Hi, after a lot of faffing around trying to get my loom up the dogleg staircase in my new place, I've finally got it set up (a lovely old 8-shaft countermarche by Don Porritt).

My first few projects are going to be scarves for friends, I want to start simple and get my rhythm going, so I'm going to be playing around with twills. This first run is going to be using a black alpaca warp and a recycled sari silk weft, around 6" wide when finished.

What advice can you give me for suitable selvedge on something this narrow, that's going to be a fairly loose weave (at 8 epi)? I'm thinking to just double up the outer 4 at each edge, and then also have a doubled-up floating selvedge, but does this sound like overkill - or underkill? I want the pattern to make it all the way to the edge, since the scarf's not that wide anyway. I've been trying to make sense of the selvedge recommendations in Anne Dixon's Handweaver's Pattern Book, but I'm confused as she seems to suggest having 8x double-up threads close to the edge but then singles at the actual edge (before any floating selvedge).

Comments

Claudia Segal (not verified)

I am relieved to hear someone else finds Anne Dixon's selvedge suggestion confusing.  
You want the pattern to go to the edge and you want a floating selvedge?  I would do a doubled thread floating selvedge on each side.  Be consistent in your weaving.  If you go under the floating selvedge as you enter the shed, go over the floating selvedge as you exit the shed.  Use the same method throughout and you will catch the selvedge every time.

Having a floating selvedge will slow you down.  If you want to KISS this project, put on enough warp for several scarves and weave them in plain weave.  You will not need a floating selvedge and the sari silk will be the focus of each scarf.  Or, try plain weave on the first scarf with NO float and see what you think.  You can always do a twill on the 2nd scarf.  My personal rule of thumb is, if the materials are complex in color, keep the weave structure simple.  If the materials are solid colors, use a more complex weave structure to add interest.  Twill patterns with hand dyed yarns may not be seen because the yarn takes center stage.  It's just IMHO.

Claudia 

padmavyuha (not verified)

Thanks - the scarves are for a couple of people who enjoy complex patterns (well, and so do I, so I'm keeping one!), hence the twill, it's meant to be psychedelic, along these kind of lines:

I was wondering more about a selvedge that's within the edge, before you get to the optional floating selvedge - which is what Anne Dixon seems to be suggesting. Necessary? Desirable for something of this narrow width?

Sara von Tresckow

On a narrow scarf, a doubled floating selvedge is all you need for a nice edge - just single warp threads for the body.

I normally double my selvedges with or without a floating selvedge, but for light, narrow scarves, i.e. mohair, I just use single threads across the entire warp and weave gently.

You are correct in wanting to use a floating selvedge where point twills in experimental combination are in play. That way you are assured of catching the edge thread. Slowdown from this on a scarf will be negligible and you can concentrate on your pattern development.

Karren K. Brito

I weave twills all the time, I just use a floating selvage.  After a while the over under becomes second nature and I don't notice that I'm doing it.

A word about the recycled sari silk yarn; we are attracted to this yarn because of the vibrant color but when you look at it for structure  it is a dense, high twist, irregular yarn.  It can make  some nasty cloths.  So sample before deciding on your definitive weave structure.  If you don't like just the sari silk weft in twill, try adding a tabby shot of your black alpaca in between each twill shot.  This will add structure so that you don't have to pack the sari silk so tightly to get a stable cloth and generally lighten (weight not color) and make the cloth drape better.  You will still see your twill pattern.  Anyhow try it, you might like it.

padmavyuha (not verified)

Thanks, Karren, I've been wondering how the sari sillk might drape, this is why I'd opted for a more open weave (and the alpaca is finer) but your suggestion is an interesting one, I'll play with it.

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

Since you are threading 8 shafts, will you weave some of the scarves as 8-shaft twills? If so, there will be more need for a floating selvage with an 8-shaft tie-up. The one shown is a standard 2/2 twill and you can weave this draft using 4 shafts.

I agree with Karen. I think 8 epi is a very open sett, one that can be used to weave weft-faced rugs. Inserting a tabby pick will help. Another option is to use an 8-shaft twill tie-up: 2/2/1/1/1/1. I have not woven with the silk sari yarn.

padmavyuha (not verified)

My loom doesn't take too kindly to being run on only 4 of its shafts, that's why I've set up the twill for 8 shafts.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on