Hello everyone!

I plan to build my own simple loom with my father-in-law. I have some woodworking experience, he has much more. I have two main questions:

1: What wood to use. Conventional wisdom is tight grained wood. All of my current equipment is Cherry, which I love, BUT--he has ash he's willing to give me for free. Obviously this is nice compared to the $$$ I'd have to spend on Cherry lumber. Is an open grained wood that big of a deal? Either way, I might go with Cherry because I love it so much more, and it will match everything else.

2: I'm not sure what size timbers to use. See the included picture. I plan on upsizing this loom to handle at least a 4' x 6' rug. I might even build one that can handle an 8' x 10'. (Keep in mind, if you don't already know, that the warp can rotate around the loom, so the height of the loom need not be as tall as the product.) If I can get away with 2" stock rather than 3" stock, this saves a lot of money, but at the 8' x 10' size especially, I don't want to build a loom I can't use!

(BONUS QUESTION) Finally, looking at this loom, can you see anything I should include, alter, etc? I've only used floor looms, so I'm not sure what to look for.

(SECOND BONUS QUESTION) I'm not sure I can get a dowel long enough for the loom. (For the tie rod and heddle stick) Is there anything wrong with using a square piece for a loom like this?

Loom Plans

Thanks for all your help!

TA

Comments

jander14indoor (not verified)

The main benefit of tight vs open grain wood is that it takes less finishing to make it snag free.  You can sand smooth and apply a simple oil finish to maple and have little risk of snags.  Not so with something like Ash. 

Now, if you don't mind a fairly "thick" finish, you can prevent snags with that open grain wood.  Sand, fill the grain with an appropriate product, sand again till you get a feel like maple.  Then apply a HARD top coat to prevent wear.  Polyurethane or Bar Top finish.  I doubt oil would hold up well enough to keep the grain filler in place.

You can do this so the grain is still evident, but so will the finish be.  The wood will look like it is encased in plastic.  It does not have to be a thick finish like you see in bars and restaurants, but it won't be almost invisible like a nice oil finish.  Up to your taste if that is acceptable or not.  I prefer minimal finishes most times, but there are occasions where that just is NOT appropriate,  And that's OK.

I've never done a cost comparison but I'd think free vs Cherry prices would buy a LOT of finishing materials.

Wood sizes.  You'll most probably have to upsize the wood significantly if you increase the loom size.  And one-to-one is not a good assumption.  Do you have access to a free mechanical engineer (or second best, any engineer who's taken mechanical stress courses, most metallurgists can handle this problem for example)?  If yes, they can make good estimates by calculating the beam bending characteristics of the existing design and then figure out how large a wood cross section is needed with a larger loom to maintain similar stresses/strains.  There are nice web based utilities now a days to do this quickly, but you need some knowledge of how to use them properly.

No comment on the first bonus question, no tapestry experience.

Second bonus, why not.  My floor loom uses rounded rectangular tie on bars.  In fact, for the tie rod, that might be better.  If you orient the rectangle so the long side is in the direction of the warp it will be stronger pound for pound than a square or round bar.  I'd round the edges generously.  At least a 1/4 inch radius roundover bit in a router will make short work of that task.

 

Have fun,

Jeff Anderson

Livonia, MI

sandra.eberhar…

If your intent is to build an upright loom for weft faced work, you might contact the guy who build the Navaho style frame loom.  The heddle stick could certainly be square, not sure what the tie rod is.  If it's the tie on rod, that could be square too.  I have looms with square maple tie on rods.  I would look at existing vertical looms like Leclerc Tissart or Glimakra's Regina to get an idea of what size lumber you need.  I had a big Navaho style loom that worked very well and used 2x6 yellow pine; it could make an 8x10 rug.

ReedGuy

And southern yellow pine is a denser hard pine than northern pines. It has to be kilned properlly to set the pitch, like with any pine. Or some finishes will end up with pine resin coming through.

Birch is another option, and there are some lesser species of hardwood that are close grained that I am unfamiliar with their working properties. For instance Sycamore, or beech. We have beech in my area, but it's too severely diseased to be anything more than firewood or pulp wood. They did prefer it for bowling pins at one time, and we had a bowling pin factory here a few years ago.

Submitted by TortoiseAvenger on