One of my pet peeves - people paying silk prices for rayon and thinking they are using a green product.

I have known for some time that so called Bamboo and Soy fibres, yarns and fabrics were in fact Rayon sourced from the cellulose of bamboo or soy.  This means that it is Rayon and rayon from any cellulose source is still nothing but rayon.  The process of extracting the cellulose is not eco-friendly nor is it worker friendly. 

There are  labelling guidelines in place for these products which I have linked to here-

http://evelynoldroyd.wordpress.com/2010/06/05/bamboo/

Comments

claudia (not verified)

Thanks for the information Evelyn.  It's quite interesting.  I never realized that those particular yarns are actually rayon. 

Claudia

Karren K. Brito

I agree  bamboo is a rayon made from the cellulose in bamboo.  There are many kinds of rayon, most people know acetate and rayon.  All are made by dissolving cellulose in organic solvents and then extruding them.  It is the solvents and chemicals used in processing that are the source of pollution and hard on the environment. 

Some rayon processing is so polluting that it can not be done in the US now (cupro-rayon for example).  Other processing has been developed to have a closed system and no solvents emitted during the processing-- this is called Tencel and is considered environmentally sound and sustainable. 

It doesn't matter much what cellulose you start with it is how you process that has the biggest impact on the earth.  I haven't heard that the bamboo processing is any better or worse than the usual rayon.  A bit of green hocus-pocus going on I fear.  I saw an article in Eco-textile News that the GOTS (global organic textile standard) was annoyed with the bamboo manufacturer's appearance of greeness.

Karren K. Brito

Here's an article on the web about rayon made from bamboo.  Rayon has always been made from other wise unusable materials such as cotton linters.

suzyhok (not verified)

What about milk fiber?  I love the idea of it, but is it ALSO rayon and not ecologically sound?  I have been spinning some and created a scarf of it on a tencel warp.  Handspun milk fiber yarn drapes beautifully and feels great... but... is it green?

kerstinfroberg

isn't there a better way of using milk than making yarn?!?

suzyhok (not verified)

As a former dairy farmer... there are LOTS of ways of using milk.  But dairy farmers are making about the same amount for their milk as we did when we sold our farm over 20 years ago -- certainly not enough to cover raising costs of production!  Any additional ways to market milk to get more for the farmers is something I welcome and support!  If milk can make a useful fiber... why not?  My question was... is it a green fiber... or like bamboo... not eco-friendly?

Evelyn (not verified)

I have never heard of milk fibre.   Milk protien  fibre might be similar to the processing of soy protien fibre, the end result being rayon from my research so far.  

All these fibres are interesting, I object to people being told they are something they are not and being charged high prices for what is actually very ordinary stuff!

 

 

Su Butler

The rayon manufacturing process is NOT eco-friendly - even the one that supposedly recycles the "bad" chemicals......only about 96% of the material makes it through to be recycled...the other 4% is dumped into the environment.    I don't like the marketing ploy of calling Tencel and Bamboo or milk, corn, or other plant materials and other regenerated cellulose or protien product "eco-friendly".  But as long as people buy into the trendy ploy they will continue to use it. 

That said, cotton is not all that eco-friendly either.  It takes great quantites of water to produce cotton.  Come to think ot if, people aren't very eco-friendly either......while I am all for responsibility in how we use our natural resources, the whole "eco-friendly" thing smacks of trends and politics and profits to me.

When I researched rayon manufacturing for my book, Understanding Rayon Chenille, I dug deep into the processing of all kinds of fibers we use.  Bottom line is if you want to use something that has absolutely no impact on the environment, you probably shouldn't be weaving or dyeing or doing other fiber activity. 

Su

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

I've heard of cows being referred to as "one step in the transformation of grass into cheese" lol.  But on a serious note, given the huge footprint of cows (water, grains and grass in, methane and other wastes out) I can't imagine that yarn made from milk could be considered eco-friendly by any stretch.  And that doesn't even take into account the processing required to turn the milk into yarn!

Bonnie.

