On smaller items, like placemeatts and scarves, I've not found selveges a huge theme, using a floating selvege seems to help, as well.  However, on larger items, such as a blanket or rug, I am finding this more difficult.  Of course I can sew on a trim or crochet and edge, but I was wondering what hints (other than lots of practice) one could give, to help maintain a nice even selvedge, when you have to manually throw the shuttle longer distances.  One that is presentable.  I made myself a spanner bar with some nails through a frame slat, which certainly helps generally.  Maybe I just need more practive throwing for such large objects.

cheers,

Jamie

Comments

pammersw

My instructor said to leave an arch in the yarn or have it be at an angle before you beat it, so there is enough there for the take up. I haven't done anything wider than a foot, though.

laurafry

You might find the videos I've posted to You Tube helpful - look for user lauraannfry1

Holding, throwing, catching the shuttle and beating takes some practice, especially for wider widths.

cheers,

Laura

gartenweber

Joanne,  I made one to help maintain the width and have a, what looks like a good variable one, on order from my local wool supplier. 

JPMorabito

You have to let yourself get a feel for it. After awhile, the way you throw the shuttle will be uniform and will create an even selvedge. 

Angle-ing the fill or using filling yarns of similar weights will help. As will the manner in which you beat and change sheds. There are a number of techniques that different weavers use, but ultimately you will just have to find a method that works for you. 

sequel (not verified)

If using boat shuttles on a wide web, I usually beat,  and with the beater still at the fell of the cloth I extend my shuttle arm out somewhat so that a little extra weft unspools before changing the shed and pushing the beater away and throwing the shuttle.  This postpones the inevitable braking of the bobbin as it "slams" against the inside of the bobbin cavity in the shuttle, thus delaying the jerking of the weft at the selvedge edge.

Joanne Hall

Are you using plastic bobbins?  I find that your method is common among those who use bobbins, as they create more drag on the yarn, and more draw-in.  Try quills some time.  They don't give you that much drag, and you then do not have to move you hand out away from the warp before you throw the shuttle.  Then you can eliminate that extra movement.

Joanne

Dawn McCarthy

I agree with Joanne, how I love my quills, I gave away most of my plastic bobbins and encourage my students to try both.  I also love my EFS 

Dawn

bewove.com

sally orgren

I too love my EFS. Another thing about bobbins or pirns, they work much better if wound tight, not mushy. I use a piece of leather when winding to protect my fingers, and I have a hand crank winder.

sandra.eberhar…

I have found using an EFS and a temple make my selvedges much better with less effort.

MMs-and-OOs-Ha…

Good selvedges seem to happen when lots of little things are adjusted and then voila! Certainly it starts as Laura suggests from consistent handling of the shuttle. End-feed shuttles with properly wound pirns help. When you advance the woven fabric frequently and keep the fell line in the same place two things happen, you keep the amount of weft you are placing consistent and the tension on the selvedge warps gets to even out. I move my cloth at least every inch depending on how fine a warp I weave. I've noticed that some weavers almost unconsciously "adjust" the weft after each shot. This is harder to do on a wider piece. Selvedges that weave well for a few inches and the suddenly "collapse" are indicative of inconsistent beaming. For a properly packed beam, you can use sticks, etc., I don't. It can help. On Peggy Ostercamp's site there is info on how to fold Kraft paper to prevent beam cigars. I either beam sectionally or beam on the plain beam with heads. A basketweave selvedge fixes most problems. On the dobby loom you sacrifice four harnesses for it. I know there is a way to set it up on a treadle loom. I saw a draft or directions for that around here somewhere. I don't use a temple, packing, and I don't use floating selvedges, too slow.

Weavingholiday

Still crawling toward consistently good selvedges myself, but Laura's videos are great, and very much believe that it is so true that a bunch of things have to come together, and that practice and experience are the answer (eventually).

Wondering if, when you are making blankets, in addition to the extra distance you are throwing the shuttle, are you using different yarn, sett, etc.?

So many variables...

Weavingholiday

Still crawling toward consistently good selvedges myself, but Laura's videos are great, and very much believe that it is so true that a bunch of things have to come together, and that practice and experience are the answer (eventually).

Wondering if, when you are making blankets, in addition to the extra distance you are throwing the shuttle, are you using different yarn, sett, etc.?

So many variables...

gartenweber

Dawn, Joanne,

I am using quills.  They simply suite me better although I find you cannot wind as much yarn on to them.  Apparently bobbins are popular in the UK, but I've not seen them offered in Germany.  Paper quills seem to be the norm.  There is something about the simplicity of the quill that I find very appealing.  And they work, are inexpensive and, even if you step on 'em, they don't really break (gives you an idea how organised I am!)

 

Jamie

gartenweber

This is what I suspected, it is getting the rhythm right.  As my loom is but 100cm, I find it too short to add a fly shuttle and a bit too long to confortably hand throw consistently.  I took of part of the warm to reduce to 80cm, which I can better handle.  I, also, found a great reference to a cardboard fly shuttle affair that I may try, as the simple application may be great for dealing with wider projects.

