I see that a lot of weavers who have used different countermarche looms are giving good advice on these forums, so I would like to open a question:

In your experience, what countermarche requires the lightest pressure to treadle?

 

I am just starting to keep an eye out for a used countermarche.  I love my current 36" Bergman countermarche (front hinged treadles), but with my particular lifelong back and hip problems, it is a bad match for me physically.  I've implemented all the tricks to circumvent strain when weaving, now I think it may be time try another floor loom as well.   The only other countermarche I have tried is a Glimåkra Ideal.  Possibly because of its small footprint, I did not find it to be much of an improvement over my Bergman.

 

The issue is mainly one of both applying and releasing controlled pressure with my legs.  With their short castle and short, close lamms, Bergmans are known (for countermarches) to be heavy treadlers.  This made me think a taller countermarche with plenty of room for the lamms to scissor might be a good pick.  Back hinged treadles also seem like they would give more mechanical advantage, but then I would have nowhere to put my resting foot?   And there is the matter balance and leverage at the jacks.  Do horizontal vs. vertical countermarche mechanisms make any difference in treadling effort?  Do wider looms (longer jacks, therefore cords further from the fulcrum) require a lighter touch than narrow ones?

 

Breast beam height is important for me.  My legs are much too long for my Bergman; weaving on it feels a lot like riding a bike with the seat too low!

 

I would prefer a loom with at least a 48" weaving width and 8 to 12 shafts.  I'm considering a Woolhouse Tools Gertrude, a Glimåkra Standard, an Oxäbäck (not a Lilla, but only because I fear its smaller size might give it some of the same problems as the Ideal I tried) or a Cranbrook.  The Cranbrook's treadle locks look like an interesting feature--useful if I ever get around to trying rolakan.  Are there other looms with locking treadles?

 

Any impressions of the treadling ease of the looms I've mentioned, or other countermarches I've failed to mention, would be very welcome.

 

Many thanks!

 

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 Funny thing is that the standard countermarche looms you list are all pretty much, as the Germans say, "Baugleich" - built alike. There is simply little or no difference in the force needed to tip the balance on any of those looms, size being equal.

The requirement to have the treadles close together in the center of the loom is the same on all models and all sizes. This is because the treadles cannot get close to the pivot point or too far away as that makes the treadle arc too different from right to left. (The exception here are the Cranbrook and Oxaback looms with "floating" lams). The force needed to move these treadles is going to be pretty constant. Vertical countermarche looms don't have center cords to interfere with fine, dense warps, but otherwise function identically with horizontal in terms of force and shed definition.

The one thing that will make a difference will be the tension on the warp. A woolen scarf puts less resistance on the shed than guitar string tension on a rug loom with reinforced beams. Treadling a rug on a loom requires more leg force than a delicate wool scarf.

I'd say that I prefer rear hinged treadles for light treadling, but properly designed front hinged ones should work reasonably well.

The Bergman loom is a bit of a compromise - the traditionally designed European countermarche looms pretty much share the back hinged treadles, high breast beam, adjustable bench, frame structure. 

Your question about foot placement - I have Cranbrook, Glimakra, Lilqvist (similar to Varpa or Toika) and Oxaback Lillla (I use and sell this model because I found it superior to the Ideal, but that is personal preference) - ALL have a crossbar near where the treadles end where the inactive foot can easily rest.

Actually, if testing one of the looms you've listed in a 40" or 48" width doesn't satisfy your physical needs, you should really consider getting a 48" Toika Eeva or Liisa (the overhead beater preferably) with the new computer assisted dobby box. This runs off an electronic foot pedal laid on one of those office footrests and avoide the issue of pressure on legs and hips altogether - while giving a lovely countermarche shed and very accurate performance. The come in 16, 24 and 32 shaft models.

Joanne Hall

As Sara mentioned, there is not much difference in ease of treadling between the different new countermarch looms.  But there are two factors which will affect ease of treadling.  Get the loom with the greatest depth from the front beam to the back beam.  And get the loom with shafts which weigh the least.  It would be best to not get more weaving width than is necessary.

It is also important to have the lower lamms longer or heavier than the short lamms for good balance, but most are made that way today.  If looking at used looms, check the lamms. 

Joanne 

Trapunto (not verified)

Thank you so much.  This is wonderfully helpful information!  Besides being the kind of stuff that fascinates me...

