Anne Crowley (not verified)

Ok, first it is hard to compare the two for me... I have lived and breathed Inkle for so long now.  Inkle is amazing, but somewhat restrictive.  I way like the closed loop aspect and the easy warping, I warp up most any design in about 15 minutes (depending on distractions).  I lean toward setting up for straight weaving and avoid pick up a bit because I am a caregiver and often get taken away from my loom.  However, once a weave is on and going it goes like the wind and looks great, on average I can complete 14 feet in about 5 hours.  One other aspect of Inkle that I love is that I weave on pretty extreme tension.  My first bought loom imploded on me halfway through.  It just collapsed because I wasn't used to adjusting for the lack of stretch in cotton threads. oops

In backstrap I see so much more potential.  Wider weaves for one.  The idea of being able to incorporate patterns and pictures fascinates me.  The portability is also a great feature, I have cats and dogs here... putting up the loom is handy.  I am still learning, but that old high tension bug is still with me, so I am having to find SOLID anchors to work from.  This will get better with time and experience.  As far as the difference in the work, so far I have been doing similar weaves between the two and find that a simple strap is pretty much the same... tamp, draw, pinch and set.

On the Inkle loom I have gotten pretty good at keeping all the warp threads even, occasionally I use an odd thread that stretches differently and I find my self hanging an extra weight somewhere in the middle that holds loose threads tight while I weave.  Fishing weights, bags of coins, whatever I can hook on a loop and hang near the middle of the warp will help with the stubborn stretchers.

I hope that answers your question? Each loom has it's good and bad points, Inkle is pretty stable, and a bit limited, backstrap has lots of potential (potential for me to go wonky and tangle and oh, my!) for so many projects that I have in mind.  I see it as a stepping stone for larger weaves like rugs or simple tapestries... I am excited to see a world opening up in front of me!

(These are my traveling loom.  This shows the double width back board... light but with much more strength than a single board.  The pegs look silly, bent as they seem to be, but no chance of them letting go, they rock with the weave and hold quite well.  The loose looking pegs are merely me not getting the holes tight enough.  Tension adjustment is merely pull a peg, adjust the warp path and set it back over the pulled peg.)

marywareodc (not verified)

Thanks Laverne - that makes sense but looks a bit advanced for me as yet!  Is that how Navajo looms work too?  I remember reading something about turning it around and working from both ends.  In fact I'm making a lot more sense of the Navajo loom from this backstrap weaving.

marywareodc (not verified)

Thanks Anne - that's very helpful.  Wow you weave fast!  Yes, I can see that the backstrap loom offers more possibilities.  Though I learnt the hard way about tangles.  My 1st attempt at rearranging the cross to do a comb pattern went very wrong and I ended up having to undo the whole warp.  Next time I'll try using 4 warp pegs.

I also understand about crooked pegs etc as most of my equipment is home made and crooked - but its the strength that's important.  On the table loom I often hang cartons of water (or anything handy) off the back to correct loose warps.

Sharonl (not verified)

That's an awesome loom Anne. Did you make it yourself?

I'd like to work out how it was made as its perfect for what I want. I find most inkle looms are just to small for me.

Sharon

francorios (not verified)

To help me keep my heddle loops even, see what I did on my blog:
 
Here I am tying on the string heddle. Important thing to remember is to thread the heddle string through the shed first! Then start tying to the heddle stick. Here I am using a shed stick as a spacer to help keep a uniform length on the string heddle. I am pulling the string off the cone and through the shed so I don't have to guess how long the string should be for the string heddle.
 
 
 
It's the third picture in the article.

 

Have a good day!

Caroline (not verified)

hi Mary, your selvedges are AWESOME! My first attempts were quite pitiful, trying to concentrate on so many different new things, but it was my first ever woven piece. 

I'm not doing the WAL, but encouraging from the sidelines, and watching these threads with great interest.

jenadina (not verified)

I have progress :) I've woven 13 inches. My selvedges are a little wonky, but so far my scarf has stayed between 3 1/8 and 3 1/4 inches wide, so I'm pretty happy with that. My backstrap, which was my first project way back when, ended up drawing AT LEAST 2", so I can live with 1/8 inch margin of error for now. I do envy your beautiful selvedges, though, Laverne!

The center is slightly more warpfaced that I had hoped, but I'll survive :) Overall, I'm very happy with my progress.

The yarn (both warp and weft) is some kind of acrylic sock yarn; the label is long gone. I had to hairspray the warp heavily to get it to behave, but it's much better now.

Now for photos:

Here's a super-close up:

jenadina (not verified)

I made my loom sticks with my handy dandy Dremel and some dowels :) Easy peasy...I just used the little sanding attachment!

Aw, shucks...thanks! It's not quite balanced, though...it's somewhat warpfaced in the center. I did *order* a rigid heddle, but it's backordered so I won't see it for another 2 or 3 weeks.

That reminds me...anyone who hasn't tried Laverne's heddle method yet needs to! It's fabulous! My loops don't change in size at all, which means I get a nice shed! I can't believe how well it's working with my hairsprayed sticky warp; I can only imagine how great it will be with a better-suited warp!

Caroline (not verified)

As an alternative to those lovely shaped loom sticks, I am using the bars from a Semco tapestry frame, with the cloth taken off, and well sanded down. They look almost identical and keep things under control. They are made to work under tension so are light but strong.