 

Yeah, the angle of the weft, beating, etc. are all items I learned on scarves, but they were with linen and cotton.  With wool, it feel I need to relearn the whole affair.  I don't really like the wool packed as hard and beat with an open shed lightly, then change the shed and throw the next.  It will be interesting to see how this all changes after the first contact with water!

thanks,

Jamie

gartenweber

I have to agree, Laura's videos are an amazing help.  Simple and direct, I can really see what needs to be understood.  Laura, if you read this, a huge thanks and a hug from a stranger!

 

Jamie

ReedGuy

Depends on what your weaving with the wool. If it's upholstery it has to be firm and not airy or it will wear out, ball up and frazzle quicker. I have a commercial made arm chair here that I think is made with cotton upholstery, that stuff is all balling up on the arms. Can't buy good furniture these days, too many corners are cut to keep it cheap. I had to replace a side piece on it that was particle board, the handle was held by heavy screws in it, they pulled out of course. I made a piece from white ash to replace it, it's a dense wood with lustre like glass when planed. Those screws aren't going to pull through that, no how. ;) That was a modern chair, most of my furniture I built or it was built back when quality meant something. :)

laurafry

You are quite welcome.  I really feel for people who are struggling so I posted the video clips in hopes that they would make things a bit easier.

Everyone has to discover what works 'best' for them and their equipment.  The videos are just an introduction.  Keep working with an analytical purpose, trying this and that to see what works for you.

Not all looms are built 'equally', neither are weavers.

cheers,

Laura

gartenweber

Just a note to say that practice is making the master!  I just posted some of the two projects I was doing for X-Mas presents and you can see my selvedges have improves.  Interesting was to observe the many items suggested and see what was influencing what.  With cracle, which is, of course, a twill, the width did tend to vary according to the treadling pattern.  Some blocks are bulkier than others.  Forewarding the warp more often does improve the eveness.

 

It has been great just having time over the holidays (between meals of considerable size, mind you!).  Tomorrow it's back to work.  I'm starting another question thread on long warps.  Just 5m is not enough!

 

Happy 2014!

 

Jamie

sandra.eberhar…

I weave a lot of twills, and that is why I use floating selvedges.  I add them the warp as I reel the warp, and weight them behind the beam with s-hooks so I don't have to adjust the weights as the warp advances.  Some people use basket weave selvedges on the edges of twill pieces to avoid what you are seeing (the weft doesn't always catch the outside warp), but I don't want to give up the shafts to to do this.  Some people figure out the threading so that the outside edge is always caught, but I'm too lazy to do this.  

Sara von Tresckow

"too lazy to figure out the threading" - FYI - on a straight twill, if the outside edge doesn't catch on one side, all you need to do is break your weft yarn and start throwing your treadling sequence from the opposite side of the loom.

gartenweber

BWSD, I am using a floating selvedge.  That I learned quickly and it is a cool way to add a dark/light contrast at the edge. 

 

Sara, thanks for mentioning this.  I wasn't sure, but did notice this doing a classic 2/2 batavia twill plaid, where I was constantly changing colours.  As I am doing mainly crackle at the moment, I find the floating selvedge gives me the freedom to suddenly change my treadling and experiment.

 

Weaving is a very satisfiing experience.

 

thanks, J.

ReedGuy

If you don't want denser selvedges (caused by draw in) you can sley the reed on the edges at a lighter set, but make sure if using finer yarns that the outside dent is at least doubled because of wear. And use a temple to ease this. The recent blanket I wove was heavy wool, so I did not worry about wear. I also advanced the warp quite often. When the piece was wet finished the edge threads were not crowded from draw in and the cloth was evenly figured between the selvedges and the body of the cloth. I still am at odds figuring how to splice where weft is joined between pirns or bobbins in the weave. I have been following techniques in the literature, but it sure isn't perfect. To the untrained eye it doesn't amount to anything, but to the weaver it's a stick in the eye. :)

Sara von Tresckow

While on the topic of selvedges - they should not be tighter or significantly looser than the body of the cloth. If the selvedge threads are under greated tension while weaving, they can make the cloth pucker of not stay on grain when off the loom - the fabric will press to a u-shape on both ends as the fabric in the center is actually a bit longer than that on the edges. A little looser is better than too tight.

Erica J

It's not difficult, as Sara says you can treadle from the opposite end. I for one prefer to start on certain treadles when the shuttle is in a particular hand. 

However "figuring out" the threadin is not difficult. Simply start on shat 2. This was a mystery to me as well, until I read the recent Twills Anatomy article in Handwoven. Nov/Dec 13 I think. If your threading starts on 2 and you treadle 1-2, 2-3, 3-4, 1-4 and are right handed your weft goes from right to left on every other treadle, so 1-2, 3-4 so shaft 2 is up for the first and down for the second. It is the same when the weft travels the other direction, therefore catching the warp thread.

If nothing else just remember to start on two and it will click in the first dozen picks! I promise! :)

Submitted by gartenweber on