I need to buy a 12 dent reed, maybe a 22 inch?  Is there a particular company that has really good prices on them and reasonable shipping charges?  I'll be using it on both the Macomber and Herald loom. 

Thanks in advance,

Deb in N TX

Comments

Alison (not verified)

Hi Deb,

Joanne Hall (one of our advertisers) carries all sorts of dents and cuts to your specifications.  You can find her stock at www.glimakrausa.com.

You can also email her at [email protected].  There are several satisfied customers on Weavolution.

Alison

sally orgren

I like your efficiency by thinking about using one reed for multiple looms!

You didn't ask, but I thought I'd post these little tips for future Weavolution users who might be cruising the forum database and searching for information about "reeds"...

If you look at the denting chart in the Debbie Chandler book, you will discover that if you own an 8, 10 and 12 dent-per-inch reed, you will have *almost* ALL e.p.i. possibilities covered! The only exception is if you like to use very fine threads, and then you might want to consider one of the finer-dented options for other reasons. (I have a 20-dent for this application.)

You don't need to go crazy with all kinds of sizes of reeds. Warp threads are typically happier rubbing shoulders with their buddies in a single dent than abrading the metal edges of a smaller-dent reed.

Be aware if you get a custom-length reed, the ends might not be as nicely finished (capped) as the standard widths. As far as I can tell, it doesn't effect the performance of the reed at all, just a cosmetic difference.

Also, if you are weaving a narrow warp, sometimes you can get away with using a reed from a table loom on your floor loom. Conversely, if your loom has open-ends on the beater, sometimes you can get away with using a longer reed than the beater, allowing the ends to hang out on either side.

...All this from a weaver who tries to keep the clutter in my weavatorium to a bare minimum, and loves it when one tool can serve many functions!

P.S. Halcyon also sells reeds.

Michael White

On Sally's note above. Are three of our Macs have a slot that the reed sits in. You need to measure your Mac & Herald loom's reed slot to be certain one reed will work. Like Sally said a slot going all the way across the beater allows you to use long reeds in a short track. Someday when I can find the time I will look at making a modification  to the Macomber's beaters.

Michael

kerstinfroberg

Just for the debate: older (before 1950ies) Swedish weaving books say that you have to use a reed with an appropriate length compared to the width of your warp. A reed should be approx 2-5 cm wider than the warp. In a thesis on househols weaving in the 1800s it says that they used one reed for weaving the "body "-width shirt material, and a smaller one for weaving the sleeve-width shirt material...

(No, I don't do that. And I think both reeds and material looks well enough, even after many yaears of usage.)

Joanne Hall

Hi Kerstin,

That is very interesting information, using a reed that is just a little longer than the warp width.  Do you suppose it might have something to do with the reeds being made of wood then, rather than metal?  I am trying to think of what the reasoning might have been.  It is convenient when warping a loom to use a shorter reed for a narrow warp.  ?When you have more than one loom, you might have a shorter reed to use.  I do that, along with shorter lease sticks and sometimes a shorter tie-on bar.  But there must have been a reason for that recommendation.

Joanne

PS all our reeds have the proper ends.  We stock them in 9 foot lengths, cut them to the size you want and carefully put the ends on with the number of the dent on it.  We have them up to 30 dents per inch.

debmcclintock

When I was traveling in Laos there was 3 sizes of reeds or fuums, they were used for traditional widths of fabric.  One was narrow for the skirt band, one was a little wider for a pa biang or shawl, the third was much wider for the skirt width.  The skirt band was sewn onto the skirt width.  The shawl was the final part of the outfit.  (sorry, not where I can measure them to quote #'s).  The girls started to learn on the skirt bands and worked their way up into the more complicated shawl and skirt body.  The reeds were switched out of the loom frame with their pattern holders.

Perhaps the Swedish books were based on the same type of methodology or tradition.

More contemporary skirts in Laos were woven with the skirt band incorporated into the warp of the yardage and cut and sewn in the traditional way.   

regards  Deb

debstein (not verified)

  Thank you all so much!  I really thought I would have to buy a 12 dent reed, but just learned that I  can adapt the project which calls for 27 epi to my 10 dent reed by sleying 2-3-3.  Happy day!

I have a 10 dent for the Macomber and a 15 for the Herald - can use the smaller one on the Herald, but can't use the 15 on the Mac.

 

Deb in N TX

 

kerstinfroberg

Hi Joanne,
after looking through the books in question, I'm afraid the answer is "I have no idea".
The weaving instruction books just say "it is best if the reed is about 5 cm wider than the warp", and the history books just state the fact.
The (best) history book is Grenanader-Nyberg: "Lanthemmens vävstolar" (Stockholm 1974 - ISBN 91-7108-076-7). She talks about a time when wooden reeds were common, although the making of metal reeds was started around 1850, according to  Svedenfors: Vävskedsmakeri och hornslöjd (Stockholm 1952, no ISBN).

The more modern weaving instruction books are all from 1920 ->, so they ought to refer to weaving with metal reeds.

