Just curious - what is everyone's favorite type of heddle?  Being a newbie, I've only used flat steel heddles, which work great but are a bit heavy and make a racket, for sure.

Also, what are the advantages/disadvantages of an X frame loom over a standard floor loom?

Thanks!

Karen

Comments

claudia (not verified)

Hi Karen,

My preference is for inserted eye heddles mostly because they are easier to see when threading and I have limited vision.  As for an x-frame loom vs. a floor loom, I own one of each and the x-frame loom is lighter weight and folds up to move it or store it.  Some people bring them to workshops because they are light and easy to handle.  The floor loom is heavy and more versatile.  You can weave rugs on a floor loom and not on an x-frame, you can weave silk on a floor loom and an x-frame. 

I think it comes down to how much space you have available and what type of weaving you want to do.  I am currently moving more towards rugs and tapestries and away from fine threads and am looking to sell  my 8-harness floor loom.  So, if you are anywhere near Washington, DC or Frederick, MD, let's talk.

Claudia

Sara von Tresckow

 Also, don't forget the shedding mechanism on a loom.

Countershed - any shedding action that raises some warp threads while lowering the rest is the ideal for weaving all types of fabric from light to dense. Even stretch on all warp threads, smooth firm shed floor makes shuttle race unnecessary.

Sinking shed - this sinks the threads on some shafts and leaves the rest where they are. For a one way shed, this will give a firm shed floor and wide range of fabrics, although there is still the issue of some threads being stretched more than others.

Rising shed - this raises threads on some shafts while leaving the rest in the starting position. This shedding is not as good as the other two for firmer fabrics (fine or coarse). By stretching the threads upward, the shed floor will always have a little slack. This is usually compensated for by a shuttle race, but still interferes enough with the beat that rugs and firmly woven household fabrics will always be a bit looser on the rising shed loom.

Lizbuppers (not verified)

Just curious - why can't you weave silk on an X-frame?  I've never woven with it either way, so I have no idea.  So far, the only fibers I've woven in my 2 years with a floor loom are cotton, wool (for a felted bag) and lots and lots of tencel.

lkautio (not verified)

I think Claudia said you could weave silk on either type, which jibes with my weaving experience.  However, finer linen is another story.  It is not great on a shallow loom (which many folding looms are), especially one with more shafts, and shafts which rise more in the back than the front.  I love 40/2 linen, but not on a shallow x-frame.

A sinking shed jack is very nice to weave on - not sure why they are more rare now than they were in years gone by.  Rollo Purrington made a lovely one with springs that brought the shafts back up when you stepped off the treadle.  They do take some getting used to after only working on rising shed or countermarch.

I like metal heddles, and really dislike texsolv or string which take me three times as long to thread.  I've used flat, inserted eye, and twisted wire for metal heddles.  Of these, the inserted eye works best, except in some cases of very fine threads on few shafts (when it is tough to get them spaced close enough). 

Laurie

tien (not verified)

My favorite is texsolv - they are quiet and kinder on fine threads.  It took some time to get used to working with them but now I find that I'm as fast or faster threading texsolv than I am at threading metal heddles - it all depends on what you're used to!

But there are many reasons for choosing heddle types...for me, texsolv makes most sense because:

(1) I have lots of shafts - 24, to be exact - so the lighter each shaft is, the better off I am.  Texsolv is much lighter than metal heddles.  (This can be a disadvantage, if your loom relies on the weight of the heddles to lower the shaft.  Mine doesn't.)

(2) I work with very fine threads - my current project is warped up with 60/2 silk at 15000 yards per pound - and Texsolv abrades fine threads less than metal heddles

(3) I like my loom to be relatively quiet - Texsolv does not come down with a crash and bang the way metal heddles do.

For those three reasons, texsolv is the right choice for me.  For you?  It depends on what you're looking for in a heddle.  :-)

Tien

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on