 

Karren K. Brito

Growing cotton the standard way uses tremendous amounts of fertilizer, pesticides, defoliants and water.  I think I saw that 25% of all pesticides used are used on cotton-- this kills weevils and bees, and the birds that eat them.  Organic cotton reduces the chemicals but not the water usage.  Treehugger is a good place to read up on this sort of thing.

I think that wool and silk are probably the most environmentally sound fibers.  With silk you are 100% sure that no insecticides were used :).  Organic wool would be better but I just saw that the Vermont Organic Wool went out of business.  Hemp, linen, alpaca...would be included here.

Tencel I think is the best of the man-made fibers, the got an award from the UN for environmental soundness and sustainability at the same time Michele Wipplinger did for her work with natural dyes.  Ingeo, made from corn, makes me think of what happened to corn (tortilla) prices in Mexico when we thought corn could be used to make ethanol for our cars.the next new one could be Crailar.e

I think that the biggest environmental problem with clothes/ fibers  with is cheap almost disposable stuff sold by Wal-Mart,Target, H&M and other trendy places.  I saw a study years ago by Limited that the average garment gets washed 3 times before it goes to the inactive part of the closet.  So if we all wore the old clothes  for another month..

I would hate to see my hand-woven worn only a few times, but then I belong to the slow cloth movement.

Sara von Tresckow

 I don't subscribe to any "movement" - just live quietly. Writing this in my white cotton summer dress woven for my son's high school graduation in 1994.

Slow down, consume less and live - its as good as all the conniving about "I'm greener than the others".

Evelyn (not verified)

I find it interesting that as hand weavers and hand spinners ,( who are for the most part very aware of what they use), so many continue to erroneously call it "bamboo".  It is not bamboo and even experts would have difficulty saying what cellulose each rayon was actually sourced from.  Indeed some of that which is labelled as sourced from bamboo might not be.  

I have written to countless retailers and wholesalers asking if they have real bamboo fibre - processed like linen - and have found none so far. 

Both Canadian and U.S. government agencies have labelling policies in place concerning the labelling of rayon products sourced from bamboo so that people know they are buying rayon, not a green product with all sorts of amazing attributes. Also if we are sellers of the products of our weaving or retailing these yarns and fibres, we are required to label that product correctly.  I have talked with yarn store owners about rayon sourced from bamboo  and find most of them don't know the truth about this yarn.  This is an entire sector of the yarn and fibre industry that has been missed by the regulatory agencies.

It is impossible as humans in our current world to be completely  environmentally friendly with everything we do as Sue says, but with the resources at our fingertips we can make informed choices by educating ourselves about the products we do use.

I too wear clothing years and years old - because  when I find or make something I like.  I keep wearing it until it is worn out. 

 

 

laurafry

Ashland Bay has begun offering bamboo bast fibre for spinning.  Email me if you are interested in details - I'm a dealer for Ashland Bay in Canada.

They also have milk fibre for spinning.

Cheers,

Laura

suzyhok (not verified)

What an interesting thread this has become!  

As a handweaver and spinner and sometime seller of my work, I just would like to be as honest as possible with the consumer.   If I have spun milk fibre into yarn and woven something to sell... I want to be truthful in its qualities to potential buyers.  If it is like rayon, I would like to tell them that.  If wearing it gives you some of the benefits of drinking milk, I would like to share that, too.  I know it was surprising to me to find that someone had thought to create fibre from milk protein!  Some of my initial excitement for the fibre is now dampened and I want to know more.  This is some of what I found: www.swicofil.com/products/212milk_fiber_casein.html  Is it slanted because its from a manufacturer?

I too wear my clothing over and over again... especially the handwoven and handknit garments!  But the fact is that many people do not.  Our years as poor struggling dairy farmers with 4 children taught me to be very frugal.  I try to live a balanced life (like Sara)... slow down and enjoy life while trying not make too big a wake!  But you can't beat the joy of creating with fibre no matter what it is!

 

Karren K. Brito

The Oeko-tex certification has a lot of meaning.  Later in the text it says that there is zinc oxide in the fiber that makes it inhibit microbes.  This is a protien fiber, not a rayon which is cellulose.  Was developed as a wool substitute and must be washed gently as wool is.  I don't think there is a scarcity of wool now, any body from New Zealand want to chime in here?

