I'm starting this topic after finishing a scarf on the rh loom using sock yarn for the warp and weft.  I have decided that selvedges on the rh loom are not as easy as they are on a floor loom. In fact, I just went to the studio and spent the past hour weaving a bread cloth on my Baby Wolf 4 shaft loom. The selvedges are straight and beautiful.

Here is the sock yarn scarf. Yukky selvedges. This was not an easy yarn to use and to get a balanced weave of 10 epi and 10 ppi I had to work very hard. It was easier to have 14-15 picks per inch rather than the plain weave required 10.

See, the selvedges stink.

Anyone have ideas? suggestions? thoughts on this issue?

Claudia

Comments

Caroline (not verified)

just a thought, why not crochet an edging?

Seriously, I think I get into more trouble with my selvedges when I think about it. My current project is a sari silk bag on the Knitters Loom. I am spinning the yarn as I need the colour runs, but even after torturing the silk through the hand carders its still a bit textured, and because I have overspun it a bit so it doesn't fall to pieces, the selvedges look terrible:

Some of it is because its really uneven, and at other places its because there is a knot or fuzzy bit at the edge, like the one you can see in the picture. The only thing in its favour is that its consistent, so I'm hoping I can somehow disguise it once I put the bag together. I do find it easier to make consistent edges if I ensure the weft bubble is pretty much the same each pick, easy to do with a weft-faced weave, but it seems to work true for balanced weave too. I do hold the side of the fell so it doesn't drag and distort as I place the weft, and once I start beating the weft I let go, and start placing the weft from the yarn/shuttle side and work back, checking its not pulling as I go.  I also change shed before I start beating or use the RH to place the weft. I might end up with too much weft at times, but thats easier to sort than when its pulled too tight.

But you are probably doing all this anyway! Worrying is going to make it worse not better, because with the best will in the world you will tense up, and this follows through to your weaving. If you concentrate on achieving consistency in the arc of the weft, you will find the selvedges take care of themselves and it all settles into a regular pattern.

I take it you prefer weaving on your Baby Wolf to your Rigid Heddle loom? Perhaps its time to just play with the RH and see what happens, instead of trying to do a specific project with a specific outcome. Make your sampling fun.  Once you have made friends with the loom instead of fighting it, you will wonder why you even had this problem.

HTH.

sandeleh (not verified)

Claudia, I've done a lot of weaving of scarves on my RH loom and have pretty good selvages (so far, anyway).  I suspect your edges on the sock yarn stem from a too-loose sett.  I have always woven my sock yarn projects at 12.5 epi.    I also add the step of laying down my shuttle and making sure the weft is at as steep an angle between the fell and heddle as possible.  Then I beat with both hands on the heddle to make sure the fell stays at a 90deg angle to the warp ends. 

I've left the photo above rather large so that you can see the selvage on the blue scarf - it is pretty even, I think.

 

Above is a photo of my Woolease (warp and weft) scarf on the RH using my 10dpi heddle.  The Woolease is nominally a worsted weight yarn and actually very much thicker than sock yarn.  It behaved well for me in the 10 dpi heddle and you can see the left selvage pretty clearly - it's pretty even looking.  (The yellow ribbon on the right is my measureing tape)

I have not woven very much on a floor loom, but I think the motions needed to get good selvages differ from those needed to get a good selvage on the RH loom.  I find that my lack of experience with boat shuttles leaves my selvages looking a bit ragged or worse!  LOL.  I suspect that my selvages will improve with more practice.   And I think if you spend a bit more time on each pick with your RH your selvages will look a lot better very quickly.

Sande in Fresno, CA, USA

 

debmcclintock

 awesome use of materials and color on the rigid heddle, thanks for sharing!  Deb

bolivian warmi

After Deb's comment I am now doubly intrigued. I read Sande's post before but never got to see the photos as they wouldn't load-very large files or just my dubious connection?

Okay..........after 90 seconds they are viewable.

Yes, this is gorgeous. Now if I can only convince them to bring sock yarn here..........

Adding to my US trip shopping list. Thanks Sande.

Laverne

EDIT: It's just my connection playing up right now.

KSfiber (not verified)

I've woven a lot of sock yarn scarves on my rigid heddle loom using a 10 dpi reed.  I like the drape they have with the open sett.  You do need a light touch when you beat.  Like don't think of it as beating.  Think of it as pressing it into place.  Count your picks until you the the idea of what it looks like too.

I go slow on a rigid heddle loom.  Maybe that helps my selvages.  I know it keeps me from over beating.  I put my shuttle down before I beat & change sheds too, using both hands to keep the fell line at 90 degrees to the warp.

 

sandeleh (not verified)

Sorry for the big photos, Laverne, but I wanted to be sure that the selvages would show up well.   I hope the wait was worth it.  :)

Sande in Fresno, CA, USA

 

bolivian warmi

Absolutely!! Thank you!

