I have a question about weaving a perfect 50/50 weave.  If sett is 20 epi  ,  how many picks would you weave to make the weave come out exactly 50/50 after washing.  I have tried a few samples and can't get it  bang on balanced.

Thanks 

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 Since every loom ans set of threads will behave differently, more sampling is your best bet.

Obviously the right number of picks will probably fall between 15 and 19.

 

laurafry

If the yarn isn't very stretchy I'd go for 18-19.  If it is stretchy, I'd aim for slightly less. 

Cheers,

Laura

debmcclintock

 so, it depends on your mood, just kidding sorta, depending on mood or music your beat will vary so you need to be careful with that.  anger or frustration can make a very tight cloth

also, how big of a sample are you weaving?  a small sample will beat and wash differently than a full size piece, be aware of that....

Evelyn (not verified)

I am going to disagree with the previous people!  ;)   With a sett of 20  I don't think you can go for less ppi and achieve a finished 50/50 web.

I would think that with a sett of 20 epi you might have to go to 21 or 22 depending on the yarn and the draw-in.   The draw-in, even if slight will make your epi more than 20.    I would use a pick-glass while your fabric is on the loom, take the tension off and see what the epi and ppi is after weaving a few inches.  You might have to try this a few times to figure out how many ppi you will need to get a 50/50 finished fabric.

Sara von Tresckow

 Warp shrinkage is always more than weft - and for even weave you'd be using a temple to control the fell line more precisely. Material used and shrinkage for that material will also play a role.

It isn't very likely that you'd want 20 or more picks to get the results desired after washing.

lkautio (not verified)

I've run into a few cases where warp shrinkage and/or take up was less than weft, but it is most commonly the other way around, especially if you use the same yarn in warp and weft.  I try for 5-10% less ppi than epi for laces with same warp and weft.  That is, 18-19 ppi on 20 epi.  If I had a linen warp and a wool or other soft weft it might take a few more than 20.

Laurie Autio

Evelyn (not verified)

 I am going by my own experience using the same yarn in warp and weft, usually linen, cotton or cottolin so the shrinkage was similar.   I  wasn't  using a temple so there was a bit of draw-in - a temple would have changed that certainly.   And measuring on a slack warp helped figure out the ppi needed. 

illoominated (not verified)

Here's my question...since you're all discuss epi and ppi.  I am figuring out an Ms and Os pattern this morning.  My warp's epi is 24, my weft epi is 12 - both cotton.  I'm trying to calculate the yards needed for my weft.  The Handweaver's Pattern Directory tells me to use a sett suitable for tabby.  I think I understand that.  However, how do I figure out "shots per inch" or PPI?

Sara von Tresckow

 You need to weave an inch, count the picks, multiply the picks per inch by loom width by length of warp in inches. Then divide by 3 for number of yards.

Take that number and add a good 15% for fudge factor.

 

laurafry

In my experience warp take up is *generally* greater than weft draw in.  However, as always, your mileage may vary.  Much depends on when you measure - under tension, or after releasing tension on the warp, and if you use a temple or not.

It also depends, as I mentioned earlier, on how elastic the yarn you are using is.  A softly spun woolen yarn will stretch more under tension than a 2/8 (warp twist) cotton or a 2 ply linen.  (I don't work with singles linen for warp so I can't speak to that yarn.)

Once you determine how many ppi you need for your warp/weft, the 'trick' is to be consistent in how much tension you apply to the warp, and how much 'force' you apply with the beater.  If you can't be perfect, be consistent.

Cheers,

Laura

Sara von Tresckow

 Before we get into all manner of aberrations and excess detail here, what is the purpose of the cloth that started the thread?

If this is planned for cross stitch, for instance, it might actually be an advantage to have a slight elongation. In spite of all our trying to get things "square", a slight elongation in the vertical actually renders many designs more pleasing.