Too bad it is made from milk protein, would be nice to have a fiber outlet for all that butterfat.

Evelyn (not verified)

When you read the company promotional literature on their "bamboo" fibre (processed by hydrolysis-alkalization and bleaching which is a rayon)  they claim a lot of properties which have been found to be not true.  So I would be wary of their claims for a milk protien fibre and they do not fully explain the process by which they manufacture the milk protien fibre. 

I am surprised this company continues  to market their products this way  in view of the number of companies that have been fined for this type of false advertising.

termiknitter2 (not verified)

I continually see reference to cotton growing taking huge amounts of water - I live in South Central Alabama USA and there is lots of cotton growing hereabouts and very few fields are irrigated.  We have had a drought for the last several years (10 or so - don't think this years is considered drought at least not yet) and these fields have produced significant volumes of cotton. 

I do agree that there is a volume of chemicals used - but many of the fields are not sprayed for boll-weevils unless 1 or more of the insects show up in the traps around each field.

I don't grow cotton or anything but a tiny bit of pygora fiber, but wool is not great either as the animals must forage and many are fed hay & commercially produced feed that is also grown with irrigation. 

Please keep in mind that the farmers and processors need jobs too, so the continual "bashing" of cotton and not a green product is certainly not helpful in keeping our farms viable.

 Lisa

termiknitter2 (not verified)

There is a source near me that has bast fiber bamboo yarn(not rayon process) - on cones in 2 weights

send me a note if you want contact information

 

Lisa

Sara von Tresckow

Lisa,

Thank you - sometimes when we don't live near the producing area, we can be mislead by hype and misleading claims.

Nice to hear that the farmers in Alabama are working in a practical manner - I still think that using cotton judiciously makes a lot of sense - and that means wearing garments a long time and laundering only when needed. 

Evelyn (not verified)

That is great - I would be interested in the contact  information.

I would be interested in where it is produced.    Laura said that Ashland Bay supplies a  bamboo fibre processed like linen, but Ashland Bay have never answered my inquiry as to the process used for their fibre.

Thanks! Evelyn

 

 

 

laurafry

Since it's the bast fibre, I'm assuming that it is processed just like linen.

Cheers,

Laura

villageweaver (not verified)

"you probably shouldn't be weaving"

Well maybe not so true with animal protein fiber?- i've been doing much thinking about the whole hype of "green" and have come to the conclusion that sheep, goats and silk worms might be the way to go!

Just this week i visited Zeilingers Wool Mill (http://www.zwool.com/)  - saw every aspect of the process - nobody walking around in hazmat suites. Visitors are permitted to walk just about anywhere - after that visit - I decided i might need some sheep!

 

 

Evelyn (not verified)

Laura -  yes I think it would be a normal assumption too.    But they do not mention the manufacturing  process which is the important factor whatever the source  is.   So until I hear from them I will wait, but thanks for the info. I think true bamboo fibre would be interesting to use. 

Habu textiles has numerous listings for yarns which they call 100% bamboo - which are all rayon from bamboo cellulose.  They did have one bamboo fibre now discontinued and as it is a long involved process the price is usually considerably higher than rayon.

;)  Evelyn

 

 

 

kerstinfroberg

just to be "contrary"... when linen was a big "home-industry" in Sweden it was considered an ecological problem. OK, the word was not invented in the 1700's, but the stench from the water retting could be felt for miles... In some literature it is also said that the fish population decreased in areas where water retting was common.

And just a reminder: arsenic (just to take one example) is a perfectly natural material. Even so, it is not healthy...

laurafry

I remember talking to Linda Heinrich when she was researching her book The Magic of Linen, and how toxic she said vat (water) retting was - how much pollution was added to the water system because of it.  There are other examples of the use of 'natural' processes that have been just as toxic (think heavy metals for dye mordants, thankfully no longer used.)

As far as 'environmentally friendly' goes, I think we need to do our research, as Evelyn is doing, find out as much as possible about the processes then make our decisions based on information, not marketing hype.  From any industry or vested interest.  Some of the so-called facts that have been presented on-line have been so heavily slanted it's impossible to do anything but react negatively to the editorial slant of the 'information' being presented.

