Hello Weaving Newbies and Gurus,

Here's my question:

I am putting together a towel warp in 10/2 naturally-colored, organic cotton.  I'm using an idea from Laura Fry and doing stripes threaded alternately in straight twill and Wall of Troy.  The treaddling will be straight Wall of Troy save for the hems which will be straight twill.  Anyway, I looked up the sett chart in my handy Weaver's Companion from Handwoven, and I found the recommended sett for 10/2 cotton to be 24-28 (plain weave) and 30-32 (twill).  I decided to start my sampling at 30 epi with a 15 dpi reed slaying 2/dent.  All my calculations were finished and then I decided to check my project notes for a sampler I did in 10/2 pearl cotton early last year..  The gamp was sett at 24 epi!  That really throws a bit of confusion into the mix.  I do remember that I had a hard time weaving square with the sampler, so it makes good sense to increase the epi from 24 - but by how much?  All the way to 30 like my original plan?  What I'm thinking is to start at 28 and see what happens.  What do you all think?

Stephen M. Palmer

Santa Rosa, CA

Comments

tien (not verified)

I'm guessing your gamp was plain weave.  Plain weave is sett more openly than twill, so your previous notes (based on a plain weave gamp?) may not be applicable to what you are now weaving (twill).  I'd start at 30 epi for your twill and make it denser if you need to.

Daleweaver (not verified)

Hi Tien,  Thanks for the response and sorry for the confusion.

The gamp was all twills - six different threading and six different interacting treaddlings.  There'd be less confusion if I was comparing twill setts to pw setts, but here I'm comparing apples to apples and that is what has me confused.

Sara von Tresckow

Your loom and your beat will affect your cloth differently than if I were to try your project.

Sampling - and wet finishing that sample will really be the only way to get the fabric you desire.

Also, most fabric tends to be a tad warp dominant -to give it "grain" and hang better when finished. Absolute balance is really only good for evenweave fabric for undistorted cross stitch.

jj50 (not verified)

I agree with Sara on all points, especially about wet finishing. Organic cotton will have natural wax remaining that needs to be scoured out in hot, hot soapy water in order for your towels to work. Hot water also enhances the natural colors. Expect 20% take up and shrinkage.  With that in mind 24 epi would prevent your towel from becoming overly stiff after finishing.

Karren K. Brito

10/2 perle cotton is mercerized and shrinks much less than I would expect the organic cotton.  A yarn that shrinks more will close up the weave quite a bit when you wash it.  It also usually gets whiter with the first few washes.

I suggest you make your warp long enough for a sample at the begining.  Start with some sett , 24-30 epi and weave a bit. Cut off and wash then evaluate the sett.  It is very quick to resley the warp and get the perfect sett for your yarn, project and taste.

sally orgren

I did a quick search under projects here at Weavo. I used "organic cotton" & "10/2" for key words.

I see one person (weavolution.com/project/kfsuko/drall-towels) wove her organic cotton towels at 36 epi. I posted a dishtowel kit in organic cotton that I wove (in twill blocks and plain weave) from Lunatic Fringe. Their recommended sett was 24 for the 10/2, and that seemed a little open for me. I don't mind a towel that starts out a bit stiff and will soften with washing and wear, as opposed to a towel that is soft from the start, and has a premature demise. 

I am thinking it also depends on how old the yarn is. (I know this sounds crazy!) In the UKI products, I have cones of 10/2 and 5/2 from an older weaver, probably purchased in the 80's. The newer cones I have purchased certainly don't match the grist of the older cones, they are slightly thinner. So when combining old and new, I have noticed I need to be aware of this in relation to possibly tightening the sett. If this happens within a single manufacturer over time, I am guessing there could also be subtle variations between different brands of 10/2.

Believe it or not, the type of loom you are weaving on can make a difference, too. Our guild did a small sett study and this issue came up. What was an ideal sett on a sample woven on a smaller width (table) loom may need to be adjusted when woven on a larger floor loom.

This is why a single solid answer is sometimes difficult, and sampling is pretty important, if you care about the final project. (Add to that keeping good notes!) Otherwise, "good enough" IS good enough.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on