Hello, I'm about to order my first reed and was wondering what the difference is between stainless and carbon steel reeds. Currently, I own an 8 dent reed - I think it's carbon, from Leclec. They sell the two types but don't indicated what the difference or pros/cons are. Any ideas? Much appreciated. L.

Comments

whiteoakgrandmother (not verified)

Hi Lyndsey. The big difference between carbon and stainless is that carbon steel will rust, stainless won't. Stainless costs more.

Lyndsey (not verified)

Thx for the info. My loom is inside the house and dry so I'll go for carbon. Thx L.

sally orgren

I would politely suggest going for stainless steel. Doesn't matter where the loom is located, "moisture" can happen. (What if you are weaving with linen and need to mist the warp or use sizing while weaving? What if you want to try painting a warp?)

If you want a forever-reed, spend the money. It will also put you in a better position if you ever sell the loom. 

Sally

Michael White

L. Sally gave you very good information. I would add shop around for the best price. Most manufactors of looms buy their reeds from someone else. The biggest differents in reeds is the height. A 12 dent reed is a 12 dent reed but it can be 3 1/2," 4", 6" and up .You need to check your loom and the reed you are using.

Michael

debmcclintock

over the years I've bought reeds and usually been lucky, upon occasion I have a "duh" moment (ok, more than one "duh" moment).  So here's my duhs in hopes you can avoid your duhs.

One thing that can make you nuts is if your reed top and bottom caps DO NOT fit into your slot that holds the reed in place.  I've had to use foam to hold the perfect reed sett in place to weave something.  Be aware of how the reed is finished.

The next thing is if your beater has "closed ends" that don't allow your reed to "hang" over the edges, just be aware if you have room to wiggle or if you REALLY have to care about the reed width.

Michael White

Deb, we know about "closed tracks" The Macomber used a close track. On Cheryl's other looms she can use a 48 inch reed on her 22 inch loom if need be. I looked at redesigning the beater on the Macombers. Too many ideas and not enough time to work on all of them.

Michael

SallyE (not verified)

Ya, I bought a reed that was just about a half inch too large for my Macomber.   I took the beater off and cut the sides of the vertical pieces of the beater back just a bit so that the reed would fit.  That is one major thing that Macombers needs to redesign.

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on