Sara, I did not know there was more than one kind of lamm set up.  Yesterday I looked around the internet a description of how floating lamms work, or a picture of what they look like, but I couldn't find anything.  All the pictures of Oxabacks, Woolhouse Tools, or Cranbrooks had the lamms hidden behind something else.  Do you know of a link to a good picture?  Can you tell me anything about how they work?

Toikas occasionally come up for sale near where I live, but I got scared off them after reading the blog of an English weaver who had to get a carpenter to put a redesigned brace on the castle of her Norjaana because it had pulled down in front.   I like the idea of hedging my bets with a loom I could fit with a dobby box.  Can they run off Macs?

Joanne, you have solved a mystery for me.  I knew the lamms on my Bergman were causing me problems, but assumed it was mostly a matter of placement: the upper and lower lamms on the earliest Bergmans like mine are too close together, a feature they later improved.  I hadn't even considered that the relative lengths and weights might be contributing.  I thought the big countermarches were just being thrifty with wood!

I would love a deep loom anyway.  I have just gone back to using a table loom for the first time since I was a baby weaver in my beginning class, and I am rediscovering all the reasons why weaving on a short loom--and a jack loom--was such a pain.

Sara von Tresckow

 1. Toika looms are as sturdy as any other brand. The Norjaana is, as far as I know, no longer made. 

2. Finnish looms are built so that the lams are usually of equal length and the placement of all other parts contributes such to the balance such  that they are as good or bad as any other.

3. The floating lams are not really for light treadling, but to allow more than 12 treadles by removing the pivot point that would otherwise get in the way. Unless you are considering more than 12 shafts, this is just an academic exercise.

4. The Toika dobby box fits any of the standard sized traditional CM looms out there - at most a little refitting of the wooden support bars is needed. They run on Weavepoint or PCW software - both of which can be run on a Mac in emulation.

5. Before you get over involved in your quest, find a standard sized loom in your desired width in "pure vanilla" flavor and try it out. As stated before, the biggest difference in treadling will come from the width and tension of your warp. The more taut warp threads, the more pressure needed to open a shed - on ANY loom.

I don't normally recommend going straight to an expensive dobby loom, BUT if you have physical impairment it might be worth considering. A hip or knee replacement is painful and expensive - and aftermarket parts are never as good as the factory originals.

 

Joanne Hall

It has been a while since I wove on a Bergman loom, but I do remember it.  If you are weaving with more than four shafts, it is actually best if the lamms and shaft bars are close together.  But, for a countermarch loom, the Bergman loom is a short loom, giving less space for the lamms to move.  The important thing is to not tie the treadles too high. 

And if the shafts drop when you take the locking pins out, you will then find the treadles rising too high.  That makes treadling uncomfortable.  Not only do you need to raise your foot higher to put it on the treadle, but you have to press down further to raise the shafts and then open a shed.  That is why the lower lamms need to be heavier than the upper.  The solution is to weight the lower lamms.  You can do this by tying up an extra treadle to all the lower lamms, to add weight to them.  This will hold the shafts at the right height.

>Joanne, you have solved a mystery for me.  I knew the lamms on my Bergman were causing me problems,... I hadn't even considered that the relative lengths and weights might be contributing.

And yes, having a higher breast beam height will contribute to more comfort.  You can put your Bergman loom on blocks to raise it a couple inches.

> and I am rediscovering all the reasons why weaving on a short loom--and a jack loom--was such a pain.

Joanne

conib (not verified)

Hi Sara ...

I'm very interested in learning more about the Toika computer dobby.

 You wrote:

 a 48" Toika Eeva or Liisa (the overhead beater preferably) with the new computer assisted dobby box. This runs off an electronic foot pedal laid on one of those office footrests and avoide the issue of pressure on legs and hips altogether - while giving a lovely countermarche shed and very accurate performance. The come in 16, 24 and 32 shaft models.

... and ...

The Toika dobby box fits any of the standard sized traditional CM looms out there - at most a little refitting of the wooden support bars is needed.

 

I have a Glimakra Standard 10S 10T 120cm, and a Glimakra Ideal 100cm 8S 8T.  Do you happen to know of anyone who's successfully fitted the Toika computer dobby onto a Glimakra Standard or a Glimakra Ideal?  If so, is it possible to get 32 shafts without utilizing a loom extension (i.e. how deep is the box)?

