Anybody (or does everyone but me) understand how to use the drafts?  Have read and reread the explanation on page 10, but still don't get it.  Guidance, explanations, any clues would be sooo appreciated.

Judith Rosenberg

Comments

Claudia Segal (not verified)

Judith,

 

There are 4 parts to the draft, the threading, which is usually across the top, the treadling which is along either the right or left side, the tie-up in the top right or left corner and the drawdown, in the center.

Do you have any other books that explain how to read drafts?  Have your tried putting the words "drafts" and "reading drafts" into the search field at the top of the page?  I know there have been a couple of discussions of drafts and how to read them in the Weaving 101 group.  

I learned how to read drafts from reading Chandler and a couple other books, probably the New Key to Weaving by Mary Black.  You might start there and Davison will be easier.

Claudia

Judith Rosenberg (not verified)

Thanks for your thoughtful response, Claudia.  I actually have been weaving for a while and have used many other books successfully.  There is a shorthand used in this book of Davison's that isn't used in her other, more popular book, A Handweaver's Pattern Book.  I haven't seen this system used in any other book, which is why I asked if anyone had  used it and could give me a clue.  Thanks again, Judith

Weavolutionary

Sorry, I didn't mean to offend.  Perhaps I have a different edition.  My page 10 has twill treadlings on it and the threading is a straight draw.  This page shows the different treadlings for crepe weave and double weave open at one side for weaving twice the width of the warp.  When using this book I find it helpful to try to isolate each pattern because there are several on each page.  

On my pg. 13 , for instance, is "Traditional bird's eye".  Although there is only one tie-up at the top of the page, Davison intends that tie-up to be used until she shows a different one.  It can be confusing.  Try isolating one pattern and you may have an easier time with it.  Is there one page or draft in particular you are interested in?

Claudia

Claudia

Mary Rios (not verified)

Judith,

My take (for what it's worth!) for the Pioneer Draft on Page 10. I have the first edition, not sure what is on other edition page 10.

Starting from the left:

3,4 *8 times*

2,3 *4 times*

1,2 *4 times*

1,4 *4 times*

etc.all the way across

tie up = 1,2/2,3/3,4/4,1 twill + 1,3/2,4 plain weave for tabby

draw down: tromp as writ

if you learn differently, kindly share the news!

Mary

Judith Rosenberg (not verified)

Dear People Trying to Help,

The Davison book to which I am referring is A Handweaver's Source Book, not the Pattern book, which is perfectly easy to understand.  The Source book, rather than having the traditional elements has just one, with an explanation of how to read the drafts on page 10.  So Pattern Book, no problem, have used it for many projects, Source book, big problem.  I hope I have stated this clearly; maybe this is a book that isn't very popular?

Cordially, 

Judith Rosenberg

lkautio (not verified)

The Source book is one of my favorites.  It is less popular than the Pattern Book, probably because it takes a little more digging to use it.  However, it is a wonderful source of profile drafts.  Originally from overshot (which is the threading part you are having difficulty deciphering), these profiles can be applied to any appropriate structure.  Studying how the drafts are made can teach a lot about how to design.

The threading is given in an antique style.  It makes pretty good sense as a shorthand when you get the hang of it.  Overshot blocks alternate back and forth between two shafts.  The A block is on 1 and 2, the B on 2 and 3, C on 3 and 4, and D on 4 and 1.  In this book's notation you will see stacked pairs of numbers.  If you see a 4 on the first shaft and a 4 on the second shaft, you are dealing with threading the A block on shafts 1 and 2.  There are four threads on each shaft (that's the stacked 4's in the notation) and they alternate: 1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,  Generally there will be the same number in the top and bottom of the pair, but at turning points (where the direction shifts) the two may not match.  This is done to preserve symmetry.  Within each block you choose the starting shaft as the one which continues the odd-even pattern.

Hope that helps, let me know if you need more.

Laurie Autio

Mary Rios (not verified)

Hi Laurie,

In reading this draft in Figure 1, would you help me understand their chicken scratches? The top figure has the double stacked numbers. The 2 nd picture has the hatch marks.The 3rd shows the blocks

If i'm reading from the right to left: 2 over 2 would be thread,

I would assume it would be 1,2,1,2

But the hatch marks  read 2,1,2,1

is this what you are referring to with the direction shift?

if so, how do i know when to shift....

Thanks kindly for any help you can offer.

Mary

lkautio (not verified)

The hatch marks are the threading.  Within a block, it doesn't really matter which one you start on as long as you keep the odd-even progression.  So, if I start 2121, the next block is threaded 2323.  If I start 1212, then the next block is threaded 3232.