The first reason I can think of is that IF using metal reeds AND having significant draw-in the dents can be permanently damaged, leaving marks in wider cloth later - but that is just a guess. In my experience, wooden reeds are more, er,  "resilient" than metal rreds - at least fine ones are a lot easier to sley than are metal reeds of the same count.

... speaking of "reed marks" - when I examined the wooden and/or "reed" reeds I happen to own, I found one with interesting marks.. read about it at. oddweavings.blogspot.com/2010/01/reed-marks.

Joanne Hall

Hi Kerstin,

 I do have that book and I can read well enough to understand most of it.  I will read about the reeds again.  Tage Olsson is someone who might be able to answer some questions.  I will send you the email address.  

I have three old reeds.  Two came from Tage who purchased them at a loppmarknad near Mora.  One is 60/10 and has VIIII on one end and VIIIII  on the other end.  They look like they were marked at the same time, but the extra I looks like it was added later.  Maybe the weaver added it when she found it was not correct.  It does have the same carefully tied crosses at the end but no carving.  It is almost 8cm tall.

The other one came with it.  It is also probably a 60/10also 8 cm tall.  There is a very faint VIIII on one end, but I cannot be sure it is the same.  They are both 81 cm long.  This second one has a repair.  The wooden sticks broke near the center on one side, so they have two metal pins about 8cm long tied to the wood in several places to keep the reed rigid.  The metal pins, now rusty are about the size of those used as shuttle pins.

I have a third one which is probably a transition reed.  It is made with metal pins rather than wood, but it has the old style wooden ends, tied with the same X tie on the four corners. It has 33/10 rör written in pencil on one end.  It has the counting cord, through the reed every 30 dents, about 8 cm, with some variation.    It has 10 of these sections and so it was made to have exactly 300 dents.  It is 94cm long. This one came with a loom I picked up in Chicago, from a couple from Sweden who said they were retiring and moving.  It had belonged to her grandmother in Dalarna.

Joanne

kerstinfroberg

I forgot to mention that the older instruction books, like Ekenmark's Mönsterbok för unga fruntimmer (originally printed 1827) and Engeström's Paraktisk vävbok (originally from 1896) do not say anything at all about the width of the reed compared to the warp width.

Ekenmark mentions that the "normal" reed width (presumably equal to the normal loom width?) is 7 1/2 "quarter" (1 quarter = almost 15 cm = almost 6" => 112 cm or  45") - Engeström says nothing about widths.

Grenander-Nyberg (see above) mentions that the 7 1/2 quarter is a "standard German reed" (no source), while a "vadmal reed" is either 90 cm or 120 cm wide.

Zone5gal

Well, I too just ordered reeds for my little CV macomber.  Here is what I discovered...its a 22 inch macomber...so I ordered 22 inch reeds (from Hacylon)  but when the came, they were actually 24.15 inches long.....which wouldn't fit in the slot for my macomber....so I've reordered from Paradise Fiber.. Schact brand reeds   which I hope are on their way, but weren't in the box that came today....AAHHHH!  (I ended up ordering 20 inch reeds-- 10 dent and a 15 dent-- and an 18 inch reed which is a 20 dent.   Frankly, after you shove the heddles to the side, my 22 inch macomber really is only going to weave a 16 or 18 wide runner...maximum!  But that's okay, because I'm quite into scarfs right now.  Hope to post a picture soon in "my corner of the world section"!     

Zone5gal

Joanne....do you have a store?  I would have bought my reeds from you if i had known.... 

Joanne Hall

Hi Rebecca,

We have the Glimakra ad for the Julia loom that pops up now and then on the left side of your screen.  If you click on the ad, it goes to our website.  Ed is sitting at the loom with heart shaped thoughts of Julia.

When ordering a reed, you should always order it by the weaving width and the maximum length.  There are 1/4 inch bands on the sides of traditional reeds, making them 1/2 inch longer than the weaving width.  If you want to order from Halcyon or Paradise Fibers, just ask for Glimakra reeds, as they both order some of their products from us.

Joanne

claudia (not verified)

Hi Rebecca,

It will be great to see a picture of your project.  You might consider putting it up in your notebook which is under the "My Stuff" tab.  There is a special place there for your projects and you can add new projects using the links in the left side of the page navigation list. More people will have the opportunity to see and enjoy your project if you post it there.  Then, you can copy the link from the url address bar at the top of the page and post it wherever you want.

Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions.  My email is [email protected].  We also have a Tour for Users under the Help tab along with other topics that may be of interest.

Happy weaving!

Claudia, Weavolution co-founder

chuck19836 (not verified)

I am looking at getting another reed for my Le Clere Dorthey  I presently only have a 12 dent what would you recomend?

 

laurafry

Depends on how thick/thin a yarn you typically use - a 10 might be useful - you could get 5 (one thread every other dent), 10 (of course) 15 (2/1) 20 (2 per) 30 (3 per dent) and so on.

 

cheers,

Laura

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on