Also, loom type plays a role. On rising shed looms, it is more difficult to use a firm sett and get a square beat - that is why so many magazine articles recommend "opening the sett" every time there aren't enough picks per inch. While that step may help, it may also open up the fabric to the point of having it too loosely woven.

The concept of evenweave is usually the same thread in both directions, or at least similar. All of the various combined fiber examples are merely adding complexity that needn't be there. Unless there is a reason for the even thread count, most commercial fabric is slightly warp dominant as is most archaeological as well - helps it hang better particularly when used for clothing or drapes. Most sewing patterns call for pieces to be cut in the warp direction for this reason.

In most cases (most implies not all) the picks required for evenweave will be at least 1 less than warps per inch. Beyond that, sampling on your loom with your tools and yarn is the only way to approach a hard number.

kerstinfroberg

This is interesting.
For the first many years I measured *all* my weavings before and after wet finishing. *All* of them (with weft same as warp) shrank more (percentage-wise) in the weft direction than in the warp direction.
I remember experimenting more with one towel-sized thing - this was long ago, I only remember it was cotton . When first washed and mangled "lengthwise" it had, as usual, more shrinkage weft-wise. I washed it again, and mangled it "crosswise" - and it got wider. The shrinkage was still higher in the weft direction, but I could influence the size some by choosing how to mangle it.

laurafry

Was the measurement taken only off loom or on loom?  I generally measure on loom under tension, so perhaps that's the difference?

Cheers,

Laura

kerstinfroberg

I measured off loom, of that I am certain.
however, I don't remember if the after-wet-finishing mearuring was consistent, and, if so, how it was done. I *think* I did the "whole finishing" (ie including pressing or mangling) but I'm not sure. I also do not recall if I was consistent with the "waiting" before taking the before measure - some things may have had time to relax, others may not.

But: *all* showed a greater shrinkage weft-wise!
(I am talking about wshrinkage from wet finishing here - this has nothing to do with on-loom take-up compared to warp length)

Fortunately, nowadays I stay away from exact measurements as much as possible, so I tend to simplify all cotton or linen into "approx 15% shrinkage", ordinary woollens get the same figure, diff.shrinkage items are "approx 35%"
Hooray for shawls!

Have fun,
Kerstin

 

laurafry

Yes, I rarely go for precise finished measurements.  :D  Much less stress to be 'approximate'.  :DDDD

After all, if you can't be perfect, be consistent.........

Cheers,

Laura

Karren K. Brito

I think that the handle of the fabric and a consistant beat are much more important than that the epi= ppi.  Who counts?  The uneven beat you can see, you don't have to count.

I'm sure there is a moment when its important but they are rare moments  and sampling is important here. Maybe sett at 20 epi you hcan only get a consistent 16 ppi, but when you go to 18epi you can get 17 ppi and that will be square off loom.

Joanne Hall

Hej Kerstin,

I'm with you on this one.  It takes time to do precise calculations and I prefer to just go by a guess at shrinkage. 

One consideration though here in the US is that many weavers do not use temples.  So, sett charts give very low numbers for sett recommendations.   Weavers do not get as many wefts per inch as they would with a temple.  We can sometimes see this when we see woven items in exhibits or at guild meetings.  I can often guess when a temple has not been used, as the weave is very open compared to my weaving with a temple.

Joanne

Fortunately, nowadays I stay away from exact measurements as much as possible, so I tend to simplify all cotton or linen into "approx 15% shrinkage", ordinary woollens get the same figure, diff.shrinkage items are "approx 35%"
Hooray for shawls!

Judith (not verified)

I am the weaver that posted the first inquiry.  Thanks everyone for your thoughtful and knowledgeable

replies.  I am working on test pieces for the Guild of Canadian Weavers and they do require exact

50/50.  Weaving a true 50/50 is more difficult than I thought it would be!

 

Cheers

Judith

laurafry

Yes, it's a real challenge to get a 'perfect' 50/50 weave!  But important for things like colour and weave, plaids/tartans etc.

Enjoy!

Laura

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on