I have got an invitation to present some of my weavings in an art competition . The goal was to represent your favorite place off the community parc by a photo and make an artwork with this as inspiration. I had to turn this round and made a photo that works with two weavings I had made. And guess what? One of them was selected

 

.

 

this was rejected . I admit my drawing is a bit simplistic .It was painted on the warp and then woven in linen.

 

original drawing.

 

This was selected out of 60 entries and will stay on display with 22 other artworks (paintings in acryl and watercolor mostly) for two months at the visitors center off Bulskampveld (community parc). I am very happy .

 

At the openingsreception we had  a long discusion on the question : " Is weaving art or just craft?"   So what do you ,as weavers, answer to this question?

With kind regards

Jeannine

Comments

Caroline (not verified)

Well done Jeannine!

Big congratulatory hugs from Australia,

Caroline

BonniePearl (not verified)

 This is a lovely interpretation, Jeannine -- and great use of color!

Weaving absolutely can be either art or craft -- or both! Certainly, what you have created here is art.

bolivian warmi

Hi Jeannine,

Well done! You are so versatile in your weaving and I think that there is a lot about your weaving that we still don't know. You constantly surprise me with things you have tucked away. :-) 

tien (not verified)

Congrats on getting in!  and what a lovely piece.  I hope you're proud of it!

I've never understood the word "just" when applied to craft - it implies that there's something less worthwhile about craft than art.  (Actually I don't think the distinction between art and craft is useful at all, but that's another story.)

To me, the distinction between art and craft (if there is one; I actually think it's a continuum) is that art is saying something.  That said, to me a well-made chair of original design says something...it may be abstract (curves in space) but then, so is a lot of art.  It is true that what craft can "say" is limited (sometimes) by the requirements of function - a chair is something that must be sittable-down-in - but that doesn't mean it doesn't have a message.

How do you define the line between art and craft?

Tien

 

Lauries (not verified)

Congratulations! The age old question is it art or craft. I think it is for each of us to decided. I am a crafts person who makes functional piece out of woven cloth. Laurie  

jemwork (not verified)

Exactly.

My line isn't your line, nor yours your mother's. A continuum.

Nurture what you do and learn to focus down on it. I'm amazed by all the techniques I'm exploring for tapestry. I admire the ability to follow a cartoon so well. Mine diverge a lot. I still try to make them, often after I've woven some.

Congratulation & the reject is a fine piece as well.

 

jeannine (not verified)

Thank you all for your reaction. It is as always an encouragement to continue with weaving.

It is a  fact that defining art is so difficult. What is ,what is not? And mostly usefull  and fuctional objects  are not considered art; But I don't care about that;

The fact of making something, creating it from an idea at first until it becomes real is art for me;And perhaps the making is more art then the object it becomes.Off course it feels good if someone tells me i made something nice and want to buy something. But that is off minor importance to me.

debmcclintock

 The only time I care about the difference is when the potters put a pot on top of my handwoven in an exhibit.....and you have to explain why your piece deserves to show as a standalone piece and not a supporting craft for their pot....and when I hang with painters and have to try and display my rug on the floor on a flat platform stand rather than hang it on the wall.....

Marsha A. Knox (not verified)

Congratulations.  I love this piece and you should be very proud.  I am not sure I would even be brave enough to enter one of my pieces in a competition.  BRAVO!!!! courage and talent, what a combination.

jeannine (not verified)

I am not a very courageous person. It was only after I got an invitation from our local art guild that I started to put some of my work on display at our anual exposition.As a member I also received invitations for competions and so i started entering some work; I don't think about winning ,just beeing part off the event and meeting other artist  is rewarding enough;

I took a look at your blog ; Your pencil art is so beautiful. I like the colours and the forms.

jeannine (not verified)

Thank you for your research and for taking part in this discusion.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on