Personally I choose my yarns based on their fibre characteristics and live the rest of my life as environmentally friendly as I am able.  :)

Cheers,

Laura

Sara von Tresckow

The retting process produces butyric acid (like rancid butter) and anerobic bacteria. The anerobic bacteria deplete the oxygen in still or slow waters leading to fish kills. In a kiddie pool in the garden, this is not much of a problem, especially since those anerobic bacteria  poured on the compost pile are as good or better than the packaged products at the garden store sold as compost starter.

The "toxicity" was not the type associated with leaking crude or petrochemical waste products.

The concept of leaving no footprint and the hype associated with it are kind of misleading. The only way I could leave no footprint is never to have existed. And i kind of like being here, nice summer day and all.

Evelyn (not verified)

So right - we too are part of the earth and all living things have an impact.  Interesting info about the retting process.  I wonder if linen and hemp production today has any ill effects on the larger scale or do they manage to recycle or collect the acids for other uses. 

The hype and misleading advertising about the "bamboo" and similar products are what I dislike,  with the result that so many people think they are using something they aren't.  Being informed consumers we have the ultimate vote but also a responsibility to whomever buys or recieves our products.

laurafry

Well, people are comparing industrially produced bamboo rayon and I assume industrially produced linen.  Of course if we are doing the process ourselves we have control over what happens to the waste water from retting, etc.

And that's the whole point, isn't it.  When we don't have control over the processes, we have to inform ourselves about them and then make choices.  Or do it ourselves.  Or support those small producers who do the process themselves.

I try to support local producers as much as possible, but we don't have a linen growing producer or cotton producer or silk producer or rayon - of any type - where I live.  Pretty much *all* of my fibre comes from 'away'. 

So as I say, I choose my fibres based on their characteristics and the type of fabric I want to produce.  And live the rest of my life in as friendly a manner as possible.

cheers,

Laura

Caroline (not verified)

Environmental impact seems to have no place in the fashion industry! I imported some nettle yarn from Nepal, thinking it was eco-friendly, and I was supporting a fair trade organisation, as it is spun in the home. I had read many accounts of how it was harvested and prepared etc,  and it seems to fit the bill, until I saw this video on YOutube:

www.youtube.com/watch

To say I was appalled is an understatement, but the fashion designer says it doesn't really harm the lungs - I beg to differ!

In that order I also had some nettle spinning fibre, and it is coated in clay!  I took it out of the bag and the amount of tiny fine particles that came loose  was not funny and took over half an hour to clear with an exhaust fan! I had to take an anti-histamine. In among the clay are tiny slivers of nettle fibres...........................................................

The clay is like talc, and is used to coat the fibres to let them slip through the fingers.

The product may well have been prepared environmentally, and sustainably, but the spinning damages the spinner's health, on top of using keroscene lamps and living in smoky houses. We are contributing to the ill-health of the spinners and their families, and THAT is not environmentally friendly at all.

Now I shall get off my soap box and go back to weaving.

Caroline (barca1au on Youtube, and author of the criticism of that video)

lkautio (not verified)

Caroline, the effect of clay or talc is not the same as the effect of asbestos as implied in your comment on the video.  I'm not saying it is good to breathe in (I have asthma and can't tolerate baby or talcum powder) but it is a great overstatement to compare it to the effects of asbestos.  Mineralogically they have completely different forms - plates of clay and talc vs fibrous needles of asbestos and will lead to different types and rates of lung damage.  Clay has even been put into coffee whitener (we analyzed some with the x-ray diffractometer in grad school). The nettle fibers may (I don't know) have as great a biological effect as the clay.  Tow and dry spun linen as well as mohair make me cough and wheeze.  Either way, masks would be helpful for any fiber worker, including us.

Laurie Autio, who was a geologist in another life

laurafry

Fibre dust of any kind breathed in will cause damage - cotton workers used to get brown lung from breathing in the cotton fibres.

But I agree - the nettle fibre workers *ought* to be given masks to wear.  Perhaps the masks would help with the smoke from their fires, too.  :((((((

Laura

Evelyn (not verified)

Those conditions looked and sounded horrendous in the video. 

