Hello Weavolution Members!

We've been taking a look at the site and how you are using the site. One of the things that comes up regularly is the drafts section. We seem to have a number of duplicate drafts. We believe this is due to the way we, as weavers, name drafts. In embroidery, quilting, and many other crafts there are names for different stitches, patterns, etc. However, there isn't one sett naming convention for drafts in the weaving world, or maybe there is and many of us just don't know about it yet.

I would like the community to use this post to discuss how draft names should be constructed here on Weavolution. If we use a common draft naming convention it will be easier for members to search to find drafts to associate with their projects and help us from duplicating effort.

Please comment here on how you name your drafts and how you think we as a community should name drafts posted on Weavolution.

I hope we will all learn a lot from this process. It will definintley help us improve the site!

Thank you for your insight,

Erica

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

WHile I don't often use this section, I just took a peek. There are several factors in each project - and the individual "drafts" are truly projects in that they contain a weave structure, instructions for threading and treadling this structure, yarn type, color scheme, and loom type recommended for this fabric.

If might be helpful to put "keywords" into an uploaded draft - basic structure type, loom type, minimum shafts requred, type of yarn used, use of fabric, etc. - that would facilitate looking up a keyword to narrow one's search for an idea.

For instance, looking under "twill" and "scarf" would narrow the items shown.

Erica

Sara good thinking. If I've understood the developrs correctly. We need to define our taxonomy, or tags/keywords in advance. We're open for help in defining and choosing the taxonomy! :)

Yes I think one of the things we need to figure out is how to explain the difference between projects and drafts to newcomers. Perhaps a different name for projects?

kerstinfroberg

"naming" anything in a way that allows others (or oneself, for that matter) to find it is, IM not very HO, impossible as long as the "naming" (in this case probably "tagging") is left to the person adding the draft. (The same goes with looms - there are lots of duplicated there, too. A search for "wolf" in category looms yields 30 results, which I have not followed. Even if there *are* 30 models of wolf looms, counting all possible widths, # of shafts etc it is certainly not helpful.)

Could there be a list of keywords to choose from, in addition to the person's own words? The list must be the responsibility of one person alone (or a closed group), to avoid "creative spellings" (ie typos).

And... as there is a figure ("Times used") - how come that always shows 0? Either link to all the projects that have given this draft as source, or omit it.

Finally, let me disagree with Sara: the draft, as such (meaning the form that appears when clicking "add draft") does not contain anything about colour, yarn, loom etc - which is good, IMO. If the "adder" wants to give lots of extra info in the text section, is a totally different question. (But I also agree that such info should be placed in the project section)

Sara von Tresckow

Sorry, I just took a quick look and saw a lot of variance in what was showing.

Probably the place to start is for Weavolution to define what is a draft and what is a project and set up a drop down list of terms that would standardize the keywords used.

Technically, the smallest representation of a draft is the interlacement square, because there are possibly several threading-tie-treadle combination that can give this interlacement. Probably for practicality, we'd want to have the threading, tieup and treadling/liftplan included.

Once there is a "filing system" created, it would be much easier to upload a draft and file it so others can find it. 

Erica

Thank you for the excellent input. Please keep ideas/thoughts coming!

Erica

Thank you for the excellent input. Please keep ideas/thoughts coming!

laurafry

Part of the problem with naming drafts is that the person doing the naming may not have sufficient information to accurately identify the draft. I think tags should be broad enough to signify categories (ie twill, tied weave) but perhaps not individual 'names". Eg overshot rather than a specific overshot pattern? Just a thought... Laura

Erica

Your suggestions are great. They make me think drafts should be categorized. What do you think about drop down menus for number if shafts, weave structure, colour and weave effect (yes/no)? Any thing else we should add?

Perhaps we need to have new drafts and looms verified before posting?

Sara von Tresckow

The type of loom recommended for the draft might make sense - such as multii-shaft, rigid heddle, inkle, tablet, backstrap.

laurafry

Hi Erica,

Maybe you could poll a few of the more knowledable of the weavers for suggestions for categories?

cheers,

Laura

SallyE (not verified)

I was looking at drafts in Handweaving.net and thinking about this question.  First, I think you would have to define your caregories, i.e., what is the definition of a satin, a twill, etc.   And second, you would have to allow drafts to fall into multiple categories.  I did a search under the category "color and weave" for just 8 shaft drafts.   The second one was an 8 shaft satin.

