I'm a fairly new weaver, having recently bought my first loom, a rigid heddle.  But I can see already that at some point I will want to move up to either a table loom or a floor loom (at first I liked the idea of a table loom but now I'm leaning towards a floor loom, despite the extra cost).  Anyway, I'm trying to decide if I would want 4 shafts or 8.  I'm drawn towards the fairly complex patterns which leads me to believe I'd want 8, but maybe I am overreaching.  Can any of you comment on whether 8 are really necessary for most designs?  Is there anyone who has 4 but wish they'd gotten 8?  Anyone who has 8 but rarely uses more than 4?  I know there are several looms with the 4 now, 4 later option but it seems it ends up being more expensive to add the 4 on later than to just start with 8. I would welcome any comments or input.

Comments

laurafry

If you are already looking at more complex weaves, go for the 8. You don't need to use all of them if you don't want, but you will have room to grow. :) Cheers Laura

mneligh

I went from potholder and rigid heddle to a 20 shaft, after having taken 3 semesters in colllege with 8's.  I've never regretted it, and frequently do 16 to 20 shaft patterns, although for the first time in 30+ years I have a single-shuttle plain weave warp on it.  Also, I have done a lot of 3 shaft rugs in the last few years.  

If you go to Harrisville loom site and go to the potholder loom page, they have a little app for designing potholders!  These are no-shaft plain weave.  There are plenty of drafts and combinations I never thought of, and I thought I was the queen of potholders.  If you download it and try it, you will be amazed at what you can do with 2 shafts, and that is with no variation in texture or yarn size.  

A lot of the standard weaves -- overshot, doubleweave, summer and winter, twills, can be done on 4 shafts, and you can spend a lifetime with just these.  Having gotten a new potholder loom, I'm now trying to convince my husband that we should add onto the house, so I can get a very large drawloom with the equivalent of maybe 100 shafts.

If you  figure out the right number of shafts, you can tell me.

sally orgren

You will have the capacity if you need it. And if you want more shafts than that, I think an 8 would be easier to resell than a 4.

The hard choice is table vs small floor loom. Ideally, you need both. If I could only get one, I suppose I would get a floor loom, as it is faster to weave with foot treadles. (Then I would borrow or rent a table loom for workshops.)

ReedGuy

I've got 8, use mostly 8 shafts, but have used 4 and 6. Even with a plain weave you can use all 8, and a herringbone twill can be expanded from 4 to 8 shafts. I do have 10 treadles now for weaving 8 shaft overshot, the two extra for the tabby ground. I really don't have plans to expand beyond 8, I can go 12 or 16. 64 lamm cords and 24 shaft cords are enough to tie-up I figure. :)

tonyaleacht

This is going against the grain, but I've had a 2 shaft, 4 shaft and 8 shaft loom. My favorite was the 4 shaft. I found the 8 shafts too many to dig through for 4 shaft patterns, and I didn't use them as much. I had a hard time keeping track of which shaft I was on even with color coding. I sold it and went back to a 4 shaft and was much happier. (course I'm a tapestry weaver and settled down to a 2 shed loom so maybe I was just heading in the wrong direction with 8.)

blueskies (not verified)

Thirty years ago I started with a rigid heddle loom.  I still enjoy using it, but it has had many other looms join it over the years.  The first step was was a used 6-shaft Macomber that was able to hold 10 shafts. I enjoyed getting used to four for a while, then figured I needed to see what 6 would do.  Well, over the years I have bought the additional equipment so it is now 10 shafts, 14 treadles (it won't hold any more) and a sectional beam to go with the plain beam. I bought an 8-shaft table loom for workshops, but it is tedious to use once you get spoiled by a floor loom.  I have done a little tapestry and find that my most enjoyable weaving is loom-controlled, whether it is twills, laces, doubleweave, bead leno, or any other loom-controlled weave my loom can handle.  I did do some multi-shaft type weaving with the rigid heddle by using multiple rigid heddles, but that's when you realize you need a "real" multi-shaft loom if you want to get something done in a reasonable amount of time.  If money is a major consideration, it would better to get a really well made 4 shaft loom over a flimsy 8 shaft.  Also think how wide you want your finished fabric?  Think how wide your reach is to comfortably throw a shuttle?  If you are short like me, a 40" wide weaving width is about as wide as you want to deal with.  Also what kind of space do you have to set the loom up?  Eventually, I had to build a separate building to house all the weaving because my husband felt the walls were closing in on us in the house.  Being able to keep it set up encourages project completion. Whatever you get, if you really get into weaving, it will not be your last loom.

jlread (not verified)

If you're the 'go get it type'....go for as many shafts as your check book will allow!.....It just saves you the time and trouble of buying and selling...Been there.....done that!

pammersw

Personally,  I'd like someone to give me a 48" 8s 10t Macomber, as the checkbook doesn't even allow a rigid heddle purchase! I found out yesterday that I will be officially unemployed as of today. A lot to do in the next few weeks,  with only a little weaving time in the evenings. 

ReedGuy

That's gotta suck Pammersw, not even a two week notice?

mneligh

That is brutal news, but the good side is, there's more time to weave.  Since the recession hit, I've been erratically employed -- killer 60 hrs/week projects or nothing.  I've found I actually like that schedule more than the standard 40 hrs/week, but then I have my looms and wheels for the times between projects.

I would say it's time to study Andean backstrap weaving.  It can distract you from the depressing activity of looking for jobs.

Good luck!

pammersw

First, I need to sort through ten years of stuff so I can sell my house. I can't afford the mortgage on unemployment. There will only be a little weaving in the evening to unwind. 

Sorry about the thread highjack, original poster!

Submitted by Raine59 on