I want to learn to weave! (I'm a knitting addict, a potter, a quilter... who's now eager to weave... and spin... and... well, you get the idea. ;-) )

Which type of loom do you recommend a new weaver buy?

So far I've been considering either a 32" RIGID HEDDLE LOOM, a 15" 4-SHAFT TABLE LOOM, or a 36" 4-HARNESS FLOOR LOOM.

Would a 32" (2-shaft) rigid heddle loom become too limiting in design opportunities? (Would I outgrow this quickly or be happy with it for a long time?)

Would a 15" 4-SHAFT TABLE LOOM create too narrow of a fabric?

OR, would our money be better spent by buying a FLOOR LOOM - to get multi-shaft and wider fabric width?

Thank you ~

Donna

 

Comments

laurafry

As so often with weaving questions, the answer depends.

A rigid heddle loom takes up less space than a floor loom, but a floor loom is more efficient, allowing you to weave longer/wider cloth with fewer issues.  A shaft loom allows you to weave more complex weave structures more efficiently.

If you are serious about wanting to make all sorts of cloth, not just shorter, narrower textiles, I'd suggest you go with the floor loom.

There are many looms available second hand.  Buying second hand would allow you to get a loom with more features and let you test the waters without investing heavily in a loom until you know more about what sorts of things you like to weave and whether or not you want more (or fewer!) shafts.

Welcome to the wonderful world of weaving!

Laura

Sara von Tresckow

How about a 24" rigid heddle loom?

32" is a bit unhandy, while 24" is wide enough to do clothing fabric as well as smaller items.

The rigid heddle is like an apprenticeship in a box - the limitation of plain weave forces you to learn to set up your loom, use a variety of material, use color effectively, learn how to handle threads under tension, how to finish woven cloth - and by the time you exceed the basic capability of the loom you're ready to tackle a more complex loom without a big learning curve.

Yes, you can buy a bunch of heddles and do exotic things on the RH, but at that point you're best off saving your pennies for a larger loom. I'd say go straight to a floor loom. Table looms, no matter how many gadgets you add remain table looms - rather slow and awkward.

There are nice little floor models starting with a 22-27" weaving width, and of course there are always the larger models. It is also worth conisdering looking at counterbalance or countermarche floor looms when you get that far - they produce a greater range of fabrics than rising shed (jack) looms.

neweaver (not verified)

Being a new weaver myself, I decided to get a used floor loom and went with a 45" Leclerc, they are readily available and less exspensive than some of the others.  So it was my first loom, came with extras and gave me a chance to see what weaving was about.  I would not have continued if I had started with a ridgid heddle loom but that is just me.  It has been a year, I'm totally self taught - have never even seen anyone else weave and now have just sold my leclerc, bought a Macomber with sectional warping beam, have 2 ridgid headdles, a Glimakra standard and a couple inkle looms...the bug bit!  I enjoy what I do on the RH, but for me its not as 'zen' as a floor loom.  Good luck.

jlread (not verified)

IMHO...I would go straight to the floor loom...I learned the hard way...don't waste $$$ on a rigid heddle, they are very limiting. You can find a nice used floor loom and >>>>> resell it easily if you choose not to continue weaving. There is a host of used equipment sites for loom shopping. There is also a buy and sell section here at Weavo.  Best of luck....

francorios (not verified)

I have to agree with Sarah about the rigid heddle loom. The limitations can make you focus on some weaving basics. My first loom was a little frame loom made from a picture frame. I moved up to a rigid heddle which is a great beginner's loom. I also like the backstrap loom and the frame/tapestry loom. I have a small multi harness (Structo) that I have yet to warp up. Have a good day! Franco Rios

Michael White

Donna, as you can tell from the above a floor loom is the way to go. How, what floor loom? If you let me know where you live I will give you a listing of guild and weaving shops in your area. You may also find a weaving group for your area here under groups in the orange box above, Going to a guild will allow you to try out different looms. When you get ready to purchase a loom let me know and I will give you a list of sites selling used weaving/spinning equipment.

Welcome to the world of weaving,

Michael

lkautio (not verified)

My preference would be to go straight for the floor loom.  There is nothing you can do on a rigid heddle loom that you can't do (and generally more easily) on a floor loom.  If you choose a jack loom tie each treadle to one shaft and you will soon have a good appreciation for how weave structures work, but with far less effort than picking up the threads you need on a rigid heddle.  I don't see any benefits to the table loom for 4 shafts.  With 8 or more shafts a table loom will allow you to experiment (slowly) with many more shaft combinations than a treadled 8-shaft floor loom without any retieing, but on a 4-shaft jack loom you can easily do all the combinations with two feet. If I had started with a rigid heddle or table loom I doubt I would still be weaving 25 years later.

