Hello everyone, I've been AFK (Away From Keyboard) for a while... not really, since I'm frequently at the work keyboard... So, I'm just getting reacquainted with the new site.  I am so thrilled!  I can't begin to imagine the time that Claudia, Alison, and the team must have put into this to move it and get things running smoothly.

So, as I'm exploring around, and mentally cataloging how the new site performs, I'm making little mini-discoveries.  Maybe many of you have noticed this one already...

I've discovered that the projects can be "rated" from 1-5 stars.  I find it hard to imagine giving anyone less than 3 stars for their hard work, but there are those that stand out as favorites in my mind.  I don't always have comments that I can think of, but perhaps if I rate them and give out those stars, maybe people will know that their projects are being viewed and appreciated.

Does anyone want to join me in this habit?  I'm finding that it's kind of fun and addicting too, because it gives me a reason to go look at all those wonderful projects...  I'm finding that I like to give 5 stars to those projects that inspire me, teach me, have a wonderful explanation, have a beautiful photo spread, or are simply outstanding quality work.

I'm sure everyone will have a different way that they might like to think about things and hand out those shiny stars!  I've been curious does the site do anything with the projects that collect lots of stars???  It might be fun if the site particularly featured the projects submitted in a particular month that collected the most stars...  Probably an idea for the future...

Kay

Comments

tommye scanlin

I haven't looked closely to see the rating option in the project area.  However, I won't be using this feature.  When I retired from my university teaching job I was glad to give up the unfortunate and difficult task of assigning grades.  In my opinion, any rating system for projects is essentially the same thing as giving one a grade for their work.  Projects that are shown, I feel, are ones that whoever presents them are quite proud of, have worked hard to accomplish, and want to share with others.    Everyone who takes the time to do the work and then share it with us all deserves the highest rating possible in my opinion!

debmcclintock

the stars, I tend to use the favorites for exactly the reasons you indicated.  That way the project is marked for me and I can find it when I want to refresh my memory on something. 

Michael White

The rating system could cause issues and come to be a burden.  If the person who created the project wants to rate it themselves that has value (did they enjoy weaving it, did it turn out as expected, etc), but for us to sit out here and rate a project we have only seen in a photo, is very subjective. We are not taking professional photos for a juried show.  A beginning weaver could become discouraged if someone puts an "average rating" on a project they toiled long and hard on, and which taught them a lot.  I may not care for rep weave so I don't rate that project high, but what does this mean?  Someone already said that any weaver who takes the time to photograph their work and share it , should not have to be rated.  If they need critique, this is an open and friendly site and they can ask for it, or send it to  be judged in a show (another whole subject!!).  Possibly people that would like a rating could ask for it, and others would not have to worry about receiving critique. This would mean a change to the website which may or may not be possible.

Just my thoughts,but I think we need to encourage people to submit projects for us all to enjoy.  I have never posted a project, but my husband occasionally posts photos to forums when it fits the discussion.

Cheryl

bolivian warmi

I don't find the star rating useful at all. I do, however, really miss the "number of times viewed" feature from which I learned a lot. For example I learned to appreciated the value of taking extra time and putting extra thought into posing and photographing a piece. Some of my projects which were not particuarly interesting IMHO received a lot of hits because of the way they had been photographed. I was also surprised by projects that proved to be more "popular" (judging by the number of views they received) than those which were my own personal favorites. The "number of times viewed" stats are educational and mean that I can learn something by posting my project. Once a viewer has simply clicked on the picture the stats are recorded. No extra effort is required to click on a star or heart symbol or even add a comment.

Please bring back this feature if possible.

lkautio (not verified)

I miss the number of times viewed, but I think it would be more useful if it were number of *viewers* (discounting multiple views by the same weaver). The favorite button is useful for building a collection of what you like - and I would love to see who else has favorited the same items as a possible networking tool. The only thing I've done with the star rating is to award 5 stars (never less) - which maybe amounts to the same thing as favoriting, but lets others see that a project is liked. Sometimes I don't feel like commenting but still like the piece. Laurie Autio

kbird (not verified)

I see that people more thoughtful than I have weighed in on the stars... Their points have merit.  I would particularly hate for someone who worked long and hard on their project to feel discouraged.  I tend to think of Weavolution as a supportive site and I wouldn't want to make any suggestions that detract from that environment.

I was thinking of Craftster and their featured projects listings... I don't know how those selections are made (chosen by the moderators?), but I like to see them, because if I don't have time to look at all of the projects, I can still see some that are considered "noteworthy".  However, maybe it shouldn't become a popularity contest to determine which ones those are.

Overall it's a meaningful discussion to have for what people would like to see as the user culture for Weavolution, so I appreciate the discussion.

Kay

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on