I am fairly new to weaving, only for about 1 year - self taught.  I have great books to help me, and I am absolutely in heaven while weaving (any part of it).  

I have discovered a repeating problem -  my right-hand selvage is always nice and neat and looks very good, but the left-hand selvage is a bit "bumpy."   Not largely so, but enough to be notice it isn't "perfect."

Is there some tip or expert advise about how to get both selvages looking nice?  I'd love to hear from you about this. 

Thanks much!

Nanette

Comments

Claudia Segal (not verified)

Hi Nanette,

I am not an expert but also face the same problem.  When I did ask an expert weaver about this she said "keep weaving".  So, I guess the answer is that it's a common occurrence and the more you weave and keep aware of the issue, the more likely it may improve.

I hope that helps,

Claudia

TNWEAVE (not verified)

I have the same problem, and an experience weaver told me to use a floating selvage on both sides of my warp. That seems to help. He also told me if my first thread on the left is on shaft 1 and my last thread on my right is on shaft 4, (this is on a 4 shaft loom) is would help, but have not try this yet. Hope this will give your something to try.

sequel (not verified)

It may be that one selvedge is on the up shed and one is on the down shed and one or the other is under more tension, which resists draw-in by the weft.  I have found that the tension on the lower shed on LeClerc jack looms tends to be softer than the upper shed.  Other looms might have the opposite situation.  The weft pulling against the softer warps will move those warps more (draw in) than the weft pulling against the upper, tighter warps.

Another situation is when the weft is pulling against the second thread from the edge instead of the first, usually on alternate sheds.  If you are having problems on a counterbalanced loom, the weft that pulls against the second warp thread may seem to pull in also. 

Just my personal theories...

 

 

debmcclintock

Check on how your thread is rolling off of your pirn from the bobbin.  It might be catching from one side of the shuttle feed. That will add to the effects that was posted in #3 note.

Check if you are twisting the shuttle as you bring it out of the shed.  You might be handling it differently from one side compared to another.

#1 rule is DO NOT FIDDLE with it!  Try to control your winding of the pirn and the throw of the shuttle.

Floating selvedges, loom controlled selvedges and an end feed shuttle helped me control my borders!

Saille (not verified)

my issue is to know how tight or loose the selvage should be when you start the next row.  iam working on my first project after designing and buiding a table loom. it is a scarf.

Joanne Hall

Hi Nanette,

Often our dominant hand is stronger.  So, if you are right handed, you may be throwing the shuttle better with your right hand.  With practice, you will be able to throw the shuttle the same with both hands.  So, tighten the warp as much as is practical, as a tight warp is easier to weave and keep weaving.  Using a temple will also help, as you need the weft snug at the selvage to keep the selvage threads from getting loose.  If you are not familiar with using a temple, or need some other ideas about selvages, look at our weaving FAQ:

http://glimakrausa.com/faq.html

Joanne

sally orgren

If you are weaving on a floor loom with a bench, I have heard that you should scooch a bit more toward the "bad selvedge" side. I have tried this and it seems to work. If I have problems it will be my left selvedge, and I am right handed.

It likely has something to do with being dominate on one side and throwing the shuttle slightly differently as a result (as others have mentioned). I am not a physicist, but moving my butt an inch or so seemed to moderate the effect.

I do weave under tight tension, use floating selvedges and temples frequently to increase my chances of getting consistent selvedges. ;-)

Keep weaving—Yes, they will get better!

Cally (not verified)

I second the suggestion to look at Laura's videos - they are very clear and helpful.

Like Sally I am right-handed but I tend to have a better selvedge on the left! I put it down to having better control over catching the shuttle rather than throwing it - I think I am more likely to tug with the left hand and thus over-tighten the right selvedge.

However, I just keep weaving and do my best to get into an even rhythm. And having treated myself to a lovely Bluster Bay shuttle seems to have made a big improvement! It travels smoothly and fits neatly into my hand so that that rhythm is easier to achieve. That's my story, anyway, and I'm sticking to it ;-)

Cally

neweaver (not verified)

Thank you for the link as a new weaver I found many helpful hints and video is much easier for me to learn.

Cindy

sally orgren

Cally mentioned a great tool that I use nearly all the time, too — end feed shuttles. (Sometimes referred to as EFS). They work better for wider warps. On smaller looms or narrower warps, not quite as efficient IMHO.

BTW Cally, if we were to sit side-by-side on same the bench weaving the same warp, what are the chances we could play to our strengths and get perfect selvedges on BOTH sides? (Or would we just end up with BAD selvedges on both sides?)

Sally

TinaHilton (not verified)

I'm right-handed and have trouble with my right selvedge.  Try shifting where you're sitting.  Rather than sitting dead center of your warp, move to the left or right.  If I remember correctly, you're supposed to move away from the bad selvedge.

katski (not verified)

I used to have the same problem of good selvedges on the right side and poor ones on the left. Then one day I noticed that I did something different with each hand as I threw and caught the shuttle. It was a very small and subtle movement, I would briefly catch the selvedge in my thumb and forefinger as I caught the shuttle and pulled the weft snug. I only did this on one side - the good selvedge side - and not the other. It was very quick and almost unconscious. Once I became aware of it, I started doing the same thing on the other side and my selvedges got more balanced. Try payng attention to what you are doing with each hand and simply make sure you are doing the same thing on each side.

Cally (not verified)

Sally, I think we'd end up with shuttles and selvedges all over the place!

Cally
at the other end of the bench

fheller

My selvedge problem is a little different.  I am making a curtain.  My warp is double the finished length and half the finished width, so I am going to seam it up the center.  I like a firm selvedge on the unseamed edge and usually get one.  However, I would like to have as little draw-in as possible on the edge to be seamed.  Any suggestions?

Joanne Hall

A temple will make the weaving go easier as well as give you better selvages.

Joanne

ReedGuy

I've been "learning" to use my temple on my blanket as well. :)

fheller

Thanks for the advice.  Have never used a temple and don't own one.  Will look for instructions here.  I remember someone had a link for how to make one.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on