaps it doesn't matter? That will depend on how long the "other direction" treadling is going on.

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

Hi peg.cherr. As to whether you need floating selvedges, I know of no utility that checks to see if you have any instances of the edge-most end not getting caught.  I think you have to eyeball it.  If you do find this to be happening you will need floating selvedges.  You will still need to check that the floating selvedge solves any long float problems.  Here is what I recommend.

In your draft, pretend you have two more shafts than you actually have, and use them just for the "floating" selvedges.  So if you enter your shuttle from the left, the left dummy shaft will be down, the right one will be up.  Alternate that pattern through your draft and if long floats occur on either or both sides, switch the treadling to mimic entering your shuttle from the other side.  If that also produces long floats on the edges try treadling both dummy shafts up then down -- this would be the equivalent of entering and exiting the shed over the floating selvedge on one pick and entering/exiting under the floating selvedge on the next one.  If this also doesn't work you might consider using two shuttles, as the selvedge "wrapping" that occurs with two shuttles can be used to prevent errant floats happening.  If all of that fails you can try the Norway selvedge, which is time-consuming but guaranteed to work:

In this diagram the floating selvedges are red.

Bonnie.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on