Laverne

claudia (not verified)

I know the big photos cause havoc for the dial up folks but I appreciate being able to see your selvedges.

I am caught between liking the drape of the sock yarn warp at 10 dpi and finding it a bit fussy to work with. Like KS I put my shuttle down and gently place the weft in being certain I have it at a 90 degree angle to begin. Once I got going, the scarf came out really nicely. It's just different working with the sock yarn. The heavier yarns are easy by comparison.

Thanks for all the help folks. And, as always, it means a lot to be able to see the pictures. Your scarves are really lovely Sande.

Claudia

sandeleh (not verified)

Hi, Claudia  (and thanks for the kind words!)

If you are putting in the weft straight across the warp before you beat, that could be the cause of your selvage problem right there.  The weft wont have enough length to beat in well if it is straight across the loom and leaving extra on the leading edge will make for wavy edges.

Instead, place the weft at as steep an angle as you can from the fell at leading edge to the heddle at the exiting edge.  I push my shuttle thru, then put it down and place the weft by hand, holding it where it enters the shed at the selvage then using other hand to make sure the exiting end is as close to the heddle (still in blocks) as possible.   Then I beat using both hands on the heddle. 

I attempt to move the heddle in an arc so that it beats at the fell on a closed shed, then continue the arc to open the opposite shed while returning the heddle to the opposite position on the heddle blocks.  I find this arcing movement places the weft nicely and clears the opposite shed if the warp is a bit sticky.

I'm sure that the more you practice the better looking your selvages will be.  :)

Sande in Fresno, CA, USA

 

janetdawson (not verified)

I had some trouble with selvages when I started using my RH, too, even though I've had nice, neat selvages on my floor looms for years.  I think it's just what Caroline said early on: the evenness of my selvages depends directly on how much I don't think about them - if my autopilot takes over they're much neater. There's a whole different rhythm and technique to weaving (slowly) on a RH than on a floor loom, so my autopilot couldn't engage at all for a while until I'd figured things out a bit. Once I had and it could, my selvages improved a lot.

claudia (not verified)

Hi Janet,

Nice to see you here. I am in the same boat as you. I had found this nice rhythm with my floor looms and I just engage the autopilot and the selvedges looked great.

Not so with the RH loom. The rhythm is very different. I am very certain to always put the weft in at an angle but the auto pilot for the RH loom hasn't kicked in yet. I'm still looking for my rhythm.

Meanwhile, I am back on the floor loom and thinking about what to weave on the rh loom once I finish this job for a client.

Claudia

sandeleh (not verified)

The only thing I've woven on my Fanny (45" counterbalance) was a series of 3 rugs.  One sock loopers, the other two different "hairy" selvages from  (agh!!  brain fart!)  the folks who bought Edgemont.   No doubt I'll remember their name in the middle of the night when I'm trying to sleep.  LOL.

The very large nature of the weft on those rugs precluded my using boat shuttles, so I still have to learn to wind bobbins and throw and catch the shuttle.  heh.  At least on my table loom I can practice the throwing and catching and not have to worry about the beater or levers at that instant.   There are a whole lot of motor skills necessary to weaving and I'm glad I can learn them one at a time rather than all at once. 

That does leave the question of when I will warp up the Fanny or the Pendleton (36" jack) - not this winter for sure, as there is no heat in the house and the back room is exposed on 3 sides and very cold.  Of course, it's too hot to weave back there in the summer, so I have about 2 weeks of spring and 2 weeks of fall when the room is bearable.  < sigh >

Sande in Fresno, CA, USA

 

djfiberarts (not verified)

I go slow on the RH too. That does help your selvedges.

Curious...have you used sock yarn as warp as well as weft? How does that work out?

DJ

claudia (not verified)

I love using the sock yarn for both warp and weft. I like it at 10 dpi, some prefer 12 and I want to try that. A friend and I have a little business and sell our pre-wound warps on Etsy. (lotsaknots.etsy.com) and the sock yarn warp is a big seller for us.

I have to weave slowly and carefully with the sock yarn. It is easy to beat too hard and firmly. I have found that I place the weft in the shed and then move the heddle to the opposite shed to "beat" it in place. That way I can beat it on a closed shed and keep it at 10-12 ppi (picks per inch) which I prefer. Getting the right tension has been a little tricky and that is what creates the greatest variation in the selvedges for me.

Claudia

2and4 (not verified)

I too struggled with my rh selvages after years of weaving on floor looms. What finally worked for me is adapting some techniques I learned in an intermediate (floor loom) weaving class with a production weaver. First, I make sure the weft wraps snugly around the edge thread - not tightly, but touching. Then, instead of bringing my weft across in an angle, I make a "hill" (for lack of a better word) with the weft - higher in the middle, then back to the fell at the other side. Finally, I "beat" on an open shed (holding the heddle in its up or down position all the way to the fell), giving the weft lots of room to arrange itself. It sounds time consuming but it gets quicker with practice.

