If you could recommend one book only, which of these books would be the better choice? and why?

Kirsten Glasbrook -  Tapestry Weaving

Nancy Harvey - Tapestry Weaving

Carol C Russell - Tapestry Handbook, the Next Generation (Revised Edition 2007)

I realise all books have their strengths and weaknesses, and your opinions are subjective, but when books cost as much as they cost here in Australia, one has to be absolutely sure that the chosen book is suitable, otherwise its an expensive mistake, and it costs nearly as much again to return that "mistake" to Amazon!

A book like this has to be purchased sight-unseen. Its not the sort of thing even our largest booksellers stock in the normal way of things and the library system cannot be relied upon to stock weaving books any more.

Thank you for your help.

Comments

runamuckweaving

 Caroline,

There is another book that should be on that list if you are looking at it from a beginning weaving perspective.

Tapestry 101 by Kathe Todd-Hooker. I have two of those books, the Russell book and the Harvey book.

Both cover techniques and have beautiful inspiring example, but since I have not had a chance to actually "use" them as a learning tool, I really can't comment which is better. 

tommye scanlin

 Caroline,

I've been weaving tapestry for 20 years, have all of the books you're asking about (and several more) and also teach tapestry.  The comments I'm making are based on that experience--but my personal opinion always plays a part of anything I might say--so please keep that in mind!

First, I'd ask about the books you mention is to inquire for what purpose do you want to use the book?  If for good, meaty, accurate information about tapestry techinque the Tapestry 101 by Kathe Todd-Hooker that was mentioned by "runamuck..." is, in my opinion, the best choice.  If you want to be inspired by beautiful tapestries--the Russell book is filled with them.

Kristen Glasbrook's book is visually nice, illustrated with her own tapestries (which are charming).  Technically, OK for beginning but lots of more in-depth information is not to be found there.

Nancy Harvey's book has pretty good technical information, clear diagrams, and is illustrated with many tapestry examples, her own and of many other tapestry makers.  Nancy Harvey has also produced several video/DVDs about tapestry making and those might be of interest to you.

Carol Russell's new version of The Tapestry Handbook has, of the three books you asked about, the best illustrations of contemporary tapestry--lots of beautiful tapestries selected and shown in great color.  She also has an extensive sampler with photos to accompany.  However, I found her first edition of the Tapestry Handbook to have better quality photos accompanying her "lessons" in the sampler.  The new edition does not have an index and thus makes it a bit challenging to quickly find the reference to something.

All this being said... if I were picking one and I was totally beginning I'd  maybe go with the Russell book, especially if I wanted to have beautiful tapestry examples included to inspire me.  BUT, if I were wanting very good and thorough information about tapestry technique and variations possible I'd go with Kathe Todd-Hooker's book (in spite of the lack of good tapestry examples shown).

I'll also mention that the American Tapestry Alliance website (http://americantapestryalliance.org), the British Tapestry Group, the European Tapestry Network, the Canadian Tapestry Network, the Victorian Tapestry Workshop website -- and many, many more -- are all great places on the web to find examples of beautiful and exciting tapestries being done all over the world today!  ATA and British Tapestry Group have memberships open to anyone around the world, as well.

Good luck with your tapestry journey--it is indeed a fine one to travel on!

Tommye Scanlin

 

Caroline (not verified)

Thank you for your responses. I'm not a total beginner ( just nearly) and have a chance to purchase the first edition of the Russell book at a reasonable price here in Australia. I already have Kathe Todd-Hooker's Shaped Tapestry book, which is very interesting and has a lot of information packed into such a small volume, so the recommendation for her Tapestry 101 is very welcome. While I like eye candy, and who doesn't, I also like my books to be good reference books as well, so I will probably end up buying the Russell book now, and putting an order in for Tapestry 101 in the new year. That way I can have my cake and eat it too, lol!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on