How loud is it when it's running?  Do you happen to know of anyone in the Pacific Northwest with a Toika computer dobby?

-- Constance

Sara von Tresckow

 Okay - the Ideal may be a tad small but the "skinny" on the Toika dobboy is that it fits ANY 80cm or larger standard footprint countermarche loom that has the design of the Toiks Eeva or Glimakra Standard. The Toika Liisa or similar also qualify.

Your Standard needs little or nothing changed to handle the unit.

Toika doesn't advertise this a lot because they sell more looms if they sell the combo - but you can get just the box - complete with the special shaft frames and software to run the loom. They may even have a kit specially suited to the Glimakra looms.

I mounted mine on a Lilqvist (Finnish loom similar to a Varpa Karelia) - 120cm wide and the smaller depth without the side entry. I got the 16-shaft box and as it was a little tight with more than 8 shafts, we made an extender so it is now as deep as your loom. My husband made a few cuts to the wooden support poles and we literally had it operating less than an hour later and were making movies for the kids.

Can't understand why there are noise concerns - it makes a little clicking sound when you push the pedal. The cords are driven by a motor and mechanism that lengthens some cords and shortens others - there is NOTHING there to make noise. The box works without a flaw. There are no other things to put in the loom - it looks just like your old loom aftterward except there are no more treadles.

How many shafts? 16 has been great so far, 24 might be nice. 32 would be more difficult to thread - even with treadling the threading, getting your arm back to the rear can be a real pain and there just aren't that many things that really need more than the 24.; For that 32 shaft model you'd need to contact the manufacturer with your loom dimensions to make sure it isn't too deep for your castle. Also it might need a little extension as well.

It always surprises me how little is known about what is, for me, a fantastic invention - you have a countershed loom with no extra moving parts and absolutely no tieup to get in the way of odd fabric designs. Just pop in a new file utilizing your current threading and make something different.

I have a video entitled Toika... at the bottom of this page: shows the loom in action the day we mounted it.

http://woolgatherers.com/WEAVINGINSTRUCTION.htm

The movie link is now fixed. The sound effects were for the grandkids.

 

conib (not verified)

Hi Sara ...

 

 Thanks for posting all the good info, and the link to your video.  I really appreciated seeing the top views of the functioning mechanism -- it appears to be very robust.  (But for some reason I couldn't hear any audio at all, grandkid sound effects or otherwise.)

 

 I agree that 32 shafts is overkill -- at least for my needs.  I asked because I was somewhat curious about the max front-to-back depth figure for this device.

 

 Can you tell me what the front-to-back depth of your 16-shaft box is?

 

 -- Constance

 

 

 

Sara von Tresckow

 The box on my unit is 11.25" deep. 16 shafts.

The shafts that you now have are replaced by thin ones that come with the box.

Trapunto (not verified)

Good advice, thanks!  Point taken on Toikas.

I understand floating lamms aren't for light treadling.  I was interested in the academic exercise: I have looked at so many diagrams of countermarche mechanisms, it intrigued me there was a modification I'd never never seen, and I'd like to know how it works.

Sara von Tresckow

 I offer instruction in the use of various types of countermarche looms - see web site for details.

conib (not verified)

Hi Trapunto ...

One of the parallel countermarche mechanisms is implemented in the Louet Spring loom.  The webpage for the Spring loom at Louet's Netherlands website at

        http://www.louet.nl/en/spring

illustrates their parallel implementation thus:

Louet Spring Loom Parallel Countermarche Illustration

In the Louet system each shaft is connected to its lamms via one continuous cable, with the shaft bars and lamms in fixed position on that cable.

In the illustration, the arrows on the cable indicate the movement of that cable when the A treadle is pressed, raising the shaft.  If the B treadle in the illustration is pressed, the cable moves in the reverse direction, lowering the shaft.

-- Constance

w178 (not verified)

I have converted both of my looms to the parallel countermarch mechanism and both work like a dream, and both are light in treadeling even the large loom that has a ss adaptation.

It was a lot of work but worth it.

 

gougy

Joanne Hall

This is a solution for a small or short loom, especially if the breast beam height is less than 32 or 34 inches off the floor.  With a short loom there is less space for lamms to move, so this tie-up solves that problem.  However, a taller loom is more comfortable for most, especially for tight tensions or for wide warps, where the treadling work is greater.  With a taller loom, there is plenty of space for the lamms to move.