I have prepared local nettle fibre for spinning years ago, but have never seen it offered for sale commercially. 

 

 

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

Really interesting discussion with great info! It Is dismaying though that we can't help but impact our environment in some way---but as others have said, we can at least try to live as "earth friendly" as we can, and try to do what we can do. Okay, a contest---Who has the oldest garment in their closet? I keep my clothes a looong time (especially ones that I have made). I have a flannel shirt that I still wear every winter, that I made before my daughter was born.....and she's now 27! We need to take a stand against a fashion industry that changes styles every 5 minutes (and sometimes claims to be "green" by using eco fibers to boot! Um, how about WEARING something for longer than 1 season?!). And I am relieved to read some comments that tencel isn't TOO bad, since I really love working with it.

Sara von Tresckow

 the vest from my first handspun dates to about 1978 and is kept at the shop as a demo of how handspun holds up.

Caroline (not verified)

I can't win any contest, but I do keep my garments for as long as I can ( at the moment I keep growing out of them, grrrrr!), and then try and recycle them when possible. Sometimes it has meant getting out my sewing machine to refashion them, but with the poorer quality of todays textiles, some end up as polishing rags, and I have jeans waiting to become rug mugs. My cats  love my old clothes to sleep on. I also re-purpose household items where I can.

This has an added benefit as far as I am concerned - what I save tends to go on supporting my hobbies. :-)

Evelyn (not verified)

I still wear a silk blouse I made in about 1978 (commercial fabric).  I  also have many vintage pieces including a silk evening dress made for my MIL when she was 17 - that makes it 70 yrs. old!

Caroline (not verified)

That is wonderful!

One thing about emigrating and starting a new life somewhere else; you tend to leave a lot of things like that behind because there simply is not enough room to pack it all. My older textiles are things I have fond in my local thrift shop that people have not recognised, and its not the same thing at all.

The lack of a sense of history and continuity here still grates after over 30 years. "Old" in Australia is 150 years, if you are lucky and it hasn't been destroyed.  The land may be as old as time, but our connection with it is fleeting and fragile and does not have a feel of permanency or of belonging, and this carries over into how everything is valued, or not valued as the case may be.

Evelyn (not verified)

That was an interesting article and shows some hope in the long term for less chemical use.     They do not talk about yarn production and water usage which are also problematic.

termiknitter2 (not verified)

So sorry I meant to get back to you right away

Mo Purl Yarns, Inc

1413 Crossing Way

Auburn, AL 38830

(334) 887-5883

contact name/owner is Bob Mosley

Evelyn (not verified)

Thanks!  I appreciate the contact info.    I will have to call or write long mail. 

Helvetican (not verified)

Sara's comments indicate that she is on the same page that I am.  And I agree with Evelyn's in that we should be informed about what we are using, in order to make our decisions.  Too much of anything can be a bad thing, which is what happens with industrialization, but I would like to add that there is a significant difference between the "stench" of retting flax, and temporary oxygen depletion of a water source, as opposed to the permanent and long term damage caused the environment by chemical contamination, such as is created in producing rayon. 

I wonder about the process of producing bast fiber from bamboo.  Does anyone know?  I ret bast fibers such as flax, dogbane, and milkweed on a very small scale in my backyard, and have attempted to ret bamboo.  It doesn't work with traditional methods, and if it did it would seem that it would have been being done in the orient for centuries.  Does it take some serious chemical processing to obtain the fibers???

sewderf

All this is interesting to me.  It was disappointing when I realized the Bamboo that I was using was simply a rayon.  It read 100%* Bamboo.  I should have paid attention to the asteric.  It is viscose of bamboo.  I had read that the word viscose hadn't been used since the 1800's.  I only saw this in one resource so I'm not sure how accurate it is. 

I had looked around myself to make true 100% Bamboo scarfs and whatnot.  It is known as a fake silk.  Maybe I'll try it.  It is interesting to note that the bamboo thread I've used feels nice compaired to other rayons.  Some I can't even stand to touch.