Whatever you choose, try to get some weaving lessons.  Books and videos are good, but an experienced weaver can help you achieve good technique faster.  That is, easier ways to warp, handle a shuttle, use your body fully, understand drafts.  There is enough in weaving to always find something new to learn. Enjoy the ride!

Laurie Autio

weaver-dyer (not verified)

At the risk of sounding like a "me, too," I agree with Laurie.  If you have a choice, start with a floor loom. 

Many guilds (and instructors) rent looms and other weaving equipment.  It's not only a great way to try weaving without making a big investment, but also an opportunity to see if a particular loom is suitable for you.

Janet

celtinbirks

I started out with a 24" rigid heddle loom and had it for a year and decided that weaving was for me.  I took a few lessons at a guild on a floor loom, then sold the rigid heddle.  I looked at new floor looms and newer used ones, but I didn't want to pay $500-$1200.  After several months of patience, I found this beautiful vintage 4 shaft CB floor loom on Craigslist for $150 with lots of accessories and books.  ( My new rigid heddle cost me $250!) This loom will do anything I want for now and should last me a long time.  If I had to do it over again, I, too would go straight for a floor loom.  If you don't have much space, try to find a small one.  Buying a used vintage loom could save you a TON of money. If you end up loving weaving, you won't be sorry that you bought a floor loom and if you don't love it, you shouldn't have much of a problem selling the floor loom.

Good luck!

Candace 

skiingweaver (not verified)

I'm another one that would never have continued if I'd started with a rigid heddle (I bought one for my daughter and it drives me batty every time I warp it for her - I actually gave in and bought her a little table loom instead).

The Spinners and Weavers Housecleaning Pages is a great place to start looking for a nice used loom along with Craig's List - and your local Guild may even have a program where you could rent a loom for a little while to experiment with it.

Have fun! Welcome to weaving!

- Kristin

 

sewdoggie (not verified)

I just checked out the site you mention, and found a loom there that's close to where I live. Restored, but shows some rust on heddles, is that a huge problem? Also, it's a Structo from Dick Blick in the 60's . Any thoughts?

celtinbirks

The rust on heddles can be bad if it is so severe that it has "eaten" into the steel.  If it is just a thin coat that hasn't made the metal rough, it really shouldn't be a problem-it just might come off on your yarn.  If it has made the heddle eyes rough, no amount of cleaning, soaking, etc., can remove that.  They will tear your yarn up.  It is the same way with a badly-rusted reed.  If it is rough, you need new heddles.  You might be able to find some that fit.  Good luck

lkautio (not verified)

Some people absolutely love Structos and collect them.  They can be tiny and very portable, great for showing someone something quickly with very little waste, or weaving a sample or two.  Those plusses are some of their greatest liabilities - it is not a loom I would want as my only loom.  They tend to be hard on the hands.  They are not great for weaving long lengths of material.

The rusty heddles can be cleaned if they are still structurally intact and not sharp.  Lots of elbow grease does wonders.

Laurie Autio

sewdoggie (not verified)

how are they hard on the hands? I'm new remember, and apologies to Donna for intruding on her topic.

celtinbirks

A Structo loom is a table loom in which you must move the levers with your hand to move the shafts up and down. Everything you are doing with the loom (changing the shafts and throwing the shuttle) is done with your hands and arms.  That is why it is harder on your hands and arms.  It is also at least twice as slow as a floor loom with treadles.  When you have treadles to move the shafts, the legs and feet are doing some of the work as well as the hands/arms.  A table loom is a lot better that no loom at all though.

lkautio (not verified)

I find the levers on Structos harder on my hands than most table looms. Dorothy table looms are also hard on the hands.  Some levers move much more easily or are at an angle that is more ergonomic.  If you have any tendency toward arthritis, carpal tunnel, or other hand pain or weakness weave on any table loom you are considering before buying it.

Laurie Autio

yarnslinger (not verified)

Thank you, ALL, for your GREAT input.

I will be attending next month's local guild meeting, taking a class, trying out different looms, looking for a rigid heddle (used or new) to get the basics down now and allow me to travel with a project-in-hand always, while I patiently look for just the right floor loom! Phew.

You are all so wonderfully supportive. Thank you.

Donna

sally orgren

The BEST loom is the one you think you'll weave the most frequently on! But as a beginner, how do you know?

This drove me NUTS when I was beginning. I'd ask "What kind of a loom should I buy?" and my guild mates would respond with, "What kind of weaver are you?" I didn't know - I was a beginner!!!