But the difference between this and a traditional vertical jack countermarch tie-up is that with this double tied system, you have twice the number of pulleys and cords.  You have cords going down both sides of the loom instead of one side.  With so many pulleys and extra cord you do have extra drag on the treadling.  This is not very noticeable with a narrow warp.

When I tried treadling this tie-up, not only did is treadle harder, but it had a noise that I was not accustomed to.

Joanne

Trapunto (not verified)

Thank you for the diagram and info, Constance.  "parallel countermarche" was the magic search term I was missing.

runamuckweaving

Just wanted to mention that the Louet Delta has a 37" breast beam height and is very light to treadle with it's rear hinged treadles. The system is quiet, efficient and gives a wonderful shed without a lot of fuss. I have both a Delta and the older Hollandia and both are very nice looms, although of the two, the Delta treadles lighter. 

conib (not verified)

Hi gougy ...

I'm very interested in learning more about your conversions.  Did you use something similar to Louet's system, or ... ?  I'd love to see photos and/or drawings, if you have any to share ...

-- Constance

w178 (not verified)

I copyed the Louet system as that was the only parallel system that I could find on the net.  Will post photos later as there is something wrong with my camara   its not taking pics at the moment.

 

gougy

w178 (not verified)

WOW it worked all I have to do is make it a little smaller I think that is easyer said than done  haha

gougy

w178 (not verified)

As promesd a few photos of my version of a parallel countermarch loom

 

the loom was origanally a 4 shaft home made with only a rairing shead so I converted it to a 12 shaft pc following the Louet system

w178 (not verified)

I hope these photos are helpful, I find this system quick to tie up as every thing is on the parallel so no funny angels and slack tie ups as with conventional countermarch.

gougy

ps sorry but coudnt make them smaller mybe next time.

joesullins

You've had some very excellent responses with lots of golden information.  One of the things I was thinking about when you mentioned not being comfortable at the Glimakra Ideal was that I had the same experience.  I'm not overly tall or anything, but I'm also not "petite" either.  I found that smaller looms are really not comfortable for me at all.  Everything feels far too cramped. 

My main loom at home is a 40" Toika which is similar, but predates the Liisa.  I love it and find that it is quite comfortable to weave at for long periods of time.  I also have a bench, well, really it is a 30" bar stool that puts me at a very comfortable height and because it has a crossbar towards the bottom, provides an excellent place for me to rest my non-working feet. 

For me, my comfort levels (especially in my very achy, temperamental lower back) are directly related to the size of the loom and the height of the bench.  I've stayed with the bar stool because there just aren't any benches out there that will get you high enough to eliminate stress on the body.  That's been my experience at least.  I'm sure everyone has a different take on it.

TinaHilton (not verified)

An easy way to make a photo smaller is to click on photo (single click, not double) while editing your post.  You'll see small boxes in the corners.  Position your cursor over one of those till you see it turn to a diagonal arrow, then click and drag it toward the center of the photo.  I sometimes do this a few times to get it to the size I want.  Let me know if you need more details.

conib (not verified)

Hi again gougy!

Thanks so much for posting the photos!

(Also -- for me, personally, none of the photos you've posted are too big -- I really like being able to see the detail.)

-- Constance

conib (not verified)

Hi Joe ...

I have to agree with you w.r.t. the importance of loom size and bench height.  My husband recently made some "platform sandals" (pattens?!?) for the feet of the bench that came with my Glimakra Standard, raising the bench another 3 5/8" from its max height. My body is *so* grateful -- no more neck and shoulder aches!  (The bench is now somewhat heavier, though.)

(N.B. I should mention that my body conformation is not typical -- I'm short-waisted and long-legged, so raising the bench worked perfectly for me.  However, it may not be a good solution in every case.)

-- Constance

ingamarie

I have wonderful instructions from Walter Turpenning that he posted once on a weaving list for adjusting benches. I've used it with my Glimåkra bench and with chairs I use at other looms and it has always worked really well.

I posted them here http://www.weavolution.com/node/8625

marie

Trapunto (not verified)

 Gougy, I'm impressed with your loom overhaul and like Constance, I appreciate the large pictures!

