So we have a WAL going in a 3 shaft twill on rigid heddles. My understanding is that this is an ancient pattern. I've read about it found in bogs, and always wondered about why 3 shafts? Why not just an even 4?  But it's very nice, I it's warp faced on one side and weft faced on another, which makes for interesting color effects, and it works quite well on a rigid heddle loom. I would imagine that it may also have worked well on early (warp weighted?) looms. Any historic weavers out there who care to enlighten us on this? 

marie

Comments

tommye scanlin

 Don't know about the historical aspects but it's interesting that krokbragd, a weft-faced pattern method, is done on 3 shafts, threaded as a point twill: 1-2-3-2 (1)

Tommye

debmcclintock

 In Cambodia it is used as the base structure for weft faced ikat (hol).  The over 2 under 1 structure lends itself quite well to simple treadle looms, shows off the decorated hol cloth and has beautiful drape.  Here's a link to some of the equipment  on my old web page.  If you look at the photos that start with Cam, those are sourced from current day Cambodia.  There are quite a few ethnic groups that cross borders with current day Cambodia, Laos and Thailand.  It is dragon water to try and discuss those.  I am speaking purely from a weaver point of view.  Suffice it to say that the 3 shaft weave has a rich heritage in SE Asia and is worth researching.  

Here's another link to the book resources I posted in another forum for books that speak to weavers.  

In SE Asia it is a 3 treadle weave that is counterbalance extension on a loom with 1 shaft tied agains 23, 2 tied against 31 and 3 tied against 12 with either a horse or a simple stick.

enjoy  Deb

 

 

lkautio (not verified)

Three shafts is the smallest number you can use for a loom-controlled twill.  You can use 3 shafts for quite a lot of different twills, so it is quite versatile.  The inherent imbalance (one side shows more weft, the other side more warp) in 3 shaft twills might have been a factor.  That is, one might have used a different warp from weft and put the soft, warm (or less precious fiber, etc.) side in, and the tougher, more abrasion-resistant (or more expensive fiber, etc.) side out.

Laurie Autio

CraftinSusan

If you consider that Rigid Heddle style looms are considered to be a lot older than multi-shaft looms than it is easy to see why 3 shaft patterns are also very ancient.  These work very easily on a RH loom set up with two heddles.  It is just a quick hop, skip and a jump from that to designing a multi-shaft loom.

My weaving guild had a program on Historical Weaving and also a Round Robin workshop on it.  We ended up warping our looms for 3 shaft patterns.  According to the teacher the first multi-shaft looms were actually set up for 3 shafts and many of these looms were later retro-fitted for a fourth shaft, sometimes not very sucessfully.  She has had the chance to set up and weave on many of these looms.  Her pictures showed the obvious difference between the original 3 shaft loom and added fourth treadle and shaft.  In some cases the wood was different and in others the four treadles were not evenly placed on the frame.  If you took away the newer treadle, the other three were evenly placed in the center.  She also showed up photos of tapestries and vases showing weavers using 3 shaft looms.

We also were fortunate to have Erica Ruiter come and give a talk about historical weaving.  She is the author of Weaving On 3 Shafts.  I purchased the book from her and have noticed that all the drafts in it can be done on a RH loom set up with two heddles.  It is actually on my RoundToIt list to do so.

On last point:  We also found out that historical looms were designed for one type of weave and a weaver could either just do that weave or have several other looms each designed for a different weave.  This is different from our thinking today where most of us have only one floor loom on which we can use for many different weaves.  Recently I finished weaving on a Rigid Heddle loom set up with three heddles.  I have a difficult time with plain weave which I was told would happen but when I swtiched to twills everything fell into place and I was able to weave 2/2, 3/1 1/3 twills without the problems I had with plain weave.  Personally I am convinced that a RH loom set up with three heddles was designed for twills.

Sara von Tresckow

 Rigid heddle looms as they exist today are not all that old. Rigid heddles for tapes are old.

The warp weighted loom is the first to produce twill weaves and it is definitely easier to work wiith 3 heddling bars than 4.

When we visited the Danish Ship Museum in Roskilde last March, there was a warp weighted loom working on a 3-shaft twill in one of their experiments to recreate wool fabric for sails.

Many of the bog fabrics were 3-shaft twill - it gives the denser more flexible twill fabric with "less work" for the weaver.

CraftinSusan

Actually there are old Rigid Heddle looms that are very wide and do still exist today.

One example is in New Salem State Park, Petersburg, IL.  It is a wide Rigid Heddle loom for rugs that takes two people to operate.  I was told (but haven't confirmed) that a wide 15th century RH loom has been found.  The woman who told me about this RH loom is the one that researches historical looms.  Most of the RH looms from the 15th to the 19th century that have survived are those band/tape looms.

We can analyze old cloth and say how it was woven (3 shafts twill, etc) but there is really no way to absolutely say what type of loom it was woven on.  Not even the experts agree on the definition of a Rigid Heddle loom.

Sara von Tresckow

 "Old" for looms goes WAY before the 19th century - and prior to that I've not seen anything other than narrow tape looms using the slot/hole heddle construction. New Salem is pretty recent in the grand scheme of weaving.

Wide looms used heddling bars or shaft frames with string heddles  were the primary looms - back to at least the iron age.

The bronze age textiles are exclusively plain weave - twill first shows up on the iron age - on primarily warp weighted vertical looms. The version with the 3-heddling bars was quite common and the textiles later found in bogs. That same area of N. Europe used 3-shaft weaves frequently - it was rather easy to fit that extra shaft frame into a 2-shaft barn frame loom when a bit of pattern was desired.

dteaj (not verified)

I've learned recently that jeans are constructed in 3 shaft twill for exactly this reason. Hard wearing yarn on the right side of the fabric, softer and more comfortable yarn on the wrong side.

ingamarie

This is great.. keep 'em coming! marie

laurafry

Davison has a draft called Jean's Twill - a 3 shaft l:2 twill - if I rememer correctly

Laura

dteaj (not verified)

I forgot to add to the jeans story that all this happens with the fewest floats and greatest sturdiness possible, hence 2/1 rather than 3/1 or greater.

Submitted by ingamarie on