So I ended up borrowing the guild's workshop loom, which happened to be a 15" 4-shaft Dorothy. Best thing I ever did! (Okay, I confess I "borrowed it" for nearly 3 years-they are a very wonderful and understanding group! ;-) In retrospect, a table loom like this (or a Structo, or Voyager, etc) *really* helped me learn structure because I could see a direct result in the fabric from lifting one shaft or several shafts together.

Also, joining a guild that hosts participatory round-robin workshops, or attending a conference and taking a round-robin workshop, is the second best thing I did as a newbie weaver. I got a chance to weave on a lot of different table looms and even some small floor looms, like the Schacht Baby Wolf. Talking to other weavers about what kind of looms they have at home for their "big" loom was also very helpful. 

I think every weaver needs at least two looms, a portable multi-shaft loom (more than 2 shafts) for learning opportunities and small-scale sampling, and a heavier floor loom for ease in weaving off more substantial projects.

So finding the "best" loom might be more of a process, and change as you develop more skills as a weaver. With that thought in mind, try not to over pay for your first loom, and get one in decent working condition. Don't expect to make money when you sell a loom. Just be happy if you can get the same for it that you paid (at best), and know that if you buy new, you will probably receive less in resale than what you paid (kind of like buying a new car, once you drive it off the lot).

Enjoy the journey—and let us know what you end up finding that works for you! I am sure your path to find the BEST loom will help others that are to follow!

sewdoggie (not verified)

I went with a Kromski Harp and stand. After having a Union 36, I just knew I needed a smaller loom, so am starting here. I also ordered a rigid heddle book from Amazon. I am so intimidated by you all with your harnesses and the terminology used, I need a guide. I think fibers are what concerns me the most, I have no idea what to buy, hoping the book will clear that up.

naturalfibres (not verified)

Sewdoggie, I've been weaving for over 25 years and there are lots of things that I don't know about weaving - especially the terminology, I'd be hard pressed to name all the parts of my loom!

Anne

laurafry

Weaving cloth is a complex craft - one of the reasons I chose it.  I knew that I could study weaving for all of my life and still not know everything.  :D  After weaving for 35+ years I'm still learning.  And loving it.

cheers,

Laura

neweaver (not verified)

I'm a new weaver also and its been like learning a whole new language, without a teacher!  It is difficult to know what kinds of yarns to use, joining a guild helped for me to be around other weavers and to for the first time see what handwoven articles looked like and the potential.  I purchased a lot of the older Handwoven magazines and pour over those paying attention to yarns, sett and number of harnesses used.  My first 2 projects on my floor loom were rugs that I had to lift the yarns everytime I threw the shuttle because the 'shed' was so bad.  I kept referring back to pictures to try and figure out what I did wrong.  It wasn't until AFTER finishing the 2nd rug I realized I hadn't gone OVER the back beam, boy did that make a difference on the 3rd rug!  Start simple, get a good book like Learning to Weave and enjoy the journey.

Cindy

sally orgren

Cindy,

True confessions! I'll bet it is a rare weaver who hasn't done this at least ONCE in their weaving life. More embarrassing is when it happens AFTER you have been weaving for a long time. >Ahem. Cough. Cough.<

A quick fix (and maybe you figured this out) is that many back beams come off. So when this happens, I just relax the tension, remove the back beam, slip it under the warp, and reconnect it back to the loom frame.

Thanks for sharing your experience. It brought a smile to my face while I am thinking "oh yeah, been there, done that!"

Sally

jemwork (not verified)

I can't believe you even got a shed!

I believe there is a book list here somewhere that could help with weaving books. There are several books for beginners ( they name the loom parts)  Debbie Chandler's is great, available new & used.

I still have my first loom - 32" LeClerc Fanny 4H CB, 1971. It needs work on a wonky beater. I have many other looms.

The weaving community is wonderfully sharing - just like all the fiber arts. Find a guild. There are videos online about winding warps, threading looms, weaving all sorts of things. Weavolution has classes. I get notices on FB from HGA & Handwoven. There are lots of ways to connect & learn. 

I love Laura Fry's statement. I was captured by weaving early & am still learning.

Joan

PS Unfortunately, there is no one loom. Looms are like rabbits - they know how to reproduce! (Harriet Johnson)

celtinbirks

I'm not sure why, but the above person copied my post on this thread from 3/29 and posted it again, even with my name at the bottom.  Maybe the person REALLY agreed with my opinion........weird...........

Candace

celtinbirks

there is some sort of an ad to click on at the bottom of the post copy.  Just probably some sort of spam

Claudia Segal (not verified)

It was spam and I removed it.  Thanks for the heads up.

Claudia

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on