The idea of "pattens" really tickles me, Constance.  I'm also short-waisted and long-legged, so I'm very familiar with the way things aren't built for us.  The fits I had trying to find a backpack with a hip-belt!  (I gave up in the end, to to tell the truth, since the ones with a short enough waist were for kids, and too narrow in the shoulders.)

 

Beth P. (not verified)

Hi Gougy,

Very cool conversion!  Where did you purchase the white plastic rollers?  I am considering doing a conversion on one of my looms.  I was going to do a regular horizontal countermarche system, but this looks like it may be better!

 

Beth

w178 (not verified)

I bought them from my lokal DIY store here in Amsterdam but I think you could buy them at any DIY shop but dont forget every shaft will need 6 wheels ( 4 shafts24 wheels)  I used texsolv cord butyou could save a bit by useing linnen cord and texsolv.

Hope that helps  gougy

 

 

conib (not verified)

Hi Beth ...

Those white plastic rollers are called "pulleys".  I've seen them available in various sizes in decently-stocked hardware stores here in the States.

-- Constance

wmvsylvie (not verified)

Hi -- I'm interested in the parallel countermarche adaptation on your loom that has the shaft switching.  How big a loom is it, what kind?  How many shafts?   How much texsolv did you have to use?  Thanks for your advice and input....Sylvie in Colorado

catbird

I was unable to find these pulleys at a hardware store anywhere locally so I made mine by buying HDMW plastic bar stock and turning them on my metal lathe.  Doing that is also much cheaper.  It is quick to set up,

easy to machine and there is very little waste.  It does require having the right tools (i.e. a wood lathe or metal lathe).

If anyone is interested in my loom build and parallel countermarche setup, I would be glad to post some pictures for you.   

 

catbird

My homebuilt loom is very similar in configuration and size to a Glimakra Standard 47" weaving width with a parallel countermarche set up as 4 shaft loom (with plenty of room to add more shafts when my expertice reaches that level). 

ReedGuy

Ron, you could post a photo or two with a little story over in the "Home Built Equipment" group on the forum. Like to see your loom. :)

catbird

I,ll check out the "Home Built Equipment" group and try to post the pictures there.  Thanks.

Katy Carr

 

Good morning,

I'm a little, well very late actually, coming to this series of posts.  I have been in conversation with Sara von Tresckow who has been patient and kind, advising me on adding 4 more shafts to my counterbalanced floor loom.  She has been a mind of invaluable information on the subject.

Sara thought that one good way would be to convert it to a countermarch system.  I was very reluctant to do this because it would mean major alterations to a dear old loom.  On reflection, I think the thing that irks me about countermarch is that everything see-saws up and down, lamms, jacks, treadles, all at disconcertingly 'untidy' angles, in total contrast to the even parallel motion of counterbalance.  But I have never used one so what do I know?!  Then I saw the Louet parallel countermarch on their website and also, searching on Weavolution (which I am new to), the photographs of your loom, which impressed and encouraged me; lovely loom and great work by the way.  So I decided to investigate further because this system would allow me to neatly add the 4 extra shafts.  The mechanism is exactly the same on the back of my old drawing board and the penny dropped as to how the whole thing works and I adapted the website drawing (apologies to Louet) which is not to scale. 

The fittings marked 'e' are hooks and eyes on the shafts where the chains are attached.  The shafts have metal heddles (I want to keep these) on metal rods inside wooden top and bottom bars.  Anchorage points for the cord are shown on the fronts of the lamms and the bottom rail of the shafts, but on reflection, they should be on the back.  I am hoping that upper lamms would be redundant as I have bottom wooden rails on the shafts.  All I have done really is move the pulleys inwards to line up with fitting already on the shafts. (The inside pulleys at the top will be 8 inches in from the side of the loom which is 50 inches wide and 50 inches deep).

I would be very grateful for any comment as to the feasability of this adaption to my loom or is it just completely bonkers!

Thanks and best wishes, Kath

 


 

SallyE (not verified)

This loom started out as a horizontal CM, and was converted to a parallel CM.   (BTW, it's no longer for sale as I later converted it into my draw loom!)

http://weavolution.com/forum/sale-or-trade/countermarch-loom-fs-boston-…

The advantage of the parallel CM is that you can add shafts with no loss of shed.   On a CM that uses a pivot for the lams, the closer you get to that pivot the less shed you get on that side.   It's just geometry!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on