Cindy in NH

claudia (not verified)

Thanks Cindy. I just wound a warp for the RH loom and I'll give that a try. Tapestry weavers create hills, as you call them, when they lay in the weft. I learned that this fall when we were in Taos and I watched various tapestry weavers at Weaving Southwest and Centenela.

Claudia

mmorse (not verified)

I'm getting a lot of practice on selvedges, having decided to give scarves as Christmas presents. Pictures in the not-too-distant future. Yes to "autopilot" and better results. Though I'm right-handed, the left edge looks better than the right. Given that there are 54 ends (double on the edges, 10-dent), the "hill" technique seems to work fairly well, and pulling out slightly on the edge warps, but on a wider fabric it might not be enough. One of the scarves is superwash merino sock yarn warp and weft, and I quite like it. The width was just right for the stripe repeats. Others I've done with Paton's bamboo and silk and bamboo and angora as warp and weft--maybe a little like thin table runners, but I'm new at this. The only disappointment is that my handspun alpaca isn't as polished looking as the commercial yarns, but then my hand-spinning is only slightly more advanced than my weaving. And now to finish the last one.

Happy holidays to all and a good new year!

Caroline (not verified)

Yes, I know about that left-hand selvedge - I think its because if we are right handed we tend to fiddle with the right side of the cloth more!

Theres no one, set in stone method of hilling, arcing or otherwise laying the weft in so its right. A lot depends on the yarn you are using, whether its a balanced, warp, or weft-faced weave, and the thickness of the yarns too. Fortunately it doesn't take long to get into a routine, so if you allow the first few rows as fringe, there is not much wastage of precious warp.

Please post piccies! Have you fulled your scarves yet as that tends to fluff the yarn out and take up a lot of slack and even things out. Franco (francorios on here) has a few before and after photos here on Weavo, and talks about the need for fulling on his blog, and shows what a difference fulling/washing makes:

francosfiberadventure.blogspot.com/

It also shows how practice makes more perfect. The blog is a visual diary of his progress as a weaver, and because he documents everything, even his whoopsies, its a good learning tool as well as entertaining!

claudia (not verified)

I like the idea of doubling the selvedge threads. I haven't tried it with the sock yarn warp and I do it all the time when I make napkins, bread cloths, etc on my floor loom. I am having a head-slap moment here. I am going to give that a try, I bet it will help firm up that edge and improve the result.

I feel like such a dummy. Thanks for the idea.

Claudia

BridgetJ (not verified)

 Wow. Yes, double on the edges. I'm having that exact same head-slap moment right now. Can't believe I didn't think of that before.

Saille (not verified)

so i use 8 dpi, so that might be my trouble with my first project? i even puy down my shuttle and try to do it right, are there set steps to follow to help with the selvages?

sarahnopp (not verified)

I just noticed the cloth beam tie-on rod is bending in the middle after I start it... so the edge have additional tension. I am staring at it to figure out a solution... perhaps additional wrapping between tie-on rod and beam?

Claudia Segal (not verified)

Can you post pictures so we can see what's happening.  Here's a little help on how to add photos to your comments.  There is also a YouTube help topic HERE.  If you are using IE for your browser, you might encounter problems since IE does not play well with Drupal sites like ours.

Claudia

sarahnopp (not verified)

I think I resolved my issue by letting off the tensioning pawl and rolling it onto the cloth beam a little bit. The new section is tensioned evenly. So my guess is the rug warp was just a bit too sturdy for the tie on bar, and now the tension has been switched to the much thicker beam, all is well.

rinka

Hi, I am a newbie weaver and having troubles with my selvedges. There has been some great advice in these comments that I am going to try. What does it mean to double edges, double the selvedge threads?

Joanne Hall

If you are weaving something like a rug, which will be getting a lot of foot traffic, it may be the edges which wear out first.  So, if you double the warp threads, the rug may last longer.

There are not many warps which require doubling the selvage warp threads for weaving purposes.  But if you are weaving with a fragile warp thread, you might strengthen the selvages by doubling them, or by using a stronger thread for the end selvage thread.

Joanne

Littlehomesteader

Hello.  I have just finished a scarf using variegated sock yarn for warp and Adriafil Kid mohair/silk weft.  12.5 plain balanced, or nearly.  perhaps the weft is about 11-12 ppi.  The fluff helps with separating the weft to this ppi,, and I was squeezing rather than beating.  Such fine yarn made it easy to get the selvedges quite nice. A close turn without being tight. I've not washed it yet, but it looks lovely anyway.  Drapes nicely too.  Only just neck soft.  Mohair can be like that.  

One 400m skein made a warp finished over 12" wide and it's a good length. I am 5'10". Sorry not at hand to measure.  I used just over one skein of mo' for the weft, annoyingly!  Only my second warp, so I'm very pleased!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on