Without some stated definitions, a lot of people would simply opt for "my own design."   They might do that in any case. . .

And then there is the problem of a draft that falls into a given category but doesn't always follow the "rules" exactly.   I am guilty of that - my shadow weave designs don't follow the rules for the turn in the draft.   I don't care - I work it out in the software, and if I like how it looks and there aren't too many floats, I go for it.

And while I'm thinking, maybe there is a book out there that lists the rules for the types of drafts, and we could just use that.   I don't know of a single book that has them "all" but would love to find one if it exists!

 

kerstinfroberg

can be done in so many ways - what *exactly* is a "twill", compared to a "twill variation"? (For all that, perhaps a few pre-set possibilities are nice, incl "other")

I will probably contradict myself with this post, but anyway:

I do not think "verifying" is good - isn't it better to encourage posting, even with the risk of misinformation, than to make ppl think "I'm probably not good enough"?

I do think #of shafts/treadles (incl "no shafts", "no treadles", "pickup", "dobby" - and probably more) is good, but that info is already there.

However, what exactly are "tags", on this site? It seems that the same cloud is used for both projects and drafts (and yarns?), which is not very helpful. (At the moment) I think there should be separate clouds for projects, drafts (and yarns). Also, I don't really believe that there are only 30 tags entered - but that is what I get when clicking on "more tags". (That is: I *know* there are tags added that do not show when I click "more tags")

It would be nice to be able to combine tags in a, what to call it, "tag search" perhaps - using the usual "search" box (advanced search, too) tags are not an option. So what purpose do the tags fulfil?

jj50 (not verified)

I haven't posted anything in the section and searched it only once. I name my drafts based on the first level - weave structure, Plain Weave, Twill or Satin, sometimes use Lace or Overshot, Shadow Weave, and so on as a primary 1st category, then by number of shafts, then a personal name or attribution. I don't know if you can make 2 or 3 levels of dropdown menu choices for uniformity.

pammersw

I think I will name my first draft George!   ;)

Seriously,  as a newby, drop down menus work for me.

Bonnie Inouye (not verified)

Many of the drafts on handweaving.net have an indicated structure but some are not correct. For example, the most recent draft posted here comes directly from that website and it does not follow the rules given for crackle. It is one made by Ralph G, not a weaver but a valuable person for the weaving community. He made a lot of drafts that include bits of crackle (those little points) along with other bits, some of which cause longer floats than crackle should have. But it did not matter to him. I don't think he expected people to take his drafts and weave them without studying crackle or checking floats, etc, first.

Many projects posted here are mislabeled, too. I don't think people come to Weavolution to learn about structures except when they sign up for a class, or maybe if they ask for advice regarding a good book or article to read about a particular structure.

Bonnie Inouye

debmcclintock

I had to go back and look at the drafts I've posted to see how I labeled them.  Since there is not a structure convention one comes up with a name.  I seem to have tried to put the structure in the name (for future search purposes) but also had a project related flow within the name.  Either a project or I was answering a question and a draft seemed the best way to illustrate a point.  

Normally I connect a draft to a project that I have posted.  One cannot link a draft back to the project.  For instance, unless I took time to link within the text descrip you would have no idea where I used that draft.  It would be nice to have a link from draft back to project.  A link exists from project to draft but not in the reverse.

I agree that many beginners don't know the naming convention or have a good grasp on structure (I still struggle sometime).  A drop down menu might be nice but someone would have to manage it.  I think it is weaver beware when it comes to drafts.

Another upgrade would be to be able to upload liftplans.  I haven't tried lately.  I used to just upload a file and note it in the description, however, since the draft function doesn't seem to be used much I haven't loaded anything lately.  Good luck with your effort.

debmcclintock

ah, and I forgot, I asked a long time ago about tags.  I never received an answer.  I am almost 60 and left the workforce before "tags" came into use.  How would tags clouds be used.  Sorry, tags were not in my work era! Kristin brought up some good questions up above in comment #12.

Submitted by Erica on