Hi,

I'm in the market for a 16 shaft loom. At college I used several different types of looms and right now I've got a self built 45" 8 shaft, but I'm having so many lamm problems that it's essentially a 4 shaft.  In any case, a kind relative is offering to help me buy a new loom and I want to make sure I get something that I'm going to use for a long time.  I've been looking at various manufacturers and I seem to be divided between computerized and non computerized options.  I have concerns about both. 

Computerized:

How expensive is it to run and maintain?  I work with computers all day and seeing that we end up replacing them every 6 or 7 years, how long do the computer components of looms last?  Also, I've not really gotten a chance to use a computerized loom and am not sure I'd like it.

 

Non Computerized:

Do I seriously limit my design options by having a set number of treddles?  I'm also concerned about being able to reach my legs to the outer treddles.  I don't really make pieces beyond 36" wide so reaching far with my arms isn't too much of an issue. 

I also noticed that Gilmakra offers a drawloom attachment, does anyone have any experience using one, or know where I can find more information about it?  My other concern is that I'm not settled so this loom will definitely be moved at some point.  This is another reason I'm finding myself drawn to the scandinavian countermarchs, cause I they're designed to flat pack perhaps more easily than say an AVL.

Any advice or insights would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance,

Rebecca

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 1. If you're looking for in depth information comparing use of multi-shaft looms vs. drawloom, contact me privately.

2. There is a significant advantage using a computer assisted dobby loom. More than 12 treadles become uncomfortable to use and already with 16 shafts, you have 256 treadle variations that can be programmed all at once to give you rich patterning. Mechanical dobbies do exist but there are two serious disadvantages - the lags need precision and are expensive, and you cannot easily store patterns because when you're finished, you need to repeg the lags to get your new pattern set up.

The computer assisted dobbies can easily run on very old, simple computers as the interface is not as complex as the software used for design - my unit has an old Dell laptop that is worth less than a replacement battery , but it drives the loom accurately.

3. You CAN marry the simplicity of a Scandinavian loom and a computer assisted multi-shaft loom if you look at the Toika unit instead of just AVL. They come up to 32 shafts, are accurate to a fault, easy to operate and have no turnbuckles, cables, springs, or other trappings. Most people who look at mine are disappointed because it looks just like it did before the conversion - except for the missing treadles. BUT it weaves complex fabrics with all the advantages of a countermarche loom. It runs on gravity for the lower shed, so rugs are probably not an option, though fine linen warps do just fine.

Joanne Hall

Hi Rebecca,

Although you may not have settled on the type of weaving you want to do, you might ask yourself if you will be a production weaver producing many yards of the same fabric, or if you will be weaving one of a kind things to frame or hang on the wall.  The computerized loom is good for production of yardage, but a drawloom is better for images and one of a kind pieces.

I recently saw Kay Faulkner's website with some of her work and it was really nice.  Also try to find the work of kathie Roig.  I think that she has an itsy site.  I don't have the links for these, but try finding websites where you can see what weavers are doing with their computerized looms and their drawlooms.

Joanne

Sara von Tresckow

 While the 16 or 24 shaft loom will not create as much detailed imagery as the drawloom, a simple "production" look at a dobby is not at all accurate. Since purchasing mine, I find I'm doing MANY more short warps with unusual effects than ever before. Since the loom doesn't take that long to warp, short runs of fabric are quite easy to do - interspersed with longer warps for multiple items.

There are a lot of applications of using a dobby head that are rarely touched by handweavers - I've looked at mill settings and started doing things vastly other than block designs and find that the range of "fashion fabrics" possible is mind boggling.

That said, I also do small yardages on the drawloom because the type of patterning suits that loom better.

 

weaversouth (not verified)

have a look at the AVL site (avlusa.com) and check out the reconditioned looms.  You can save quite a bit.  You really don't want to be trying to treadle 16 shafts, trust me.  Anything involving "weaver-controlled," like drawlooms, is going to slow you down a bit.  I know there are a few folks who wouldn't have anything else, but, if you are interested in producing with any efficiency, you need to options offered by loom-controlled weaves and I would suggest a computer-dobby loom.  Some kind of lift-assist is a good thing.  Macomber make excellent dobby systems.  I've seen the Leclercs, but wasn't terribly impressed at "Convergence."