At a reversal, for example ABA (reversing on the center B block), you might have 2121, 23232, 1212 .  Or, 1212, 32323, 2121.  The center block contains one extra or one fewer thread, and the threading on each side reverses.  This preserves the symmetry and the odd-even twill progression. 

If you write out the block letters, and they change from the alphabetical order (ABCDABCD), then you have a reversal.  In the sequence, AB C BA D A D ABC, the reversal points are shown in bold (first C, first D, third A, second D).

Laurie Autio

 

lkautio (not verified)

While you could certainly treadle this tromp as writ, following the twill line (with or without a tabby), an overshot style is what is called for.  For overshot, you would alternate tabby with twill, but the twill shots will repeat, enough times to square the blocks. At reversals you need an even number of pattern shots to keep the symmetry. 

Overshot pattern is made by creating weft floats in the block.  The pattern shot for A is lift 3+4 (giving a weft float in the A block of 1+2).  In the B block lift 1+4, C 1+2, and D 2+3.  [Note that Davison gives shaft numbers for lowering shed loom which is less common now.] Starting with one tabby will make the threads nestle better than starting with the opposite tabby.  Try it and see which you like best.

Laurie Autio

 

lkautio (not verified)

What I am trying to say, is you need a profile (block) tromp as writ, rather than a thread by thread tromp as writ.

Laurie Autio

Mary Rios (not verified)

thanks Laurie for shedding the light on this subject.  i'm glad Judith brought this subject up! we can all be so much smarter with the help of already smarter people!

thank you.

kerstinfroberg

I've always found it interesting that most american sources give the overshot blocks as did Laurie: A is 1,2; B is 2,3; C is 3,4; D is 4,1. Using this will lead to the need of adjusting - either dropping threads/shafts or adding incidentals at the block shifts.

In all (most, anyway :-) Swedish sources it is said that block A is 1,2, but (to keep the odd-even sequence needed for the tabby) block B is 3,2; then C gets to be 3,4 and (again to preserve the odd-even) D goes on 1,4.

Also, we seldon reverse the threading for the "other half" - A is on 1,2 regardless if it is to the right or to the left of the middle block.

And, Laurie - can I ask you a favour? I wrote a couple of articles on how to read foreign books. This one (only in Swedish) contains my (at that point) understanding of a threading from Tate. When I read your post #6 I think that I may have misunderstood... Can you please take a look and tell me if it is wrong? (This takes you to that threading)

Kerstin in Sweden, often confused about odd notations...

ALittlebird (not verified)

Kerstin,

I have a set Lou's originals in front of me. Her threading can be explained like this. If you see say a 1 on shaft one and a 4 on shaft two you will thread it 1,2,1,2. The 1 always denotes the starting shaft and the second number straight up is the next shaft plus how many threads in the sequence. So on that draft if you look in the middle of the second block from the right you see a 1 on shaft one and an 8 right above it on shaft 2. That would mean you thread 1,2 - 4 times (a total of 8 threads). Then to the left you see 1 on shaft one and an 8 on shaft four would mean 1,4 - 4 times. Make sense? 

lkautio (not verified)

Kerstin, Your convention is simpler and would take care of many of the difficulties with the usual American convention.  There are certainly a lot of conventions, and in the US, some have changed over time and definitely vary between regions.  Many of the old American coverlets do not preserve the symmetry at turning points. Some like the effect, others hate it.  In modern versions the symmetry is generally preserved.  You can see pictures of a lot of old American coverlets and count the threads in Of Coverlets by Wilson (if you are lucky enough to have access to it) or The Coverlet Book by Helene Bress (still in print). 

I think of the blocks as being set on particular shafts, not as a particular order.  That is, A is either 1,2 or 2,1 - switch as needed to preserve odd-even.  While a number of American adjust by dropping a thread at every block change, not all do.  Some of us switch back and forth, the way you are doing. 

Laurie Autio

lkautio (not verified)

ALittleBird explained this well.  Looking at your page, the "Chariot Wheel Formed by a Diamond and a Square" is doubled in size from the original.  That is, where there should be a two thread block, there is a four thread block, etc.  The smaller blocks make a more delicate pattern with shorter floats for the same size yarn.

I can't read the black original of the second one, but the pattern looks correct.  All the other transcriptions look correct as far as I can tell. 

Laurie Autio

lkautio (not verified)

Forgot to say:  Since I can't read Swedish, I don't know if you have noted the need for tabby in the Tate overshot draft.

Laurie Autio

kerstinfroberg

Let me see if I got it...

This is what I have on my webpage:

Following (I hope!) Alittlebird's direction, comparing all three, I get:

(the green warps are those supposed to be there...)

So what I should instead have in the article would be this:

Is that correct?

