I spent the last 2 months working on this rug for my friend for her wedding gift.  I got the weaving technique from Peter Collingwood's book.  I had some problems with my loom early on, but then fixed them.  But now that I have it off the loom I see that the problem created "static" in the pattern. (see bottom left square in photo)

 

Also, the pattern just appears too small to really look interesting.  In the photo, the rug looks better than it does in real life.  The digital photo seems to make the 3D effect I was going for pop more than in real life. 

 

What should I do with the rug?  It seems like such a waste.  Could I dye it to make it more interesting?  I've never dyed wool.  Should I unweave it to salvage the yarn?  So, sad to have blood, sweat, and tears in this thing and it not work out.  Maybe I just need to accept the failure, and remember to make a sample next time?

Comments

Kade1301

What exactly is wrong with the pattern? i don't see the problem... I would probably finish and use the rug. The only thing I don't like on the picture - but that's just my taste - is the red yarn on the wooden floor.

thelmaweaves

Finish it off and use it.  I like the design, it's an optical illusion.

Sharon

 

maurak

Heather, This is a lovely rug. Sometimes we are our worst critics; you may have imagined a different outcome, but no one else did! So finish it and enjoy gifting it as intended.

Maura

 

 

 

celtinbirks

I like it and would gladly use it in my house.  The people you made it for won't know how it was "supposed" to turn out.  Go ahead and give it and be proud that all your hard work really looks nice even though it didn't look like you originally intended.

Candace

JacRoyce

I would be thrilled if my friend made such a nice present for me. She'll treasure it.

Jac

rlmarchand (not verified)

Heather,

I made a scarf for my sister-in-law for her birthday.  There was a blaring error in it.  My 15 year old, overly critical, artistic daughter admired it.  When I showed her my mistakes, she rolled her eyes and said it was a homemade gift and that no one else would notice the error and even if they did, they would still love it because I had made it.  She told me I was being overly critical about my work. 

Your rug is beautiful.  Be proud of it and use it or give it as a gift.

Shelley

 

Kelly Range

  You can send it to me. I am trying to learn weft face designed rugs.

If you have ever gone into a new house with fancy trim, I bet the carpenter could point out evry "mistake" he made. 

Good job!

 

Alaire Rieffel (not verified)

I always HATE things I have woven when I take them off the loom.  Really sick of looking at them. Recently I visited my sister and saw a gorgeous rag rug in her bathroom.  Asked her where she bought it (feeling a little hurt she had bought it from someone else) and she replied "You gave it to me!"  So--weaving always looks better if you think someone else is the weaver.  Try putting your rug away for a while--you'll be amazed how fast rugs improve when hidden in a dark closet!

calebsb

It looks quite acceptable to me.  Not sure what you mean by static.  Do you mean a slack area that makes the pattern look freaky due to tension issues?  If so, and if it really bothers you, it is possible to remove or reduce such areas by pulling the slack down the warp ends an inch or so at a time, but it's a lot of work and not very rewarding.  I have only done it in extreme cases.  From what I can see there are no eyesores in that picture.  No one is going to scrutinize it in detail, and if they do it will just show what fussy work it is and how much time and care were involved.  I only wish I could have managed to get a project like that together in time for anyone's wedding.

apw1970 (not verified)

We as weavers are always hard on ourselves.  Use the rug!  Give it as a present!  And celebrate that you got it done.

Submitted by Heather26 on