I am about to give up. I finally started making progress on my overshot Thanksgiving table runner, weaving more than I was unweaving, and now a new problem has surfaced. About every 6 to 8 inches, my right side floating selvedge is breaking. I am using 8/2 tencel, have even tension, and am using a temple (the weighted edge temples). The left side selvedge is fine. What is going on?

Thinking back, I had this same problem when I wove my color gamp throw using 3/2 perle cotton. It is always the right selvedge thread or threads. I have not had this problem on any of my towels, scarves, or placemats. Is there anything that can be done to stop it?

Comments

Joanne Hall

Hi Gailc,

Even though you are using a weight type temple, look to see if the last woven wefts are drawing in.  The width of the warp in the reed is the width the temple should be holding for you.  If the temple is not holding it out this far, you will have wear on your selvage threads.

The reason it is happening more on one side than the other, is that you are probably throwing the shuttle faster from that side.  This makes the selvage nice and tight, which is good, but the temple must hold the width out to the full size to prevent selvage problems.

Take a look and see if you can weight the temple a little more.  Or perhaps it is time to invest in a wooden temple.  It will hold the full width and it will be easier to move as well.

Joanne

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

Depending on the twist direction of the warp and weft yarns, the act of beating in a weft can have the effect of beating the twist of the selvedge end into the web -- in other words, loosening the twist in the unwoven part.  This always only happens on one side.  The warp end gets weaker as more twist is taken away, and finally pulls apart.  The only solution I know of to minimize this is to double the selvedge warps.

Bonnie.

 

Joanne Hall

PS  I read your message again.  Broken selvage threads are more likely to happen with a wide warp, which can cause more draw-in, and it can also happen when you beat harder, which you may be doing with this table runner.  In both cases, a temple is needed even more.

Joanne

gailc

Thanks, Joanne.  I think it may be time to get a wooden temple.  I will check out your website again.

 

Gail

gailc

I tried doubling the floating selvedges and it helped, but didnt solve the problem.  The right selvedge, or one of them, broke after about 12 inches.  Just before I reached the end of the project, the left selvedge broke as well.

I didnt have much draw-in, only about 1/4 to 1/2 inch on each side.  The finished project came out the same width as the instructions indicated it would.  I have a lot of this yarn left, but I dont know if I would use it again.  If it breaks so easily, wouldnt poking the teeth of a temple in weaken it as well?

At least the finished runner is nice.  I refuse to look for any errors that I missed - I am just going to assume there are none.  It was such a relief to put in the hemstitching at the end:

 

Joanne Hall

Hi Gailc,

It would be nice if you could send this photo to Susan at Yarn Barn.  Not only would she like to see that you did such a nice job on this runner, but they would like to know about the breaking selvage problem.  I am sure that they would like other weavers who purchase this kit to not have this problem. 

[email protected]  ask for Susan.

Joanne

debmcclintock

Nice job on the runner!  Looking at your photo it looks like the tape that is over the reed at the bottom is coming loose.  Is it possible that that is abraiding the warp enough to wear it down and break it?  Look at the reed teeth also and see if somehow something is amiss there. Sometimes they bend or fray.

Here's another link to a making a temple also... I usually make mine for lighter scarves and runners and use the larger metal toika temples for my rugs...

laurafry

Just curious - did you skip a dent before you sleyed the floating selvedge? 

Another thing that might be a factor is the relative humidity where you are.  I've found that if the relative humidity drops below about 50% Tencel tends to get a bit 'brittle' and threads may start to break.  When I use Tencel in the warp and the humidity is low I run a humidifier which seems to help........

Cheers,

Laura

Ellen (not verified)

Forgetting about your selvedge problem for a moment: That is a beautiful project!!! :-)

gailc

Thanks, Deb. Yes, the tape on that reed (a brand new toika by the way) was peeling off.  I thought that might be contributing to the problem, but it was only the outer floating selvedge threads that broke.  I would think that other threads along the warp would also have been abraded.

gailc

Thanks, Laura. No, I didnt skip a dent betweent the last warp end and the floating selvedges - will that help?  I guess the humidity could be below 50% because the heater has been on for a few weeks and that dries the air.  I always assume that with four cats and a panting dog I have plenty of CO2 and water vapor in my inside air, but maybe I dont.  The selvedge threads almost seemed to pull apart rather than snap, and not one other thread broke, so I have no clue what was going on.

 

Gail

gailc

Thank you, Ellen.  I am happy with it - especially happy that it is done.

 

Gail

gailc

Thanks, Joanne.  It is a boost to my confidence that expert weavers like you and Deb M think I did well.  I guess I wove it well enough for you to recognize that it was a yarn barn pattern.  I will send a photo to Susan and let her know the problem I had.

 

Gail

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

Hi Gail.  Your runner is beautiful!  In addition to all the good advice you've gotten, another thing that will help save your selvedge threads is to not beam them on the warp beam.  Dangle them over the back beam and hang weights on them.  They should be at about the same tension as the rest of the warp.  Having live weight rather than static tension allows them to give when there is a little draw-in.  I'm a stickler for not having any draw-in as I weave, and for that a temple is mandatory.

Bonnie.

 

laurafry

Okay - I just thought I saw a bit of a gap between the floating selvedge and the rest of the cloth on the left hand side and wondered if that gap might have been part of the breaking problem.  It's hard to see but it doesn't look as though you have excessive draw-in and since you didn't have problems anywhere else, just the floating selvedge, I would think the breakage has more to do with the Tencel than anything thing else.  Checking your humidity is a simple thing to do - you can get small gauges to show that in most hardware stores.  Since you don't have this problem with cotton, I would suspect lack of humidity (at least relative to what Tencel needs.)

Otherwise, well done.  Looks like you have a nice consistent beat and pretty straight selvedges.  :D

Cheers,

Laura

gailc

Thanks, Bonnie.  After the selvedge thread broke the first time, I replaced it with a weighted thread that wasnt beamed and never went back to the original thread.  The weighted one still broke routinely.  I dont know what I will do if I try this yarn again.

lkautio (not verified)

If you are having the same trouble with 8/2 tencel and 3/2 cotton (which is very sturdy) it is probably not the yarn. Many weavers can handle these yarns without a temple.  You can check for burrs on the heddles and reed on that side, the squareness of the loom, higher tension on one side of the warp than the other, and the difference in draw-in on both sides. 

One thing that often works is to sit 4-8" off center.  I can never remember if you move toward or away from the bad selvage (try both if no one chimes in with the answer), but it can make a surprising difference.  Or, try an end feed/delivery shuttle.

Laurie Autio

Joanne Hall

Another thought about your floating selvage is that it is traditionally used when the last warp thread is not being caught into the weave.  Overshot is based on plain weave, so a floating selvage is not necessary.  The pattern weft does not need to go around the selvage thread.  If you are asking Susan about the kit, also ask her why the instructions call for a floating selvage.  Or, is that something that you decided to add?

Joanne

Submitted by gailc on