Enviromentaly there is alot of inconsistancy.  Even Lye is bad!  Yes it is a corrosive material, but it is also an edible material (believe it or not - food grade used origianlly on bagels and pretzels for a glaze). 

laurafry

Viscose is one type of rayon. Rayon was developed in the late 1800's.  According to A Guide to Textiles for Interior Designers, the first spinnerette was developed in 1862 in France.  In 1883, J. W. Swan (an English weaver) developed fibre by using a solution of cellulose nitrate in glacial acetic acid.  These fibres were used in the first light bulbs.

In 1889 Count Hilaire Chardonnet used a cellulose nitrate solution dissolved in alcohol, forcing this solution through a spinnerette.

The first American plant, the American Viscose Company was opened in 1910.  In 1926 American Bemberg introduced the cuprammonium process.  

Industry is getting cellulose from various sources for yarn.  Bamboo as a crop grows much faster than trees.  They are now sourcing cellulose from sugar cane as well as other plants.

According to labelling laws in the US and Canada any regenerated cellulose yarn is supposed to be identified as rayon. 

cheers,

Laura

weave2 (not verified)

Well, I must say, this has been an interesting  discussion! I love weaving with cotton and linen, but am now rethinking trying silk or bamboo.   But, what does everyone suggest to weave with?  

Thank you,

Alaa

laurafry

Well, silk of course is lovely.  :)

cheers,

Laura

Liese (not verified)

After having read thru this thread and understanding the distress people rightly show regarding the enviromental affects of producing different fibers I do have to ask if you feel that way about bamboo/rayon etc. do you use silk? After all,  to harvest the silk the living pupea is killed ...

To paraphrase Sara, to live on this earth is to have an impact,  but I choose not to use silk, nor merino wool. Sometimes tho I think that knowledge is both wonderful and awful ...how to live and do without causing harm, it's a mystery!

Liese

editing to add that I'm using the general "you", this is absolutely not a direct reply to Laura.

Neshobe (not verified)

I began weaving rag rugs to re-use something that is treated as throwaway waste in the USA. Then I got interested in weaving with other fibres and learning other techniques. I wear clothing to death, and then, as I was taught, make something else out o it. I spent a career working on minimizing or eliminating the use of chemicals in agriculture (with some success, Monsanto notwithstanding), and in encouraging the growing of crops suited to the natural conditions of the land. There are dry areas that are now irrigated to grow things like cotton and rice, but we can change that by buying cotton (and rice) that are grown in areas that are natually watered as much as possible (there ar now natural rice paddies in Vermont!), or choosing other fibres. I bought some bamboo, not realizing that the only difference is the ability of the plant to regrow, not the process to extract and use the cellulose. I will use it to make a shawl, and give more consideration to the nature of the fibres I use.

I have been buying local wool to spin as much as possible. Many former dairy farms are going back to sheep (Vermont's original livestock) and some other fibre animals, such as alpacas. I know some of them, and the drive to farm sustainably with these animals is high.

I grew up in Oregon at a time when the wool market was being driven down by sythetics, all the rage. At one times, Oregon was the USA's biggest producer of wool-- almost all of it grown on the beautiful dry grasslands of eastern Oregon (think Pendleton Woolen Mills). Now there are people there who are starting to bring this back. And in other sheep and wool producing areas.

This could happen, and it could be part of a "sustainable clothing" movement. Consumers can change their habits, and now is a good time to start that movement by bringing consumers into our circle of wool producers and artisans, in the same way that small sustainable farmers are bringing the into the sustainable ag movement by giving them a sort of "ownership". We can't emulate that model directly, but we can start experimenting with ways to make what we do part of a larger, more inclusive movement. And maybe the place to start is by partnering somehow with the small scale food producers. Wool is making a comeback, and maybe even a guy in a city, like the guy in Vermont, can understand that a good wool garment that lasts is cheaper than a dozen made from imported cheap artificial cloth.

TinaHilton (not verified)

I must have missed something.  I've heard why some people won't use silk or bamboo, but what's wrong with merino wool Liese?  Are the sheep harmed somehow or does it need to be processed differently that's hard on the environment?  Just curious.

Tina

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on