Lot's of good info on Macombers as well as the official sales rep here: http://macomberloomsandme.blogspot.com/

Nancy C.

Sara von Tresckow

FYI, I recently completed a major project using both the drawloom and the dobby - It is listed in my profile as "Heirloom Tablecloth" with a black and white graphic.

Basically I designed a tablecloth and napkin set to match our good china. The tablecloth has motif placement that necessitates the drawloom, but the napkins had a simpler configuration. Since I wanted the drawloom for another project, I changed the basic structure from a 5-end satin to a 4-end broken twill and wove them on the dobby. Both looms stand side by side in the same room - it was quite satisfying to see both yardages take shape at the same time.

 

weaver85 (not verified)

Thank you all so much for your advice :)

It's definitely given me a lot to think about.  I'm going to go down to Webs sometime next week and try out one of the computerized toikas to see how I like it and keep deliberating from there.

 

Joanne Hall

Hi,  If you write to me, joanne at glimakrausa.com, maybe I know someone in your area who has a drawloom.  Joanne

lkautio (not verified)

For 16S, I'd definitely go computerized.  It gives you so many more design options than treadle controlled, and much simpler and faster to change on the run than mechanical dobbies.  I miss the treadle dance, but have a small 4S and 8S when I need to do it.

Toikas are a nice loom and seem more trouble free than many others.  There are a number of Weavebirds near Webs, also.  We might be able to find one you could try out (I have one but will be out much of next week) when you are up this way.  They have a countermarch action, are counterweighted so the treadling is much lighter and more balanced on the body than the AVL, no noisy compressor, have metal heddles (a plus in my book, though not everyone's), feel like a regular treadle loom, and are much cheaper than the other computer controlled looms.  Let me know if you are interested in trying one and I will arrange it for you.

I run my 32S off an ancient pc, and if it dies, I get another ancient pc to replace it.  There's little or no computer upkeep costs associated with any of the computer looms.  There are people who have been using the same computer equipment (particularly on AVLs and Macs which have been around a long time) for many years - longer than you would keep the average pc or mac by far.

Laurie Autio

weaversouth (not verified)

I should like to point out that the AVL's have an "e-lift" as an option, so you are NOT stuck with the noisy compressors.  Ultimately, you need to find a loom with which you are comfortable.

Nancy C

dteaj (not verified)

If you are going "down" to Webs, you might want to check out Vavstuga in Shelbourne Falls, MA for Glimakra looms. They may have a drawloom all set up to try out.

KMR Handwoven (not verified)

Just joined weavolution! and this post was the very top one after I registered...good karma?! Thanks Joanne for thinking of me and my drawloom.

I do have an Etsy site www.kmrhandwoven.etsy.com you can see some of what I do on my drawloom. BUT...

I have a brand new web site www.kmrhandwoven.com where you can see just about everything that I have done on my drawloom. I've had mine for almost 20 years. I have moved it around a fair amount, from various studios to home...I even moved it to the Cleveland Museum of Art several (many) years ago for a demo. It does come apart and although it takes some time...it is easy to move the parts.  I might also add that by assembling and disassembling the loom you really get to "know" it!

That my help...also feel free to contact me privately if you'd like more details or have any questions!

Kathie Roig

 

Joanne Hall

Welcome Kathie,

It is nice to see you here.  And I will go to spend some time on your website. 

I too have taken my drawloom for demonstrations, but only two times to West coast weaving conferences.  It took about 1 hour 15 minutes from carrying the parts into the space to weaving on the warp.  As you said, it is a good way to become very familiar with your loom.

Joanne

CherylfromCreemore (not verified)

Hi Rebecca

I have a 16 shaft AVL 48" with Compudobby II and and ELift with lots of stuff that I'm getting ready to put on the market.  I'm not sure where you are -- I'm in Ontario.

I'm certainly prepared to sell it for a better price than AVL sells their reconditioned looms.  It has been my favourite of the many looms I have owned and used.  Ongoing health issues are my reason for giving up this really wonderful piece of equipment.

I'd be very happy to discuss loom pros and cons if you'd like to contact me.

 

Cheryl

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on