I did a search before posting this but I didn't see anything that directly addressed my question.

-----

Can Twills be combined with Plain Weave to achieve the same hand across the fabric.  From what I gather, the hand is different for each weave structure - but is there a way to make it feel similar? (crowding, draft adaptation, etc.)

-----

I'm sure I've seen it done before but I want to be certain on this project that I don't get any crazy results.  I also know this is a pretty basic issue weavers have to address.  I want to combine a point twill pattern with vertical stripes of plain weave (including a nice stout selvage) but I don't want any weird draw-in or undulating edges or bizarre puckers on the fabric.  I know some of these issues can be addressed with a temple and aggressive steam ironing, but I'd just like for the fabric to behave from the get-go.

Now... something I think I remember reading leads me to believe a 2-2 twill will act "better" than a 3-1 or 1-3 twill -- do I have that right?

The proposed yarns are  8/2 rayon and silk, if that matters.

Any comments are welcome.  Thanks

Comments

amelia (not verified)

A 2/2 twill is "balanced", so the fabric will lie flat.  1/3 and 3/1 twills are unbalanced, the fabric will have a tendency to curl. You can use that to good effect to get a rib effect, alternating 1/3 and 3/1 in stripes, for example.

 

BonnieI (not verified)

If you want the hand and drape of a twill, then weave the piece in twill. You cannot have the same hand with a vertical band of plain weave (unless maybe it is a very small amount, perhaps, but then why bother?).

If you want to include some plain weave without running into problems of take-up or puckering, then make the plain weave go on a diagonal across the fabric. If it goes in a straight vertical line, it is likely to cause problems, although the end result depends on the yarn and sett and especially on the width of each structure. 

It takes 6 shafts to weave an area of plain weave and an area of 4-shaft twill side by side.  If you have 8 shafts, you can make a diagonal line of plain weave and have a lot of options regarding the size of repeat and width of line, etc.  Or you could make the line of plain weave go in curves or diamonds. Any of these will retain the hand of the twill, pretty much. I do not think it matters if you use 2/2 or 1/3.

Rayon and silk are both slick fibers. An area of plain weave is likely to keep the twill picks from packing in as firmly as you would want, and these fibers might then slide around some. There is a reason why the sett for plain weave is not as dense as that for twill.  If you have a good reason for trying vertical stripes in these yarns and structures and stripes, then I would sample first.   Bonnie Inouye, coming to Colorado in April

laurafry

What Bonnie says....if you want the fabric to behave combining vertical stripes of plain and twill will lead to problems.  Doing them on the diagonal will equalize the difference in take up more than vertical stripes but you may still get puckering between the two weave structures.

Cheers,

Laura

Sara von Tresckow

 I mix plain and twill all the time - using 6 shafts and using two setts - one for plain weave and the other adjusted for the twill. Even using the fan reed I get smooth fabric with a nice hand.

Joanne Hall

You can also use basket weave for the plain weave part.  There is a four shaft draft in the Davison book.

Joanne

cacolorado (not verified)

I kind of thought this was not going to go well.  I figured I'd get seasoned, knowledgeable advice before putting myself through  more stress than is necessary.  This is bunny-birthing week and I don't want more brain damage.

Thanks to all who replied.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on