- what I guessed from the beginning was that the number 2 (or 4) denoted the number of repeats - so 2 over 1, I interpreted that as 2 x (shaft 4, shaft1). My first reason to believe that was that I have never even thought of having an overshot block consisting of just 2 warp ends...

Kerstin (hopefully less confused now)

PS - yes, I know of (and write) that tabby is to be added. The notation without tabby is fairly common here, too.

 

lkautio (not verified)

I think both ALittlebird and I would convert to the last draft.  Other than color, I am not seeing the difference in your middle draft from the first draft.  I was sure you knew about the tabby and probably mentioned somewhere, but with a lot of beginners here who might not know it is needed, I figured it should be mentioned.

It's often useful to be able to miniaturize or expand a pattern by changing the block size.  It might allow you to change the size of the pattern with the same thread, shorten or lengthen the floats for durability or visibility, adapt to different size threads or uses.  It is difficult to impossible with some structures, but most, like overshot, are easy to change.

Laurie Autio

ALittlebird (not verified)

Sorry I was at work yesterday and didn't get to check here.

Lou also expected that you would know the patterns were tromp as writ. So going up to your third draw down which is correctly threaded and what I meant, the treadling is incorrect. If I start at the far right i'd treadle 1-4, 3-4,1-4,3-4,1-4 (all one time) then 3-4 (2x), 2-3 (2X), 1-2 (2X), 1-4 (2X). It follows the threading exactly.

Lou's drafts are cut down from the larger originals in quite a few cases because she was weaving placemats, skirt material, bags, etc which needed smaller designs elements. 

lkautio (not verified)

ALittlebird, are you using a sinking shed loom or weaving the pattern upside-down?  On a rising shed loom one would reverse the numbers to weave star fashion, as shown in the original.  That is, to make pattern in the A block (threaded on shafts 1 and 2), leave 1 and 2 down and raise 3 and 4 to make a weft float in A. [On a sinking shed loom, treadling 1 and 2 drops them down, leaving 3 and 4 up - same result.] 

Laurie Autio

kerstinfroberg

Thank you again, Alittlebird. I will go through it, and try to get my figures right... sometimes it is difficult to see all squares "square"!

When I think I'm done, I'll show it to you again.

ALittlebird (not verified)

All of Lou's loom were rising sheds. I haven't woven these in a while but I'm pretty sure her drafts were all rising. I'll have to think.

Davidson of course is sinking shed. Screwed with my head the first time I started weaving. :)

kerstinfroberg

I beg you excuse me, if I seem a little obsessed by this :-), but I am just trying to understand what I read in those older publications.

So. I tried out the instructions (as I understood them) above, and got this:

(it is sinking shed, btw)

But... comparing them with the hand-drawn page below

I wonder - in the publication, there are two (or four) pattern shots, where I now have one (or two). Am I misunderstanding the "treadle 1-4, 3-4,1-4,3-4,1-4 (all one time) then 3-4 (2x), 2-3 (2X), 1-2 (2X), 1-4 (2X)"? Or is the hand-drawn pattern just an example?

- in at several Swedish weaving books it is clearly stated that "for overshot (daldräll), one always has to sample to see how many pattern shots it takes to square the pattern". In that context, "tromp as writ" means "treadle the blocks in the order they are threaded, until square". Is that an ok (as in "traditional") way to read older American books?

ALittlebird (not verified)

OK, tromp as writ but the same number of times as the threading. So I'd have to do the first set of treadles - 1-4 - twice. The number in the threading that tells you the number of threads will also tell you the number of TIMES to treadle. So when you see 1-2 in the threading that means you treadle that pattern twice. So the first far right threading is a thread in harness 1 and a thread in harness 4 but it reads 1,2 on the diagram right? So treadle 1 and 4 at the same time but 2 times.

In the next full pattern block where it has 1-4, 1 on the 3rd harness and 4 in the fourth - there are 4 threads making it 3,4,3,4 but it also means to treadle 3-4 4 times. It's a weird Scottish shorthand in this case. So double each one of your treadlings and it will work.

And Lou's drafts  are rising shed.

I also have my treadles tied up in straight twill pattern so I don't have to do a drawn down that shows both treadles as black boxes. Easier to read. 

lkautio (not verified)

Kerstin, your draft is correct except you need to double the number of pattern picks to match the original (and it doesn't show the tabby).  If you look at some of the US books teaching overshot they will have you circle the threads in the (overlapping) threading blocks and weave one less pattern pick than the number in the overlapped group.

In practice, you square the blocks as needed for the materials used, exactly like the Swedish instructions. Keep an even number of pattern picks at the turning points and all turns out well.

Laurie Autio

kerstinfroberg

Thanks again - less confused (for the moment... ;-)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on